Will a DIY Basement Remodel Save Money?

Angie Hicks
Written by Angie Hicks
Updated October 13, 2016
Will your basement require new plumbing and water lines? Best to leave that to the pros. (Photo by Kelly Kazmierczak)

Weigh risks, rewards before acting as general contractor on a basement remodel.

Get quotes from up to 3 pros!
Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.

Dear Angie: Can I save money by finishing my basement piecemeal rather than hiring a general contractor? — Jennifer M., Alpharetta, Georgia.

Our research found that general contractors — who hire and supervise subcontractors such as plumbers, electricians and carpenters — typically mark up labor and material costs by as much as 20 percent. A 20 percent markup on a $15,000 basement remodel, for example, would be $3,000. That’s money you could pocket if you supervise all aspects of the project.

But weigh your options carefully before deciding what's best for your situation. Unless you have experience in the building trades or house construction, as well as a flexible schedule with significant free time, you're probably not ready to act as your own general contractor. Orchestrating a full remodeling of your basement can be a monumental task for an inexperienced homeowner.

You could end paying more if the job is done incorrectly by the subcontractors you hire or if scheduling conflicts arise. Highly rated general contractors tell our team that they sometimes are brought in to fix problems created by workers homeowners hired on the cheap. A general contractor is responsible for fixing problems with the job. If things go wrong on your watch, you'll be paying.

A licensed, qualified contractor can make a difference

Also, keep in mind that an experienced and qualified general contractor will handle getting all necessary permits, and making sure subcontractors are appropriately insured and licensed. A good general contractor will also ensure that work meets local building codes, comes in on budget and maintains high quality standards.

But if you have the experience and the time to be your own general contractor, you may save money as well as stay on top of all details.

No matter which way you go, though, best of luck with your project!

Angie Hicks is founder of Angie’s List. Have a question for her team? Email askangie@angi.com or tweet to #AskAngie. Follow her @Angie_Hicks.

Editor's note: This is an updated version of an article originally posted on Jan. 20, 2014.

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.