Top-rated animal removal specialists.

Get matched with top animal removal specialists in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Enter your ZIP and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your animal removal project in Shelter Island Heights, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY SHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.7
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon25
    Verified animal removal services reviews

Find Animal removal specialists in Shelter Island Heights

Avatar for Exterminex Pest Control Inc

Exterminex Pest Control Inc

4.79(
300
)
Approved Pro

Exterminex Pest Control Inc

4.79(
300
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 95% of Angi customers
Recommended by 95% of HomeAdvisor customers
2000 years of experience

Residential & Commercial Pest Control. Exterminex Pest Control,Inc is your leading commercial/residential provider of pest management.From ants to raccoons we are your one stop shop.Our service area includes Nassau,Suffolk and the entire New York metro area. In addition to traditional chemical methods we offer a Go-Green Program which uses non-chemical approaches as the primary tool to control pests.

"They were fast and knowledgeable"

Robert O on May 2025

Residential & Commercial Pest Control. Exterminex Pest Control,Inc is your leading commercial/residential provider of pest management.From ants to raccoons we are your one stop shop.Our service area includes Nassau,Suffolk and the entire New York metro area. In addition to traditional chemical methods we offer a Go-Green Program which uses non-chemical approaches as the primary tool to control pests.

"They were fast and knowledgeable"

Robert O on May 2025


Avatar for PESTIFY LLC

PESTIFY LLC

4.97(
19
)
Approved Pro

PESTIFY LLC

4.97(
19
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
2017 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Pestify is a family-owned, 5-star–rated pest control company serving homes and businesses. We’re fully licensed and insured, and we use pet- and kid-friendly products. Our specialties include rodent control, nuisance wildlife removal, mosquito & tick programs, and year-round protection against ants, spiders, crickets, wasps, and more. Fast scheduling, clear pricing, and service you can trust.

"Nick and Rob did a great job and fixed my problem while they were here. They used cameras and equipment the big companies did not have and they were much cheaper. I highly recommend them."

Margaret g on February 2025

Pestify is a family-owned, 5-star–rated pest control company serving homes and businesses. We’re fully licensed and insured, and we use pet- and kid-friendly products. Our specialties include rodent control, nuisance wildlife removal, mosquito & tick programs, and year-round protection against ants, spiders, crickets, wasps, and more. Fast scheduling, clear pricing, and service you can trust.

"Nick and Rob did a great job and fixed my problem while they were here. They used cameras and equipment the big companies did not have and they were much cheaper. I highly recommend them."

Margaret g on February 2025


Avatar for Knockout Pest Control

Knockout Pest Control

4.72(
995
)

Knockout Pest Control

4.72(
995
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers

Knockout Pest Control, Inc. has been the premier pest management company in the metropolitan New York area since 1975. We provide effective, timely and professional pest management services to residential and commercial customers throughout Suffolk, Nassau, Westchester. Main Office: 1009 FRONT ST, UNIONDALE, NY 11553 and Rockland counties, and in Brooklyn, Queens, Manhattan, Bronx and Staten Island. You can depend on us to help solve all your pest control needs. Knockout Pest Control, Inc. is equally adept at addressing pest control issues for both homeowners and commercial enterprises, including apartment and office buildings, educational facilities, hospitals and adult homes. We have the experience, education and ability to control pest infestations, including Bees, Bed Bugs, Birds and a whole lot more. We get rid of the current problem and eliminate recurrences with both emergency services and monthly preventative care. What’s more, as one of the ten largest pest control companies in the region, our entire team is trained to control your pest problems. Each of our certified technicians has a minimum of 100 hours of classroom and field training and also receives ongoing classroom instruction. You can be assured of the safest and most advanced pest control methods. We also offer pest control solutions that are "green" or safe for the environment. We are a Quality Pro Green company. Less than 1% of the companies nationally earn this designation.

"Beware, tried to rip off my elderly parents. My parents entered into a MONTHLY contract with them for pest control. So they showed up at beginning of month to install some bait stations and said they would be back in a few weeks to check they were installed correctly. WE ARE STILL IN THE SAME MONTH. The tried to double charge the month of July to follow up on the initial installation. They kept saying "it's a monthly charge" and we told them WE HAD PAID FOR THIS MONTH... and then when we SHOWED THEM that we had already paid for July they changed to story to a "new fee".... There are other businesses that are not shady, use them and stay away from "knockout""

david r on July 2023

Knockout Pest Control, Inc. has been the premier pest management company in the metropolitan New York area since 1975. We provide effective, timely and professional pest management services to residential and commercial customers throughout Suffolk, Nassau, Westchester. Main Office: 1009 FRONT ST, UNIONDALE, NY 11553 and Rockland counties, and in Brooklyn, Queens, Manhattan, Bronx and Staten Island. You can depend on us to help solve all your pest control needs. Knockout Pest Control, Inc. is equally adept at addressing pest control issues for both homeowners and commercial enterprises, including apartment and office buildings, educational facilities, hospitals and adult homes. We have the experience, education and ability to control pest infestations, including Bees, Bed Bugs, Birds and a whole lot more. We get rid of the current problem and eliminate recurrences with both emergency services and monthly preventative care. What’s more, as one of the ten largest pest control companies in the region, our entire team is trained to control your pest problems. Each of our certified technicians has a minimum of 100 hours of classroom and field training and also receives ongoing classroom instruction. You can be assured of the safest and most advanced pest control methods. We also offer pest control solutions that are "green" or safe for the environment. We are a Quality Pro Green company. Less than 1% of the companies nationally earn this designation.

"Beware, tried to rip off my elderly parents. My parents entered into a MONTHLY contract with them for pest control. So they showed up at beginning of month to install some bait stations and said they would be back in a few weeks to check they were installed correctly. WE ARE STILL IN THE SAME MONTH. The tried to double charge the month of July to follow up on the initial installation. They kept saying "it's a monthly charge" and we told them WE HAD PAID FOR THIS MONTH... and then when we SHOWED THEM that we had already paid for July they changed to story to a "new fee".... There are other businesses that are not shady, use them and stay away from "knockout""

david r on July 2023


"Ray was everything. If you have a critter removal need, you've found your contact. He came immediately the day we called him and evaluated the situation (raccoons on our property) in a Raccoon Dundee style, which made us laugh! He has decades of experience in wildlife removal and it shows. He was efficient and told us exactly where and how many raccoons were on our roof and how long they'd been there. He gave us two options for removal and explained the benefits and explanation for using each one. One route involved a lower fee and focused on tactically chasing the animals away rather than trapping. We chose this option and so far the animals have not returned. Ray called us within a week to check in on the situation. We learned so much from this experience about raccoon behavior - it was an education combined with a removal! Call Ray, he's THE BEST!"

Katie W on June 2024

Catch A Critter Inc.- Wildlife Removal from homes and businesses.

"Ray was everything. If you have a critter removal need, you've found your contact. He came immediately the day we called him and evaluated the situation (raccoons on our property) in a Raccoon Dundee style, which made us laugh! He has decades of experience in wildlife removal and it shows. He was efficient and told us exactly where and how many raccoons were on our roof and how long they'd been there. He gave us two options for removal and explained the benefits and explanation for using each one. One route involved a lower fee and focused on tactically chasing the animals away rather than trapping. We chose this option and so far the animals have not returned. Ray called us within a week to check in on the situation. We learned so much from this experience about raccoon behavior - it was an education combined with a removal! Call Ray, he's THE BEST!"

Katie W on June 2024


Avatar for All About Bats & Wildlife Inc

All About Bats & Wildlife Inc

4.87(
47
)

All About Bats & Wildlife Inc

4.87(
47
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers

Humane Animal Removal, Prevention and Relocation Services. Serving Westchester County in NY and Fairfield County in CT since 1971 Bats, Squirrels, Raccoons, Woodchucks/Groundhogs, Skunks, Chipmunks, Mice, Snakes and more.... Owner Operated, Insured, and Licensed in NY by the DEC and in CT by the DEP. Unmarked Vehicles. Courteous Service. On-time Appointments. Fair Prices with Greatest Value. Please call for an honest evaluation and tailored solution to your wildlife concerns. Additional phone - (203) 984-4837. Additional contact: Reid Boone.

"Very responsive, unlike other companies I tried to contact. Reliable. Took several weeks to get all the squirrels, but Pat showed up every morning, even in 5 degree weather, to check the traps and reset them. He patched up the entry hole once they had all been evicted, and we have had no problems since. We definitely recommend All About Bats and Wildlife."

Lee A on January 2018

Humane Animal Removal, Prevention and Relocation Services. Serving Westchester County in NY and Fairfield County in CT since 1971 Bats, Squirrels, Raccoons, Woodchucks/Groundhogs, Skunks, Chipmunks, Mice, Snakes and more.... Owner Operated, Insured, and Licensed in NY by the DEC and in CT by the DEP. Unmarked Vehicles. Courteous Service. On-time Appointments. Fair Prices with Greatest Value. Please call for an honest evaluation and tailored solution to your wildlife concerns. Additional phone - (203) 984-4837. Additional contact: Reid Boone.

"Very responsive, unlike other companies I tried to contact. Reliable. Took several weeks to get all the squirrels, but Pat showed up every morning, even in 5 degree weather, to check the traps and reset them. He patched up the entry hole once they had all been evicted, and we have had no problems since. We definitely recommend All About Bats and Wildlife."

Lee A on January 2018


Arrow Exterminating

4.73(
213
)

Arrow Exterminating

4.73(
213
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers

Arrow Exterminating has been serving Long Islanders and New Yorkers for more than sixty years—since Bernard Stegman founded the company in 1947. Now under the management of his daughters; Jackie Grabin and Debby Tappan, Arrow is one of the largest pest control companies in the New York metropolitan area. There are several things that have always set Arrow apart: • We’ve always been willing to take on problems others won’t, and to do whatever it takes to help our clients. • We are always accessible. When Bernard Stegman founded the company, he gave clients his home phone number. We try to be just as accessible today, and always give free phone consultations. • We inspect every property carefully before deciding on treatment. We won’t just come in and spray chemicals indiscriminately. • We have a fulltime, board-certified entomologist on staff to help us understand the way insects behave, to make our treatments as effective as possible. • Our staff receives extensive training, and many have been with us for several decades. We know the quality of our staff determines the quality of our company, and we’re very proud of the team we have. Nassau County Consumer Affairs license: #HI84714.

"Mr Martinez came over and answered all my questions and was very thorough. He kept me informed through the whole process. They got all the raccoons removed and I am very happy with their work. I would highly recommend them."

margaret s on July 2020

Arrow Exterminating has been serving Long Islanders and New Yorkers for more than sixty years—since Bernard Stegman founded the company in 1947. Now under the management of his daughters; Jackie Grabin and Debby Tappan, Arrow is one of the largest pest control companies in the New York metropolitan area. There are several things that have always set Arrow apart: • We’ve always been willing to take on problems others won’t, and to do whatever it takes to help our clients. • We are always accessible. When Bernard Stegman founded the company, he gave clients his home phone number. We try to be just as accessible today, and always give free phone consultations. • We inspect every property carefully before deciding on treatment. We won’t just come in and spray chemicals indiscriminately. • We have a fulltime, board-certified entomologist on staff to help us understand the way insects behave, to make our treatments as effective as possible. • Our staff receives extensive training, and many have been with us for several decades. We know the quality of our staff determines the quality of our company, and we’re very proud of the team we have. Nassau County Consumer Affairs license: #HI84714.

"Mr Martinez came over and answered all my questions and was very thorough. He kept me informed through the whole process. They got all the raccoons removed and I am very happy with their work. I would highly recommend them."

margaret s on July 2020


NUISANCE WILDLIFE CONTROL

5.00(
31
)

NUISANCE WILDLIFE CONTROL

5.00(
31
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Owner-operated for over 30 years in the business for 44 years, I started trapping at 12-years of age. Cover all of Suffolk County.

"No problems, no issues ! A dependable professional. You will be pleased that this man is doing your animal relocation/removal. Do not hesitate to call him (Mike) ! ."

Vin D on January 2020

Owner-operated for over 30 years in the business for 44 years, I started trapping at 12-years of age. Cover all of Suffolk County.

"No problems, no issues ! A dependable professional. You will be pleased that this man is doing your animal relocation/removal. Do not hesitate to call him (Mike) ! ."

Vin D on January 2020


Trapper John

4.87(
119
)

Trapper John

4.87(
119
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 92% of Angi customers
Recommended by 92% of HomeAdvisor customers

Hi, my name is John, and I'm the founder of Trapper John Wildlife Management Services. I pride myself on old fashion values that were instilled by my mom. When I was a teenager of which I still can recall clearly today how important my first job was to me. It was more to me than just independence, but rather on pushing the limits of my job position. I didn't just want to be good at what I was doing, but rather the best at it. I then began understanding people, people’s needs and how vital customers are to the success of a brand. At the very same time I also began noticing how many companies lost the fundamentals of serving customers and from their Trapper John came to light. Since then (Trapper John) I have been featured in "The Brooklyn paper", The New York Times", on the popular "NHK" Japanese cable channel, reviews on "Yelp" and let’s not forget Angie's List. Through more than 20 years of experience in urban wildlife issues, we've proven that even the most difficult problems have a humane solution. Our clientele span a wide range of satisfied customers, including large organizations such as Verizon, Home Depot, and New York City governmental agencies, as well as numerous industrial, commercial, and residential consumers. We are "not" a pest control company that uses and/or sprays dangerous chemicals and poisons. We use a winning combination of modern high tech equipment and in depth wildlife experience. We only deal with "wildlife species". As a result, we provide you a solution that offers long term peace of mind. If you wish to contact us then, please only do so by via phone. Thank you

"Squirrels had gotten into our roof timbers and were scratching around making a racket. Every morning and every evening I could hear them above my bedroom and they were driving me crazy. I decided to contact Trapper John because of his Angie's List recommendations. He figured out where they had entered and put up a one way squirrel door so that when they came out to forage they would not be able to get back in. Sure enough, after a day or two, they all left. John then plugged up the hole. I would recommend his services to anyone who is having problems with invasive wildlife. He was very pleasant and informative about wildlife and other problems he noticed around the property."

Milly I on October 2019

Hi, my name is John, and I'm the founder of Trapper John Wildlife Management Services. I pride myself on old fashion values that were instilled by my mom. When I was a teenager of which I still can recall clearly today how important my first job was to me. It was more to me than just independence, but rather on pushing the limits of my job position. I didn't just want to be good at what I was doing, but rather the best at it. I then began understanding people, people’s needs and how vital customers are to the success of a brand. At the very same time I also began noticing how many companies lost the fundamentals of serving customers and from their Trapper John came to light. Since then (Trapper John) I have been featured in "The Brooklyn paper", The New York Times", on the popular "NHK" Japanese cable channel, reviews on "Yelp" and let’s not forget Angie's List. Through more than 20 years of experience in urban wildlife issues, we've proven that even the most difficult problems have a humane solution. Our clientele span a wide range of satisfied customers, including large organizations such as Verizon, Home Depot, and New York City governmental agencies, as well as numerous industrial, commercial, and residential consumers. We are "not" a pest control company that uses and/or sprays dangerous chemicals and poisons. We use a winning combination of modern high tech equipment and in depth wildlife experience. We only deal with "wildlife species". As a result, we provide you a solution that offers long term peace of mind. If you wish to contact us then, please only do so by via phone. Thank you

"Squirrels had gotten into our roof timbers and were scratching around making a racket. Every morning and every evening I could hear them above my bedroom and they were driving me crazy. I decided to contact Trapper John because of his Angie's List recommendations. He figured out where they had entered and put up a one way squirrel door so that when they came out to forage they would not be able to get back in. Sure enough, after a day or two, they all left. John then plugged up the hole. I would recommend his services to anyone who is having problems with invasive wildlife. He was very pleasant and informative about wildlife and other problems he noticed around the property."

Milly I on October 2019


"The service was great and the employee was very professional and helpful. Thank you for your quick response."

Andrew A on August 2020

Full service pest control company with licensed uniformed technicians. Our service contracts are reasonably priced and come with a guarantee.

"The service was great and the employee was very professional and helpful. Thank you for your quick response."

Andrew A on August 2020


Avatar for Ace Walco Termite & Pest Control

Ace Walco Termite & Pest Control

4.85(
27
)

Ace Walco Termite & Pest Control

4.85(
27
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Family owned and operated, Ace Walco Termite and Pest Control has been a leader in pest management since 1936. Our goal of 100% customer satisfaction has resulted in effective & environmentally conscious treatments, directed by our staff entomologist, as well as prompt & punctual service provided by our trained and licensed technicians. We ask: When is good for you? Scheduling a visit from one of our knowledgeable and thorough inspectors does not bind you to any service but will always prove to be insightful. We are looking out for your best interests! Whether you need an immediate inspection or would prefer to take the proactive approach of preventative treatment, Ace Walco can help!

"I have been with them for 38 years and they have been reliable and nice to work with."

Dominick M on August 2023

Family owned and operated, Ace Walco Termite and Pest Control has been a leader in pest management since 1936. Our goal of 100% customer satisfaction has resulted in effective & environmentally conscious treatments, directed by our staff entomologist, as well as prompt & punctual service provided by our trained and licensed technicians. We ask: When is good for you? Scheduling a visit from one of our knowledgeable and thorough inspectors does not bind you to any service but will always prove to be insightful. We are looking out for your best interests! Whether you need an immediate inspection or would prefer to take the proactive approach of preventative treatment, Ace Walco can help!

"I have been with them for 38 years and they have been reliable and nice to work with."

Dominick M on August 2023

...
Showing 1-10 of 93
Animal Removal questions, answered by experts

DIY animal removal is rarely a good idea and is not advised for many reasons. First, these types of animals can carry diseases and, therefore, pose a health risk to you, your family, and your pets if mishandled. Second, depending on your city or municipality, it may be illegal to remove or handle wildlife yourself. 

Sealing your home against these animals yourself is also a bad idea. Trapping an animal under your house will cause odor and insect problems when it passes away. 

You might be tempted to call your local municipality to remove animals from your property, such as a groundhog burrowing in your yard or raccoons getting into your trash cans. However, they typically only remove domestic animals like dogs and cats from properties, or sick and injured wildlife that pose a public safety risk or health threat, such as a rabid animal. They typically do not capture or remove healthy wildlife.

Animal removal professionals have the tools, knowledge, and skills to trap and remove wild animals adequately and humanely. They also can relocate them correctly.

Ensure proper ventilation, address leaks, and conduct regular inspections.

Whereas a honeybee can only sting you once, a yellow jacket can sting you multiple times because they don’t leave stingers in the skin. In the unfortunate case that you get stung by a yellow jacket, it’s important to react calmly and quickly. Immediately ice the affected area until the swelling subsides. You may also take an antihistamine if necessary. If you experience an allergic reaction to a yellow jacket sting or have been stung several times, seek medical care right away. 

Removal typically takes 30 minutes to 1 hour per item, depending on accessibility and size.

The Shelter Island Heights, NY homeowners’ guide to animal removal services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

What do you need done? We’ll find top pros.
  • 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
  • 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
  • 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"