Top-rated home builders.

Best home builders near Mattituck, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your home building project in Mattituck, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY MATTITUCK, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon5
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon15
    Verified home building services reviews

Top-Rated Home builders in Mattituck - Updated Nov 2026

Avatar for Arthur DeRosa Building and Remodeling
Arthur DeRosa Building and Remodeling
4.7(
13
)
Find a Custom Home BuilderFind a Modular Home BuilderShelter or Outbuilding - Build

Serving Mattituck, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1986

Free estimates

Customers say: True professional

"Artie & Mike are simply the best. I used them to: 1) Build a LARGE extension to my house and redo my entire kitchen and dining room. The job was completed on time and on budget. Throughout the process Artie was transparent & professional. EVERY person who has stepped into my house has complimented at the detailed perfection. 3) Artie built us a custom walk in pantry 2) Built 2 large decks in the backyard as well as an outdoor shower. This project was completed on time, on budget while exceeding all expectations. If you are looking for a contractor and crew that is responsible, responsive, polite, creative and delivers the HIGHEST LEVEL of quality - Artie is the one."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+20

Response time2 days
4 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for Agate & Co. Builders
Agate & Co. Builders
5.0(
13
)
Find a Custom Home BuilderFind a Modular Home Builder

Serving Mattituck, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1990

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"Jim and his crew went over and above our expectations. They did a beautiful job on our new deck. When completed, they cleaned up and carted away all scraps. A truly professional job by all."
Sag Harbor Re-Build
Sag Harbor Re-Build
Sag Harbor Re-Build
Sag Harbor Re-Build
Sag Harbor Re-Build

+40

Response time2 days
15 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by92%of homeowners
Dreamy Interiors
5.0(
2
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Mattituck, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2007

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business! Book with us online or feel free to give us a call today! \n

Response time3 hrs
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for MHI Metro Home Improvement
MHI Metro Home Improvement
4.7(
29
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Mattituck, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 2007

Free estimates

"First off I live in Queens not Long Island..I got Metro Home Improvements number from someone who used them.. I called Romeo to set up an appointment for an estimate. Not only did he return my call within 15 minutes...he was at my house in Queens within 2 hours...now anyone who would do that gets high a mark from me. Over the years dealing with contractors none had ever responded that quickly...I hired them and I did not regret it. Romeo may have regretted the quote he gave me. My deck isn't big but does have quite a few angles involved and two sets of stairs.. They ripped out the old deck I had for 23 years and reinforced the base structure and started installing the new composite decking on day one ...day two job was completed. They were prompt; curtious and above all neat. I would definitely recommend Romeo and Metro Home Improvement. You will not ne disappointed..Five Stars ...If I could give Ten stars I would..."
After
Before
Levittown NY
Outdoor
#1

+106

Response time4 hrs
Response rate100%
3 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Cary's Home Improvement
Cary's Home Improvement
4.4(
35
)
Shelter or Outbuilding - Build

Serving Mattituck, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1985

Emergency services offered

"My wife and I DO NOT use anyone who is not on Angie's List so we understand the importance of having accurate, fair reviews. We found Cary on Angie's List with overall great feedback on jobs he had done so we called him in for an estimate. Despite being very busy, he made the time to come over on a Saturday morning. He had previously dropped by and assessed the damage from the outside but needed to see it from the inside to ensure he could judge it accurately. After 15 minutes, our fears were realized and he said he would need to remove the cedar impression siding and remove the roof and replace it with a different system because the pitch wasn't steep enough. 
Within 48 hours, he provided a quote for his crew to come out and get the work done in a single day which was completely reasonable. He completed the work (guaranteed) as promised and left the site immaculate. He took pictures of the issue, of job progress and of the completed job. He mentioned he went around and filled some other issues he noticed while he was waiting for his crew to wrap up, no charge at all. He then discounted the quoted, agreed price 5% for angie's list deal I wasn't even aware of. Have you ever heard of a contractor accept less than an agreed price? Me neither.
Angie's List is a great resource for people to share experiences. I think the contractors who are honest and reasonable should be applauded too. We have been on the receiving end of some really lousy service so this was a new experience having someone do what they promised to do. Cary and his crew are the best in Monmouth County. We already have him pricing out finishing a storage space and will use him to build our deck in the spring. I cannot recommend Cary enough and you can reach me through Cary if you'd like to see his work firsthand. 
Kevin
"
Before
After
After
Before
After

+9

Recommended by100%of homeowners
Boulevard Planning Pc
4.9(
12
)
Find a Custom Home BuilderFind a Modular Home BuilderShelter or Outbuilding - Build

Serving Mattituck, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1987

"Boulevard Planning did a total remodel of our home. We had a cape and removed the entire second floor and built an full third floor attic. Thanks to John, we some how were even able to live in the house (not ideal) through the entire construction. Could not have asked things to go as smoothly as they did. John is a stand up guy and really went above and beyond. To be expected a few bumps along the way that were immediately taken care of. Cannot tell you the number of complements we get, more importantly it is awesome to be living in the new house. Unbelievably, John stuck 100% to the original budget. We did exceed budget with extras, mostly on the first floor. All of the extras were our own doing. With any contractor, stay on top of the work they are doing in order to be sure it is up to your liking. I would hire Boulevard Planning to do it all over again."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+6

Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for Kentstruction
Kentstruction
4.6(
40
)
Find a Custom Home BuilderFind a Modular Home BuilderShelter or Outbuilding - Build

Serving Mattituck, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1981

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Once we hired Kentstruction to do our job, Kent told us he would start in 4 weeks and that's exactly when they came. The job was done quickly and efficiently. Kent and his brother Eban were so helpful when it came to making decisions on products and designs. They were always timely and professional and the work they did was excellent. We will hire them again for our next home improvement,."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+17

Recommended by84%of homeowners
Avatar for NY1 Home Improvement Inc. general contractor
NY1 Home Improvement Inc. general contractor
4.4(
42
)
Find a Custom Home BuilderFind a Modular Home BuilderShelter or Outbuilding - Build

Serving Mattituck, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 2001

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"We had hired Waheed back in 2008 to replace our kitchen Formica countertop with a granite countertop.  He was very professional and courteous.  He supervised the job from beginning to end.  The new countertop exceeded our expectations.  He gave us a beautiful radius on the island corners which we did not expect.   We needed 2 slabs to accommodate 40 linear feet of countertops plus a 5 1/2 foot long by 40" wide island.   We receive a lot of compliments from our family and friends.
This January, we needed to replace our accessory apartment kitchen Formica countertop.  We didn't hesitate to call Waheed again.  He came and gave us an estimate.  He sent us to pick the slab from his warehouse.  We wanted a white Carrera quartz countertop and we had so many to choose from.   The new countertop was installed 1 week after the template was taken.  We would recommend Waheed to anyone needing a new countertop.  He is very pleasant to work with."
Additional Photos
Recommended by82%of homeowners
Avatar for 112 Home Improvement Inc
112 Home Improvement Inc
4.5(
32
)
Find a Custom Home BuilderFind a Modular Home BuilderShelter or Outbuilding - Build

Serving Mattituck, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1995

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"John Hayes and his 112 construction team came and expedited the repairs to get our home back to not only a functional state, but a more improved home better than we had before. The rooms that were effected the most look better than they ever did. As repairs occurred; John was very open to having other work in our home being renovated as part of the original repair work. Work such as our master bathroom renovation as well as our living room look as if we moved into a brand new home. During the repair phase, an ongoing problem with our plumbing was discovered. John and his team didn't miss a step. They immediately went into action to solve the issue and continue with the existing repairs like nothing happened. Their knowledge, professionalism, expertise, flexibility, and courtesy during the work was well over outstanding. John's assistance on helping us locate the best products to add to the repairs and renovations is greatly appreciate. The costs we paid for his services and work doesn't compare to the price we paid. Considering we had a limited budget of funds to work with, John was able to meet our budget and surpass our expectations on the results. John Hayes was always available for any questions we had, and always had an answer to any question we had to guide us thru the entire process of the work. He didn't miss a step being onsite and available to oversee all the work. Hands down; we will definitely be calling on John Hayes and 112 Home Improvements in the near future for any construction needs on our home. Thank you John once again for making my family's home whole and "Improved". Sincerely, Craig"
Kitchen 1
kitchen 2
kitchen 3
kitchen 1
kitchen 2

+22

Recommended by92%of homeowners
...
Showing 1-10 of 173
Home Building FAQs, answered by experts

The average cost to renovate or remodel a home is $52,300, with most projects ranging from $19,500 to over $88,400. However, costs can vary significantly, from as low as $3,000 for a small project to $170,000 or more for a complete home remodel.

Several factors influence the total price, including:

  • Project Scope and Size: The extent of the renovations, whether it's a single room or the entire house.

  • Location: Geographic location affects labor and material costs.

  • Materials: The quality of materials chosen.

  • Room Type: Kitchen remodels ($14,500 - $70,000+) are generally more expensive than bedroom remodels ($1,500 - $5,500).

  • Other Factors: The time of year, complexity of the work, and any additions or expansions.

On a per-square-foot basis, you can expect to pay between $15 and $60 for standard projects and up to $150 for luxury renovations.

Examples of specific project costs include:

  • Basement remodel: ~$20,200

  • Garage remodel: ~$27,900

  • Loft conversion: ~$20,200

  • Disability accommodation remodel: ~$4,300

  • Major home repairs: ~$11,700

If you are financing the project, note that some loan programs, like the FHA 203(k), may require a minimum project cost (e.g., $5,000) and will necessitate a home appraisal and professional cost estimates. Using a home renovation cost estimator can also help you budget for your project.

Modular homes can be a great investment, especially for those who find the prices of stick-built real estate too high. Modular homes are usually much more affordable because they’re mass-manufactured and then assembled on-site or delivered mostly assembled. If they’re installed properly and by professionals, they can last for between 50 and 100 years, potentially making them an outstanding investment.

Whether it’s more affordable to gut a house than build a new one depends on the markets where you'd be buying and selling. However, it’s usually less expensive to renovate a home than to build new construction. 

Most homeowners pay between $100,000 and $200,000 for demolition and remodeling costs, whereas the average cost to build a new home is between $139,000 and $531,300.

One of the best ways to negotiate with a homebuilder is to forgo price reductions. Instead, negotiate over upgrades and incentives, as many builders are more willing to go down that road than to decrease their own fee. Even if they were willing to take a cut, a reputable homebuilder often knows their worth, so a willingness to negotiate could be a red flag. Beyond that, builders are typically willing to negotiate closing costs instead of offering a discount on the base price.

A-frame homes are on the smaller side. While there’s no set square footage amount it has to be, it will usually come in around 1,000 square feet or smaller.

The Mattituck, NY homeowners’ guide to home building services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.