Get matched with top mailbox repairers in Fishers Island, NY
Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros
Need a pro for your mailbox repair project in Fishers Island, NY?
Select your specific project to find the pro for you.
TRUSTED BY FISHERS ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS
4.5 Average homeowner rating
177 Verified mailbox repairs reviews
Verified Reviews for Mailbox Repair pros in Fishers Island, NY
*The Angi rating for Mailbox Repair companies in Fishers Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Mailbox Repair needs.
*The HomeAdvisor rating for Mailbox Repair companies in Fishers Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Mailbox Repair needs.
Last update on December 13, 2025
Find Mailbox repairers in Fishers Island
Magic Improvement, LLC
Magic Improvement, LLC
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
23 local quotes requested
20 years of experience
We are extremely passionate about the work that we do. You can depend on us to provide a high quality service at a fair and honest price. We understand that the future of our business depends upon our reputation and that is why customer service is by far our highest priority. If you are looking for a professional you can trust, please call today to schedule a no-obligation estimate!
"We had a few jobs including grouting of shower, reinforcing kitchen cabinets and making a wall opening in our laundry room. Angel and his workers are truly professional, friendly and hard working. They were perfectionists."
John F on October 2025
We are extremely passionate about the work that we do. You can depend on us to provide a high quality service at a fair and honest price. We understand that the future of our business depends upon our reputation and that is why customer service is by far our highest priority. If you are looking for a professional you can trust, please call today to schedule a no-obligation estimate!
"We had a few jobs including grouting of shower, reinforcing kitchen cabinets and making a wall opening in our laundry room. Angel and his workers are truly professional, friendly and hard working. They were perfectionists."
John F on October 2025
Neversweat Property Management
Neversweat Property Management
Customers say: Quick response
76 local quotes requested
2 years of experience
Neversweat Property Management specializes in the care and maintenance of properties in the picturesque East End of Long Island. Our dedicated team offers a comprehensive range of services, including property management, seasonal house care, and handyman repairs. With a passion for excellence and a commitment to property owners, we ensure that each property thrives, allowing our clients to enjoy peace of mind and the full experience of East End living. At Neversweat, we take care of your property as if it were our own, making your investment our responsibility.
"Everything went great, went over and above to make sure that we were pleased with the job."
Carlos F on November 2023
Neversweat Property Management specializes in the care and maintenance of properties in the picturesque East End of Long Island. Our dedicated team offers a comprehensive range of services, including property management, seasonal house care, and handyman repairs. With a passion for excellence and a commitment to property owners, we ensure that each property thrives, allowing our clients to enjoy peace of mind and the full experience of East End living. At Neversweat, we take care of your property as if it were our own, making your investment our responsibility.
"Everything went great, went over and above to make sure that we were pleased with the job."
Carlos F on November 2023
OnCall Handyman
OnCall Handyman
82 local quotes requested
Welcome to OnCall Handyman, we look forward to discussing all of your handyman needs, please give us a call!
Welcome to OnCall Handyman, we look forward to discussing all of your handyman needs, please give us a call!
Woodland Park NJ Locksmith Store
Woodland Park NJ Locksmith Store
36 years of experience
At Woodland Park NJ Locksmith Store our promise to you and this great community is a great Locksmith Service in Woodland Park, NJ. We offer Locksmith Service at any time 24 hours.
At Woodland Park NJ Locksmith Store our promise to you and this great community is a great Locksmith Service in Woodland Park, NJ. We offer Locksmith Service at any time 24 hours.
Hackensack NJ Locksmith Store
Hackensack NJ Locksmith Store
36 years of experience
Hackensack NJ Locksmith Store are a full service Locksmith Company, Who proudly provides Residential Commercial and Automotive and Emergency Service 24 hours in Hackensack, NJ.
Hackensack NJ Locksmith Store are a full service Locksmith Company, Who proudly provides Residential Commercial and Automotive and Emergency Service 24 hours in Hackensack, NJ.
Garfield NJ Locksmith Store
Garfield NJ Locksmith Store
39 years of experience
Garfield NJ Locksmith Store are a full service Locksmith Company, Who proudly provides Residential Commercial and Automotive and Emergency Service 24 hours in Garfield, NJ.
Garfield NJ Locksmith Store are a full service Locksmith Company, Who proudly provides Residential Commercial and Automotive and Emergency Service 24 hours in Garfield, NJ.
Closter NJ Locksmith Store
Closter NJ Locksmith Store
42 years of experience
Closter NJ Locksmith Store are a full service Locksmith Company, Who proudly provides Residential Commercial and Automotive and Emergency Service 24 hours in Closter, NJ.
Closter NJ Locksmith Store are a full service Locksmith Company, Who proudly provides Residential Commercial and Automotive and Emergency Service 24 hours in Closter, NJ.
Bergenfield NJ Locksmith Store
Bergenfield NJ Locksmith Store
26 years of experience
We are a Local Locksmith Company that provides locksmith service in Bergenfield, NJ. We offer our Locksmith service 24 hours a day and 7 days a week to those in need of our assistance.
We are a Local Locksmith Company that provides locksmith service in Bergenfield, NJ. We offer our Locksmith service 24 hours a day and 7 days a week to those in need of our assistance.
Teaneck NJ Locksmith Store
Teaneck NJ Locksmith Store
21 years of experience
At Teaneck NJ Locksmith Store our promise to you and this great community is a great Locksmith Service in Teaneck, NJ. We offer Locksmith Service at any time 24 hours.
At Teaneck NJ Locksmith Store our promise to you and this great community is a great Locksmith Service in Teaneck, NJ. We offer Locksmith Service at any time 24 hours.
FAQs for mailbox repair projects in Fishers Island, NY
Brick mailbox repairs cost about $625 on average, ranging from about $500 to $750, depending on the extent of damage, type of brick and mortar, time of year, location, and experience level of the mason doing repairs. Hire a masonry contractor to inspect the brick mailbox’s damage and recommend a repair plan. They can also provide a price estimate that’s specific to your type and size of mailbox.
Yes, it’s usually possible to repair damaged brick mailboxes. If the masonry is damaged, the brick can be cut out and replaced, or the mortar joints can be cut out and retucked. However, the new mortar will likely be different in color from the original mortar joints. In most cases, if the mailbox itself is damaged, it’s possible to cut it out and replace it. Consult a masonry contractor to determine whether it’s worth repairing your brick mailbox based on its value and amount of damage.
Typically, a brick mason will repair a brick mailbox. They can provide an estimate for repairs, which may include sourcing replacement brick, mortar, and other materials. If your brick mailbox has been completely destroyed, you should check with your local building code enforcement office to confirm that a brick mailbox is allowed in your location as some areas do not allow brick mailboxes because of the potential hazard for drivers who may hit them.
Homeowners are responsible for maintaining their own mailboxes. Otherwise, a property manager is responsible for repairs and maintenance if the Post Office does not maintain it. If you own your home, you are responsible for maintaining the mailbox at the specified height, distance from the road, and functionality.
Mailbox repair can cost anywhere from $100 to $300, depending on the type of mailbox, materials involved, and labor cost. The estimated cost of repairs also depends on whether you need to replace the mailbox post, the post’s construction, and type of mailbox. If you have multiple mailboxes, the cost will increase compared to a single mailbox.
The Fishers Island, NY homeowners’ guide to mailbox repairs
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
Whether you're planting your flag with a new build or upgrading a leaning or crumbling mailbox, get an idea of brick mailbox cost with this guide.
- Mystic, CT Mailbox repairers
- New London, CT Mailbox repairers
- Stonington, CT Mailbox repairers
- Groton, CT Mailbox repairers
- Waterford, CT Mailbox repairers
- Old Mystic, CT Mailbox repairers
- Niantic, CT Mailbox repairers
- Quaker Hill, CT Mailbox repairers
- Pawcatuck, CT Mailbox repairers
- Gales Ferry, CT Mailbox repairers
- Ledyard, CT Mailbox repairers
- Orient, NY Mailbox repairers
- East Lyme, CT Mailbox repairers
- Westerly, RI Mailbox repairers
- Montauk, NY Mailbox repairers
- Montville, CT Mailbox repairers
- Uncasville, CT Mailbox repairers
- Lyme, CT Mailbox repairers
- Old Lyme, CT Mailbox repairers
- North Stonington, CT Mailbox repairers
- Oakdale, CT Mailbox repairers
- Ashaway, RI Mailbox repairers
- Bradford, RI Mailbox repairers
- Preston, CT Mailbox repairers
- East Hampton, NY Mailbox repairers
- Norwich, CT Mailbox repairers
- Old Saybrook, CT Mailbox repairers
- Amagansett, NY Mailbox repairers
- Shelter Island, NY Mailbox repairers
- Greenport, NY Mailbox repairers