Top-rated fence painters.

Get matched with top fence painters in Shelbyville, IL

Enter your ZIP and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your fence painting project in Shelbyville, IL?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY SHELBYVILLE, IL HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.4
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon49
    Verified fence painting services reviews

Verified Reviews for Fence Painting pros in Shelbyville, IL

*The Angi rating for Fence Painting companies in Shelbyville, IL is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Fence Painting needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Fence Painting companies in Shelbyville, IL is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Fence Painting needs.

Last update on October 23, 2025

Find Fence painters in Shelbyville

CI Fencing

No reviews yet

CI Fencing

No reviews yet
2 years of experience

Here at CI Fencing, we offer you the best fence on the block! We are a 2 man team, and we have been fencing together since 2020 through other businesses. We have finally decided that we want to branch out and start our own company. If you call us, we will give you a free estimate, or meet with you in person to meet your needs efficiently.

Here at CI Fencing, we offer you the best fence on the block! We are a 2 man team, and we have been fencing together since 2020 through other businesses. We have finally decided that we want to branch out and start our own company. If you call us, we will give you a free estimate, or meet with you in person to meet your needs efficiently.

Erickson Handyman Service

No reviews yet

Erickson Handyman Service

No reviews yet
Emergency services offered

We are a small handyman service headquartered in Shelbyville, Illinois. Our service area extends to Effingham, Mattoon, Pana, Ramsey, and more. We do both interior and exterior work, including tree trimming, cleanup, pressure washing, painting, drywalling, trim, cabinetry, small remodels, and more.

We are a small handyman service headquartered in Shelbyville, Illinois. Our service area extends to Effingham, Mattoon, Pana, Ramsey, and more. We do both interior and exterior work, including tree trimming, cleanup, pressure washing, painting, drywalling, trim, cabinetry, small remodels, and more.

Renewable Mowing & Landscape

No reviews yet

Renewable Mowing & Landscape

No reviews yet
Free onsite estimate

We are certified in Horticulture Production as well as Landscape and Design. We provide many services such as mowing, weed eating, blow off, debris clean up, tree and shrub trim or removal, installing or fixing fencing, pressure washing, landscape design, rock and mulch beds, and more. We offer competitive prices and guarantee the lowest prices around. We take great pride in our work and customer satisfaction is our number one priority.

We are certified in Horticulture Production as well as Landscape and Design. We provide many services such as mowing, weed eating, blow off, debris clean up, tree and shrub trim or removal, installing or fixing fencing, pressure washing, landscape design, rock and mulch beds, and more. We offer competitive prices and guarantee the lowest prices around. We take great pride in our work and customer satisfaction is our number one priority.

Avatar for Josh Wallis Roofing & General Construction

Josh Wallis Roofing & General Construction

423 N Chestnut St
1.00(
1
)

Josh Wallis Roofing & General Construction

423 N Chestnut St
1.00(
1
)
19 years of experience

Call cause we do it all..! 10% off all asphalt roofs through June.. 5% off all treated decks.!

"no-show, no call, two days in a row."

Joi O on April 2022

Call cause we do it all..! 10% off all asphalt roofs through June.. 5% off all treated decks.!

"no-show, no call, two days in a row."

Joi O on April 2022

Cedar Mill Fence Company

1805 Ashley Road
1.00(
2
)

Cedar Mill Fence Company

1805 Ashley Road
1.00(
2
)
50 years of experience

The Cedar Mill Fence Company designs and builds custom cedar, aluminum and vinyl fences. We are one of Chicagoland’s oldest direct-mill outlets and we use skilled, professional full-time employees not sub-contractors. We offer full 5x5 posts, fully turned posts, and professional pre-staining.

"I should have checked all these reviews before engaging them. Overall fencing was good but I was charged for branch removal from a tree even though their estimator told me that they will take care of everything. Moreover, they had cut two of my sprinkler pipes and did not even inform me about it. My garden was flooded in the morning as I had my sprinkler to run every day early in the morning. All that I was asking was to reimburse $200 paid to their crew to remove the branches but no they would not. So watch out for all the hooks and hidden costs. Not ethical"

Jeyanth J on August 2021

The Cedar Mill Fence Company designs and builds custom cedar, aluminum and vinyl fences. We are one of Chicagoland’s oldest direct-mill outlets and we use skilled, professional full-time employees not sub-contractors. We offer full 5x5 posts, fully turned posts, and professional pre-staining.

"I should have checked all these reviews before engaging them. Overall fencing was good but I was charged for branch removal from a tree even though their estimator told me that they will take care of everything. Moreover, they had cut two of my sprinkler pipes and did not even inform me about it. My garden was flooded in the morning as I had my sprinkler to run every day early in the morning. All that I was asking was to reimburse $200 paid to their crew to remove the branches but no they would not. So watch out for all the hooks and hidden costs. Not ethical"

Jeyanth J on August 2021

Harry the Handyman

2239 E. 1900 N. Rd.
1.00(
1
)

Harry the Handyman

2239 E. 1900 N. Rd.
1.00(
1
)
Customers say: Quick response
24 years of experience

I'm a sole proprietor. On very rare occasion, I may need to sub-contract a portion of your repairs. I'm centrally located along the shores of Lake Shelbyville, my shop is just SE of Findlay. Generally, we will discuss payment. It largely depends on the scope of the project. You and I will sit down and discuss completion goals, and if a large project, payment may be required in measurable and pre approved stages.

I'm a sole proprietor. On very rare occasion, I may need to sub-contract a portion of your repairs. I'm centrally located along the shores of Lake Shelbyville, my shop is just SE of Findlay. Generally, we will discuss payment. It largely depends on the scope of the project. You and I will sit down and discuss completion goals, and if a large project, payment may be required in measurable and pre approved stages.

...
Showing 1-10 of 99
Fence Painting questions, answered by experts

On most untreated wood fences, there is no need to sand before treating. You typically only need to sand if there’s an old coat of paint or stain on your fence. If you do need to sand off a previous paint or protective coating (like an old stain or sealant), use medium-grit sandpaper.

The general consensus is that two coats of stain are required and since the cedar is siding, a third coat of sealant is always a good idea. This helps protect the wood and stain, so you won’t need to resand and restain for at least a decade. Each stain after the first will darken the wood, so be aware of that when choosing a colored stain.

The number of coats you need to apply when whitewashing a surface depends on how opaque you want the final product to be. If you're going for a transparent, barely there look, a single coat or two may suffice. For fuller coverage, you'll want to use multiple coats. Another option is to use a less diluted paint to get a thicker coverage. 

To prevent a fence from becoming dirty, hose it down weekly and after every time you mow the lawn. This will prevent algae from being able to feed on grass clippings. You should also wash your fence once per season and trim plants so they don’t touch it. As a precautionary measure, you can treat your fence with a coating of a mold prevention product.

Late spring or early summer is usually the best time to stain a fence. Pick your timing carefully and aim to start your DIY when you see a forecast that shows no rain and low humidity levels for at least a few days. If it’s too hot (like in the middle of summer), the stain will dry out too quickly. If it’s too cold (like in the winter and early spring), the stain might not be able to fully dry.

The Shelbyville, IL homeowners’ guide to fence painting services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles