Get matched with top toilet pros in Bayside, NY

"Our toilet flapper had a problem last summer and a handyman tried to help us fix it as a favor to us while doing another job in our home. He said that he was missing a small key part from our supplies, but he did his best. So then we called in another plumbing co. to help tweak it back to 100%. More $$ and it still was not up to par by co #2. So then we tried to fix it ourselves, which lasted a few months fine. But then, it when it went totally kaput. Yikes! So we let it sit for a month, completely useless to all. Finally yesterday we woke up and said that THIS is the day that we will get this properly fixed!!!! I reviewed many Anglie's List reviewer's comments and narrowed it down to Barnagat. I bought the necessary items early that AM to make sure that the supplier had them in stock. Then I reached out to Barbara and was so appreciative that she was able to take my call because I had little time remaining to meet all timelines. I explained to her our needs, our timeframes, etc. I told her our main job was the toilet but we had a few side jobs too if possible, all upfront. She called us back shortly afterwards, after she managed to change her schedule around to meet our time needs, which we greatly appreciated!!! She called prior to the agreed upon arrival time to responsibly notify us that she was minimally delayed, just as the others had previously mentioned. She was professional, polite, warm, friendly, and caring. She is very genuine. I have waited a full day to hold off on writing this review to confirm that it was done accurately (after usage), and indeed it surely was. We are nothing but grateful to Barbara for her help from A to Z and will surely call on Barbara again in the future. Thank you so much Barbara!!!!"

"Anthony arrived super early which was good because my toilet was leaking to the floor below. He gave me a list of options and after removing the toilet and reviewing the damage, we decided on a course of action. He was efficient and clean. The work was finished in no time . I thought the work would have been much more extensive. Perhaps other plumbers would have priced it for more than was necessary. I am VERY pleased with the work Anthony did for our family."

"Tyrone was on time & did a great job fixing old running toilet."

"I called P & A Sewer and Drain to replace the toilet flange and to unclog the kitchen sink. The plumber did an excellent job, paying close attention to detail and he left the work areas spotless. If you're looking for an honest plumber with very reasonable rates, I highly recommend calling P & A Sewer and Drain."

"I worked with Jesse to help with a clogged bathtub drain after I tried plunging it myself. I explained over the phone that I was dealing with backflow problems and each time I used the bathroom sink the water would end up back in the tub. Unlike another plumber who said they would need to charge me to snake both the tub and the bathroom sink, Jesse explained it would likely just need to be the sink and there is an issue in the shared drainage pipe. Jesse communicated clearly when he'd arrive and on his availabilites, and helped resolve the issue quickly and cleaned up after himself. He also gave me additional advice on how to manage my drainage issues in the future, and another toilet problem I had. Good guy to work with, and got the job done. Would hire again."

"This company did an excellent job. They repaired my toilet and replaced the toilet shutoff valve. Lazer was very nice and polite and cleaned up after himself after he finished. The price was fair. The quality of work was excellent."

"Had to replace a toilet wax seal. Job was done perfectly and quickly. Would highly recommend Jimmy."

"Joe is the man. I hired him to install a digital toilet and he did an excellent job. He is very knowledgeable about plumbing and electric work. The new toilet is large and heavy, but Joe took the time to get it installed beautifully and the water pipe work he did was perfect. I will hire Joe again with no hesitation."

"Egli Plumbing was available on short notice and able to solve the problem with our sump pump with ease. They also helped to repair 2 of my toilets the next day. Would definitely recommend for any plumbing needs!"

"Great service, professional and flexible. Would hire again. They replaced two of our toilets and faucets. The work was quick and very well done."