Top-rated bathtub replacement pros.

Get matched with top bathtub replacement pros in Carthage, IN

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your bathtub replacement project in Carthage, IN?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY CARTHAGE, IN HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.4
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon88
    Verified bathtub replacements reviews

Find Bathtub replacement pros in Carthage

Avatar for Madison County Cabinets Inc

Madison County Cabinets Inc

5.00(
222
)
Approved Pro

Madison County Cabinets Inc

5.00(
222
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 99% of Angi customers
Recommended by 99% of HomeAdvisor customers
1973 years of experience

Since 1973, it has been our mission to build cabinets that we would be proud to put in our homes. Over the years, we have continued to refine our process and continuously learn so that we can provide you with the best custom cabinetry in Indiana. We remain committed to exceeding customer expectations and we hope that you give us the opportunity to exceed yours. To maintain a high quality installation experience, we only install our own cabinetry. We have won quite a few Angie's List Super Service Awards - including for 2013-2022. To maintain a high quality installation experience, we only install our own cabinetry. When you are ready, please let us know when you'd like to come out to our showroom for a tour. If you would prefer, we also love the opportunity to meet you at the job site. Thanks for looking at Madison County Cabinets. Family Owned & Operated. Cost Is Determined By The Job. No travel charges. 19 Employees.

"My husband and I began looking for a home in the area three years ago. In one of the houses we looked at, the cabinets were beautiful and were made by MCC. When we did our new home build we knew no one one else would build our cabinets. We couldn't have been more pleased with the attention and time spent by MCC to make our cabinets into the fine furniture they are . The special lighting features, drawer spice rack, under cabinet mixer stand and kitchen utensil pull out made our kitchen a wonderful place to prepare meals. Working with MCC was truly a blessing."

Katherine O on March 2023

Since 1973, it has been our mission to build cabinets that we would be proud to put in our homes. Over the years, we have continued to refine our process and continuously learn so that we can provide you with the best custom cabinetry in Indiana. We remain committed to exceeding customer expectations and we hope that you give us the opportunity to exceed yours. To maintain a high quality installation experience, we only install our own cabinetry. We have won quite a few Angie's List Super Service Awards - including for 2013-2022. To maintain a high quality installation experience, we only install our own cabinetry. When you are ready, please let us know when you'd like to come out to our showroom for a tour. If you would prefer, we also love the opportunity to meet you at the job site. Thanks for looking at Madison County Cabinets. Family Owned & Operated. Cost Is Determined By The Job. No travel charges. 19 Employees.

"My husband and I began looking for a home in the area three years ago. In one of the houses we looked at, the cabinets were beautiful and were made by MCC. When we did our new home build we knew no one one else would build our cabinets. We couldn't have been more pleased with the attention and time spent by MCC to make our cabinets into the fine furniture they are . The special lighting features, drawer spice rack, under cabinet mixer stand and kitchen utensil pull out made our kitchen a wonderful place to prepare meals. Working with MCC was truly a blessing."

Katherine O on March 2023


Avatar for Alamo Garage Doors

Alamo Garage Doors

4.96(
190
)
Approved Pro

Alamo Garage Doors

4.96(
190
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Terrific value
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers
Free onsite estimate

We guarantee your satisfaction and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Check out our services offered and call or click to schedule a free estimate today.

"The installation of our new garage door went perfectly. The team worked efficiently, cleaned up after themselves, and made sure everything looked great. They even showed me how to use the remote properly."

Stanly S on November 2025

We guarantee your satisfaction and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Check out our services offered and call or click to schedule a free estimate today.

"The installation of our new garage door went perfectly. The team worked efficiently, cleaned up after themselves, and made sure everything looked great. They even showed me how to use the remote properly."

Stanly S on November 2025


Avatar for West Shore Home Indianapolis

West Shore Home Indianapolis

4.91(
960
)
Approved Pro

West Shore Home Indianapolis

4.91(
960
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers
2006 years of experience

West Shore Home offers a risk-free home improvement experience, so you never have to worry that you are sacrificing on quality, convenience, or expertise. We specialize in window, entry door, shower and bath replacements, including walk-in tubs. We offer fully customizable, limited lifetime-guaranteed solutions installed in as little as one-day. All of our installers are in-house employees, so we can guarantee the quality of the whole project from start to finish. We get it done the way you want - fast, easy, smart and right. Our team is following all CDC guidelines so we can provide you with the fast and convenient home improvements. We are also offering free virtual design consultations! Schedule your free consultation today.

"currently in progress"

Nathan B on October 2025

West Shore Home offers a risk-free home improvement experience, so you never have to worry that you are sacrificing on quality, convenience, or expertise. We specialize in window, entry door, shower and bath replacements, including walk-in tubs. We offer fully customizable, limited lifetime-guaranteed solutions installed in as little as one-day. All of our installers are in-house employees, so we can guarantee the quality of the whole project from start to finish. We get it done the way you want - fast, easy, smart and right. Our team is following all CDC guidelines so we can provide you with the fast and convenient home improvements. We are also offering free virtual design consultations! Schedule your free consultation today.

"currently in progress"

Nathan B on October 2025


Avatar for Yesteryear Construction Services

Yesteryear Construction Services

4.96(
39
)
Approved Pro

Yesteryear Construction Services

4.96(
39
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
2000 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Here at Yesteryear Construction Services, we have over 16 years of experience under our belt and we are your first choice for an excellent customer experience. We are a locally owned and operated business. Our professionals are always prompt and friendly every step of the way. We specialize in all types of remodels and several other home improvement projects. Call us today for a free estimate!

"Andy and his team were an A+ company form start to finish. Professional, excellent craftsmanship, great ideas to make the project even better, on time from the beginning. Complete and total trust. I can’t say enough how good they were. Hire this company!!"

Rebecca C on October 2025

Here at Yesteryear Construction Services, we have over 16 years of experience under our belt and we are your first choice for an excellent customer experience. We are a locally owned and operated business. Our professionals are always prompt and friendly every step of the way. We specialize in all types of remodels and several other home improvement projects. Call us today for a free estimate!

"Andy and his team were an A+ company form start to finish. Professional, excellent craftsmanship, great ideas to make the project even better, on time from the beginning. Complete and total trust. I can’t say enough how good they were. Hire this company!!"

Rebecca C on October 2025


Avatar for Indiana Foundation Service

Indiana Foundation Service

4.51(
669
)
Approved Pro

Indiana Foundation Service

4.51(
669
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
1993 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Established in 1993, Indiana Foundation Service stands as a trusted subsidiary of Groundworks, a distinguished family of companies renowned for delivering unparalleled solutions. From foundation repair, structural reinforcement, crawl space encapsulation, basement waterproofing, and concrete lifting, we provide comprehensive services tailored to meet your needs. With our coverage spanning across the entire state of Indiana, we bring our local expertise closer to you. Indiana Foundation Service proudly holds accreditation from the Better Business Bureau, a testament to our unwavering commitment to excellence. Drawing from decades of collective experience, extensive industry knowledge, and ongoing specialized training, our dedicated team is poised to safeguard your residential property against water damage, concrete sinking, and foundation instability. At IFS, we are not just builders; we are guardians of your peace of mind. Contact us today for a FREE estimate! GL1600041 (IN)

"I’m a 70 year old Senior. I had sagging at the end of my hall, in my 3-BR ranch home. I got five other quotes, none of which suggests a problem with my foyer or kitchen. They sent out some 20 something young man -that clearly did not know what he was doing to complete my main beam replacement project. I mentioned to David (the 20 something) and his assistant IMMEDIATELY, that my kitchen cabinets had pulled away from the wall and the foyer was tilting. Several times. He assured me that he would run the beam right up under the kitchen between the kitchen and the foyer, to the garage door —to correct it! I had an intense disagreement with him when he tried to leave and did not make any attempt to correct the damage. The damage they had caused. I used my burial money to correct this sagging in the hall-and they left me with a huge problem with my foyer and kitchen that WASN’T THERE BEFORE, that they caused, & knew they caused. Indiana foundation, now Groundworks, sent Blake to my house under the guise of completing my first adjustment to the main beam, and as I had instructed them, to formulate their repair project based on a certified Home Inspection Specialist that I had hired to let me know what, specifically, Ind Found. should do to correct the serious problem they created. They promised to schedule the repair work at that time, but have ghosted to me ever since coming to see the damage they caused and formulate the repair. I have not been able to get in contact with them since; I’ve left numerous v-mails and texts. They have no integrity towards my project and nor will they have ANY integrity towards yours."

CJ M on October 2025

Established in 1993, Indiana Foundation Service stands as a trusted subsidiary of Groundworks, a distinguished family of companies renowned for delivering unparalleled solutions. From foundation repair, structural reinforcement, crawl space encapsulation, basement waterproofing, and concrete lifting, we provide comprehensive services tailored to meet your needs. With our coverage spanning across the entire state of Indiana, we bring our local expertise closer to you. Indiana Foundation Service proudly holds accreditation from the Better Business Bureau, a testament to our unwavering commitment to excellence. Drawing from decades of collective experience, extensive industry knowledge, and ongoing specialized training, our dedicated team is poised to safeguard your residential property against water damage, concrete sinking, and foundation instability. At IFS, we are not just builders; we are guardians of your peace of mind. Contact us today for a FREE estimate! GL1600041 (IN)

"I’m a 70 year old Senior. I had sagging at the end of my hall, in my 3-BR ranch home. I got five other quotes, none of which suggests a problem with my foyer or kitchen. They sent out some 20 something young man -that clearly did not know what he was doing to complete my main beam replacement project. I mentioned to David (the 20 something) and his assistant IMMEDIATELY, that my kitchen cabinets had pulled away from the wall and the foyer was tilting. Several times. He assured me that he would run the beam right up under the kitchen between the kitchen and the foyer, to the garage door —to correct it! I had an intense disagreement with him when he tried to leave and did not make any attempt to correct the damage. The damage they had caused. I used my burial money to correct this sagging in the hall-and they left me with a huge problem with my foyer and kitchen that WASN’T THERE BEFORE, that they caused, & knew they caused. Indiana foundation, now Groundworks, sent Blake to my house under the guise of completing my first adjustment to the main beam, and as I had instructed them, to formulate their repair project based on a certified Home Inspection Specialist that I had hired to let me know what, specifically, Ind Found. should do to correct the serious problem they created. They promised to schedule the repair work at that time, but have ghosted to me ever since coming to see the damage they caused and formulate the repair. I have not been able to get in contact with them since; I’ve left numerous v-mails and texts. They have no integrity towards my project and nor will they have ANY integrity towards yours."

CJ M on October 2025


Avatar for The Trim Doctor

The Trim Doctor

5.00(
12
)
Approved Pro

The Trim Doctor

5.00(
12
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers
2002 years of experience

I have a small interior trim business, in which I am the one who does the work. I've been in this field for over 19 years, and can do any job when it comes to interior trim. Whether it's a remodel or a new home, any job big or small, I can get the job finished. You will be dealing directly with me, and I am not happy until the customer is happy.

"They did an amazing job. "

Amy w on October 2025

I have a small interior trim business, in which I am the one who does the work. I've been in this field for over 19 years, and can do any job when it comes to interior trim. Whether it's a remodel or a new home, any job big or small, I can get the job finished. You will be dealing directly with me, and I am not happy until the customer is happy.

"They did an amazing job. "

Amy w on October 2025


Avatar for Hope Plumbing, Heating, and Cooling

Hope Plumbing, Heating, and Cooling

4.41(
299
)
Approved Pro

Hope Plumbing, Heating, and Cooling

4.41(
299
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers
2003 years of experience

When you're looking for a local and honest plumbing company in Indianapolis, IN, and the surrounding areas, Hope Plumbing gets the job done fast and to the highest standard. Our services are tailored to suit your needs and we'll ensure you get the best service possible at all times. We take care of your plumbing problems as soon as they come up. Speak to our team today to get great customer service immediately!

"Very quick and great value"

David N on March 2025

When you're looking for a local and honest plumbing company in Indianapolis, IN, and the surrounding areas, Hope Plumbing gets the job done fast and to the highest standard. Our services are tailored to suit your needs and we'll ensure you get the best service possible at all times. We take care of your plumbing problems as soon as they come up. Speak to our team today to get great customer service immediately!

"Very quick and great value"

David N on March 2025


Avatar for Neli Virtual Appliance Repair

Neli Virtual Appliance Repair

4.30(
577
)
Approved Pro

Neli Virtual Appliance Repair

4.30(
577
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
2016 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

NEW! Appliance Consultation – Just $35 Get expert advice before you spend on repairs or replacements. A Neli technician will evaluate your issue and help you decide if your appliance can be fixed—or if it’s time for a new one. Virtual Appliance Diagnosis and Repair - Just $45 Service Description: Diagnose or repair your appliance virtually—no need for anyone to enter your home. Neli’s certified technicians guide you step-by-step via secure video chat. How It Works: Book online at nelihome.com or call 833-876-0900 Connect with a tech through our video platform Diagnose or fix the issue in real time Get expert advice and confidence in your next steps What’s Included: Real-time video guidance from a certified technician Diagnosis of the issue OR full repair (when possible) Step-by-step guidance using your smartphone or tablet Safe, contact-free service - no one in your home Flexible scheduling—appointments available daily Perfect For: Appliance fixes HVAC troubleshooting DIY-savvy homeowners Saving time and money on service calls

"Super helpful"

Michele H on November 2025

NEW! Appliance Consultation – Just $35 Get expert advice before you spend on repairs or replacements. A Neli technician will evaluate your issue and help you decide if your appliance can be fixed—or if it’s time for a new one. Virtual Appliance Diagnosis and Repair - Just $45 Service Description: Diagnose or repair your appliance virtually—no need for anyone to enter your home. Neli’s certified technicians guide you step-by-step via secure video chat. How It Works: Book online at nelihome.com or call 833-876-0900 Connect with a tech through our video platform Diagnose or fix the issue in real time Get expert advice and confidence in your next steps What’s Included: Real-time video guidance from a certified technician Diagnosis of the issue OR full repair (when possible) Step-by-step guidance using your smartphone or tablet Safe, contact-free service - no one in your home Flexible scheduling—appointments available daily Perfect For: Appliance fixes HVAC troubleshooting DIY-savvy homeowners Saving time and money on service calls

"Super helpful"

Michele H on November 2025


Avatar for Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Indianapolis & Central Indiana

Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Indianapolis & Central Indiana

4.15(
450
)
Approved Pro

Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Indianapolis & Central Indiana

4.15(
450
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
1970 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Mr. Rooter® Plumbing delivers trusted, high-quality plumbing services to Indianapolis and the surrounding areas. With over 200 locations and more than five decades of experience, Mr. Rooter is a reliable name in the industry. If you're searching for a plumber in the Indianapolis area, Mr. Rooter has you covered. We offer live support to schedule emergency plumbing services quickly. From sewer backups and leaking or frozen pipes to clogged drains and water heater repairs, you can rely on us for fast, dependable solutions. Contact Mr. Rooter today for upfront pricing and easy scheduling.

"High 5 to Luke for his support plus his assitance and focus, and pleasant disposition to get the work done. I'm very pleassed and thankful."

Patricia F on October 2018

Mr. Rooter® Plumbing delivers trusted, high-quality plumbing services to Indianapolis and the surrounding areas. With over 200 locations and more than five decades of experience, Mr. Rooter is a reliable name in the industry. If you're searching for a plumber in the Indianapolis area, Mr. Rooter has you covered. We offer live support to schedule emergency plumbing services quickly. From sewer backups and leaking or frozen pipes to clogged drains and water heater repairs, you can rely on us for fast, dependable solutions. Contact Mr. Rooter today for upfront pricing and easy scheduling.

"High 5 to Luke for his support plus his assitance and focus, and pleasant disposition to get the work done. I'm very pleassed and thankful."

Patricia F on October 2018


Avatar for Premier Home Pros, LLC

Premier Home Pros, LLC

4.48(
62
)
Approved Pro

Premier Home Pros, LLC

4.48(
62
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
2022 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Premier Home Pros specializes in full bathroom remodels and installs finely crafted bathtubs and showers in as little as one day. With maintenance-free solutions and a variety of stunning designs to match your style, getting your dream bathroom has never been easier and more affordable. All of our products our backed by a full lifetime and service warranty program to offer customers the last system they will ever need. Get a FREE design consultation and transform your bathroom into a space that's not only functional, beautiful.

"Friendly and professional customer service. Product excellent and finished work to customer satisfaction. Would highly recommend."

Ronald P on May 2025

Premier Home Pros specializes in full bathroom remodels and installs finely crafted bathtubs and showers in as little as one day. With maintenance-free solutions and a variety of stunning designs to match your style, getting your dream bathroom has never been easier and more affordable. All of our products our backed by a full lifetime and service warranty program to offer customers the last system they will ever need. Get a FREE design consultation and transform your bathroom into a space that's not only functional, beautiful.

"Friendly and professional customer service. Product excellent and finished work to customer satisfaction. Would highly recommend."

Ronald P on May 2025

...
Showing 1-10 of 319
Bathtub Replacement questions, answered by experts

The diverter valve in your bathtub is responsible for diverting water between your tub spout and your shower head. If water comes out of both at the same time, you have a faulty diverter valve. You can have a plumber replace this for you, or you can replace it yourself if you have some experience working with plumbing fixtures.

Ensures correct plumbing connections and secure installation to prevent future water damage.

Of the two most common and affordable bathtub materials, acrylic is notably better. Though fiberglass is cheaper, it is also more prone to scratching, chipping, fading, and cracking. Acrylic holds up better to wear and tear, cleaning, and sun exposure; the slight cost increase is usually worth the increased longevity.

If you don’t caulk your bathtub, then there won’t be a watertight seal between your bathtub and the wall tile surrounding it. As a result, water can seep into the wall and the floor and cause the perfect breeding grounds for mold and mildew. Not only does this require costly repairs, but mold can be harmful to those breathing it. 

In many cases, a shower is a safer option than a tub and causes fewer slip-and-fall accidents. If safety is a concern, making your home safer is always worth it. However, the cost of a tub-to-shower conversion can be a deterrent to some people, as the average price is between $1,200 and $8,000.

The Carthage, IN homeowners’ guide to bathtub replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.