Get matched with top roofers in South Setauket, NY

"When you are doing a large project at your home and spending a large amount of money you want the job done correctly. D&S Roofing did the job correctly and were neat. I have a large roof with a lot of sections and skylights, so it took 5 days to complete. They showed up on time every day and discussed the entire job with me multiple times to make sure I was satisfied. They are very knowledgeable about roofing and use quality products and craftsmanship. The workers are professional and courteous. I am in the architecture/engineering field, and I built my home myself and I was very satisfied with this project and would feel comfortable recommending them and using them again, which I never do unless a company is excellent. Dominick, the owner, was on site every single morning to ensure I was happy, and things were going well. They are the only roofing company you need."

"Exterior team roofing Long Island did our siding. Josh was amazing to work with. He was professional, responsive, and he took a lot of time with us going over all the fine details. He was with us from start to finish. Exterior team roofing is cost effective, their work is beautiful, and it’s exactly what we envisioned for our home. We are now life long customers!"

"The initial meeting with John was promising. He was straightforward, easy to talk to, and quickly provided a quote without being pushy. I appreciated that he offered light recommendations without trying to upsell us. After that first meeting, I felt comfortable moving forward. I had John come out one more time so my boyfriend could meet him, ask a few more questions, and finalize the siding and color choices. The next morning, John texted early, saying he’d be by within the hour to pick up the $10,000 deposit. We were told materials would be ordered right away and the project would begin by the end of the month. However, as that date approached, we hadn’t heard anything. When we reached out, we were told it would be delayed by another week — and then again, another week. We were okay with some delays, but the complete lack of communication was extremely frustrating, especially since we needed to coordinate our work schedules. We were also told the work wouldn’t involve anything on the inside, but that turned out not to be true — which was a big issue since we have two pets. During the project, our flower beds and garden were completely destroyed. While some wear and tear is expected, there was no reason for a large boxwood bush to be crushed with a cinder block when there was clearly space to work around it. Several things were damaged, including blinds, window sills, a shelf, and part of the entrance flooring. While I understand that accidents happen during construction, what bothered us most was the lack of accountability. None of these issues were addressed until we specifically called them back out to deal with them. John never showed up for a single walkthrough, and to our surprise, the entire job was done by a different company altogether — not his own crew. That was something we hadn't anticipated, and unfortunately, we didn’t think to confirm it beforehand again our fault. The windows installed were low quality and very off-brand compared to what we expected. We had also discussed having decorative grills/grid lines in the windows, which were completely left out. In the end, while everything listed in the contract was technically delivered, the overall experience left a lot to be desired. The workmanship felt sloppy, communication was almost nonexistent, and the lack of oversight from the owner was disappointing. We definitely feel we overpaid for what we received. It’s partly on us for not being more proactive during the process, but someone who takes pride in their business would have at least done one final inspection or walkthrough."

"Power Home Remodeling did an amazing job replacing the windows in my home. From the very first visit, their team was knowledgeable, friendly, and focused on helping me find the right solutions for my space and budget. They explained the benefits of different window types without any pressure, and I felt confident I was making the right decision. The installation crew was professional, clean, and efficient — they showed up on time, worked quickly, and made sure everything was spotless before they left. The windows themselves look fantastic and have already made a noticeable difference in the comfort and energy efficiency of my home. If you’re thinking about upgrading your windows, I highly recommend Power Home Remodeling. Their service, quality, and attention to detail are second to none!"

"It went great! Eric and his crew did a great job! Showed up every day, on time, worked clean, didn't leave debris behind when the job was done. I even had them cut a new double window on the side of the house. He was the only contractor who did his best to give me the type of siding I wanted and brought me samples of what I wanted. Eric also replaced two attic fans on my roof prior to starting the siding job. I would use P17 Construction again, in a heartbeat. He was reasonably priced and did a great job! Thanks, Eric!"

"Project went as well as anyone could have hoped. Working with Selective Remodeling was a great decision. They were always responsive and explained everything along the way."

"We went over everything that was going to be done step by step both A.J. and Sam explained and guided us in the process. All came in at budget and in a timely manner. They were clean and reliable. I Will use them for my next project! ps. All of their recommendations for plumbing, electrical and painting were fantastic."

"Good work Price fair"

"Arjan helped me out with an urgent roof inspection. he was fast, reliable, friendly and best of all affordable. he didnt hesitate, and came by right away. on a moments notice. now that's good service"