How do I know if my gutters need to be replaced?

• <div><p>With routine maintenance, gutters don’t usually need to be replaced for 20 years, but there are warning signs that they might need early replacement. Signs that your gutters need to be replaced include sagging, visible cracks or holes, peeling paint, rust, <a href="https://www.angi.com/articles/standing-water-sign-your-gutters-need-repair.htm">standing water in your gutter</a>, and water leaking into your basement. Pushing off replacing your gutters can lead to extensive damage to both the interior and exterior of your home. Regular maintenance can help your gutters last all 20 years — and sometimes, even longer. </p></div>

Is it better to repair or replace leaking or damaged gutters?

• <div><p>In most cases, it makes more sense to repair <a href="https://www.angi.com/articles/fix-gutter-leak.htm">leaking or damaged gutters</a> than it will to replace them. You’ll spend an average of <b>$400</b> to repair your gutters, while full replacement will cost around <b>$2,000</b> or more, depending on the gutter material and style and the size of your home. If your gutters are nearing the end of their lifespan—usually around 20 years for aluminum or vinyl gutters or up to 50 years for copper or steel—then it might make sense to replace them, as it could cost you less in the long run.</p></div>

Top-rated gutter repair and replacement pros.

Get matched with top gutter repair and replacement pros in Lyons, NY

Q: How do I know if my gutters need to be replaced?

• <div><p>With routine maintenance, gutters don&rsquo;t usually need to be replaced for 20 years, but there are warning signs that they might need early replacement. Signs that your gutters need to be replaced include sagging, visible cracks or holes, peeling paint, rust, <a href="https://www.angi.com/articles/standing-water-sign-your-gutters-need-repair.htm">standing water in your gutter</a>, and water leaking into your basement. Pushing off replacing your gutters can lead to extensive damage to both the interior and exterior of your home. Regular maintenance can help your gutters last all 20 years &mdash; and sometimes, even longer. </p></div>

Q: Can sagging gutters be repaired?

• <div><p>Yes, and repairing such damage is another repair that&rsquo;s done often. Sagging gutters are usually the result of one of two things: damage or overload. For example, ice buildup over the winter due to clogged gutters can cause expansion, stretching the gutters. A falling tree limb or even a rogue baseball can cause gutters to sag. <a href="https://www.angi.com/articles/how-repair-sagging-gutters.htm">Sagging gutters can be repaired</a>, but they are often replaced because it can take less time.</p></div>

Q: Can I repair my own gutters?

• <div><p>It is possible to repair your own gutters, but we don&rsquo;t recommend it. First, gutters need to sit at a precise slope to direct water toward the downspouts but also appear level from the yard, and this task is challenging to get right through DIY gutter repair. Second, any mistakes you make could be costly if they cause water damage or foundation damage. It might seem unnecessary to spend <b>$400</b> on professional gutter repair, but it pales in comparison to what you might pay if you make a mistake doing the work yourself.</p></div>

Q: Is it better to replace or repair gutters?

• <div><p>If you are experiencing minor issues with your gutters, such as a small leak or cracks in one or two sections, it makes more sense to repair the issue than to replace your entire gutter system. However, you may need to replace your gutters if they&rsquo;re frequently detaching from your home or if you notice a buildup of mold or mildew in your basement.</p></div>

There are 4 highly-rated local gutter repair and replacement pros.

Need a pro for your gutter repair and replacement project in Lyons, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

Verified Reviews for Gutter Repair And Replacement pros in Lyons, NY

*The Angi rating for Gutter Repair And Replacement companies in Lyons, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Gutter Repair And Replacement needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Gutter Repair And Replacement companies in Lyons, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Gutter Repair And Replacement needs.

Last update on October 04, 2025

Reviewed in June 2025
Everything was great. Jason was a real pleasure. Did Everything we agreed upon and did it all quickly and to my satisfaction. Will definitely recommend and use him and his crew again for sure
Ever After Remodeling
Request a quote
Reviewed in October 2022
Both projects went well. Artie was very helpful and was always on top of things. He made helpful suggestions as the projects went forward. He was very flexible and when we wanted some changes or additional work it never was an issue.
AJC Designs Construction Inc
Request a quote
Reviewed in July 2020
It is obvious that efficiency, quality, and rapport are important to the Perfect Exteriors family. Every person we came into contact with, whether directly from the company or a company contracted from outside, was respectful and dedicated to delivering the highest quality materials and service....
Perfect Exteriors
Request a quote
Reviewed in December 2020
I couldn't be more pleased with Xterior. I am thrilled that I found them on Angie's list. They were communicative, professional, hard-working, fast, efficient, and cleaned up beautifully. I recommend them 100%! This is one of the very best companies I have ever worked with, from the owner...
Xterior Solutions
Request a quote
Reviewed in September 2020
Jeff was invaluable in helping to assess a mold issue on a property that we were trying to purchase. He quickly returned phone calls, answered questions in an understandable way and gave direct clear advice. I highly recommend Jeff and his company!
NU-Life Resources
Request a quote
Reviewed in January 2018
They did a *wonderful* job (in the dead of winter, no less)! We are very pleased with them and would recommend them to anyone without reservation!
Northern Windows, Siding, Roofing, & Insulation
Request a quote
Reviewed in September 2022
Everything went extremely well. Alex and his crew were punctual and before they started working, Alex and I went over everything they were going to do. New gutters and downspouts were installed as well as cleaning and repairing some of the existing gutters. Their work was excellent and when...
Lake Country Gutters Inc
Request a quote
Reviewed in March 2017
Jason and his crew were among the most professional that I have ever experienced working with. Jason was knowledgable, caring, friendly and extremely easy to talk to. He had no problem answering even the silliest of questions that I had. His crew leader Rick was of amazing talent. And also just...
Explicit Exteriors
Request a quote

Get matched with top gutter repair and replacement pros in Lyons, NY

There are 4 highly-rated local gutter repair and replacement pros.

Need a pro for your gutter repair and replacement project in Lyons, NY?

Seamless Metal Gutters Installation

Seamless Metal Gutters Repair

Asphalt Shingle Roofing Installation and Replacement

Verified Reviews for Gutter Repair And Replacement pros in Lyons, NY

Find Gutter repair and replacement pros in Lyons

J&H Home Renovations

J&H Home Renovations

Byler builders

Byler builders

MAC Contracting

MAC Contracting

Proline Maintenance

Proline Maintenance

J.S.M.E.C.C. Handyman home improvements

J.S.M.E.C.C. Handyman home improvements

Monarch Home Solutions Inc.

Monarch Home Solutions Inc.

Staples Exteriors

Staples Exteriors

New Look's Renovations

New Look's Renovations

Holbrook Marketing Firm

Holbrook Marketing Firm

J.P.S General Contracting

J.P.S General Contracting

The Lyons, NY homeowners’ guide to gutter repairs and replacements

How Much Does Gutter Installation Cost? [2025 Data]

How Much Does It Cost to Install Copper Gutters? [2025 Data]

How Much Do Faux Copper Gutters Cost to Install? [2025 Data]

Is Your Gutter in the Right Place? Here's What to Know

What Are Seamless Gutters and Are They Right for Your Home?

5 Questions to Ask About Gutter Repair

Find Gutter repair and replacement Pros in other cities near youNot finding what you are looking for in Lyons? Check surrounding areas for Gutter repair and replacement pros.

Find Pros for other jobs in LyonsIf your Gutter repair and replacement job is complete, use Angi to find quality Pros in Lyons for any number of jobs.