Top-rated locksmiths.

Get matched with top locksmiths in Pine Island, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your locksmith service project in Pine Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY PINE ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.9
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon27
    Verified locksmith services reviews

Verified Reviews for Locksmith Service pros in Pine Island, NY

*The Angi rating for Locksmith Service companies in Pine Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Locksmith Service needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Locksmith Service companies in Pine Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Locksmith Service needs.

Last update on May 03, 2026

Find Locksmiths in Pine Island

Murphy's Lock & Key
4.9(
52
)
LocksmithLocksmith - AutoLocksmith - For Business

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2008

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"I should have just done it myself. A lot of the problem was mine. I booked them, thinking I needed 5 locks done, but it turned out I only needed 1. They were very patient with my fluctuating understanding of my needs. The fee to come out is worth it if they're doing 5 locks, not if they're doing 1 lock. I think this is true for all locksmiths. The lock was replaced quickly; that part of the job was fine. I wasn't thrilled with the hard sell. Nothing against them, but, if you only have 1 to replace, go to Home Depot."
Recommended by96%of homeowners
Request Quote
Murphy's Locksmith, Inc.
4.7(
90
)
LocksmithLocksmith - AutoLocksmith - For Business

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2009

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Mark Murphy was outstanding to deal with. I'm so happy we found him. I had (5) locks re-keyed and one lock changed to a digital lock. Going forward he will be my go to locksmith! He was super patient with me and very knowledgeable. Also fairly priced. HIGHLY recommend!"
Response time6 hrs
25 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by95%of homeowners
Request Quote
Avatar for SafeStreets - ADT Authorized Provider
SafeStreets - ADT Authorized Provider
4.8(
320
)
Security Safe - Install

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved (Corporate)

In business since 2010

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"I would like to recognize employee Doug A at SafeStreet/ADT. We’ve had an old security system sitting in our house for over 15 years without service or functionality. He took the time to explain the differences between how the old systems work and how the new systems work. He was patient with us, and we are happy customers."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+1

6 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by94%of homeowners
Request Quote
Avatar for ADT
ADT
4.5(
878
)
Security Safe - Install

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved (Corporate)

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 1874

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Walter and Glen at Protect Your Home Group with ADT are the best people to talk to in terms of security alarm. Being a locksmith myself I know how important it is to deal with the right people. I referred a lot of customers to them and so far they are happy with their service. I myself got one for my house. Thank you for a consistent service and great deal."
Home Security Essentials
Smart Home Security
Cameras
Our Team
Home Security Essentials

+35

62 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by89%of homeowners
Request Quote
Avatar for Kingdom Cabinets LLC
Kingdom Cabinets LLC
5.0(
7
)
Hardware, Latches & Tracks (Door) - Repair or Replace

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2023

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"These guys are the best. Highly recommend them. Top notch work done."
Full Reno
New Kitchen
New Kitchen
Kitchen Remodel
Response time2 hrs
Response rate100%
Recommended by83%of homeowners
Request Quote
Avatar for John Carpenter Craftsmanship and Design
John Carpenter Craftsmanship and Design
4.2(
5
)
Hardware, Latches & Tracks (Door) - Repair or Replace

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1998

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"Excellent communication and excellent job done. Would definitely hire again."
Distance misjudged.
Like it never happened.
Response time3 days
Response rate100%
4 neighbors recently requested a quote
Request Quote
Avatar for Re-Entry Lock and Safe, LLC
Re-Entry Lock and Safe, LLC
4.8(
88
)
Hardware, Latches & Tracks (Door) - Repair or ReplaceLocksmithLocksmith - Auto+1 more

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 2020

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"Although the locksmith came later than he said he would he was very polite and very professional."
Smart Locks
Smart Locks
Smart Locks
Smart lock
Commercial

+19

Response time3 hrs
Recommended by96%of homeowners
Request Quote
...
Showing 1-10 of 230
Locksmiths questions, answered by experts

If part of the key is protruding out of the lock, you can use a pair of needle-nosed pliers or tweezers to gently turn the key in the lock to open the door. If the key is fully inserted into the lock, you may also be able to use a key extractor to help turn the key into the unlocked position. 

But if the key breaks off halfway into the lock or you simply can’t reach it to help engage the unlocking mechanisms, you should probably call a professional.

Many local hardware stores have the equipment to copy basic keys at a low cost. Some locations may have freestanding machines where you can pick out a blank and insert it and your original key into the duplicating machine.

There are several situations when you should change or replace your locks to ensure your home's security. Key moments include moving into a new house, after a break-in or attempted break-in, or when a roommate or anyone else with a key moves out. It is also wise to change your locks if you lose your keys, especially if they have an address attached or you suspect they were stolen. Finally, if your locks are old, broken, worn out, or have become unreliable, they should be replaced.

Rekeying is typically cheaper than replacing locks. Professional rekeying costs between $40 and $160, sometimes with an additional fee of $15 to $40 per lock. A locksmith's hourly rate averages around $75. If you do it yourself, a rekeying kit can cost as little as $10. In contrast, replacing a lock costs between $130 and $500, with an average of around $315, depending on the hardware and lock type. Rekeying is a simpler process that changes the key for your existing lock without replacing the hardware. It is a good option if you have a quality lock that works well, you've recently moved, you've lost a key, or you need a quick security upgrade. The best choice depends on the condition of your current locks.

In some cases this is possible, but it’s not advisable as the screwdriver is likely to leave marks all over the wall and a noticeable dent on the door. Move slowly and carefully if you have to use this method, and consider calling an emergency locksmith right away instead of trying to break in.

The Pine Island, NY homeowners’ guide to locksmith services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles