Get matched with top locksmiths in Pine Island, NY

Pine Island homeowners rate locksmiths in our network

4.9

(27 reviews)

Top-rated locksmiths.

Need a pro for your locksmith service project in Pine Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

Verified Reviews for Locksmith Service pros in Pine Island, NY

*The Angi rating for Locksmith Service companies in Pine Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Locksmith Service needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Locksmith Service companies in Pine Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Locksmith Service needs.

Last update on October 16, 2025

Find Locksmiths in Pine Island

Murphy's Locksmith, Inc.
4.7(
89
)

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2009

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Mark Murphy was outstanding to deal with. I'm so happy we found him. I had (5) locks re-keyed and one lock changed to a digital lock. Going forward he will be my go to locksmith! He was super patient with me and very knowledgeable. Also fairly priced. HIGHLY recommend!"
Response time6 hrs
21 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by96%of homeowners
Request Quote
Avatar for 24-7 Access Granted LLC
24-7 Access Granted LLC
5.0(
13
)

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 2024

Emergency services offered

Small jobs welcome

"Dante was SOoooooo fantastic I wanted to write this review awhile ago but I've been so busy running around that's how I misplaced my keys originally in the first place. However, Dante came to the rescue. If you're ever in need of a locksmith Dante is the MAN!!!!!!!"
Response time6 hrs
Response rate92%
Recommended by25%of homeowners
Request Quote
Avatar for 711 Locksmith & Security
711 Locksmith & Security
5.0(
4
)

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 2015

Emergency services offered

Credit card accepted

"It went well. He was very professional, straight forward, and fast. I would definitely recommend him to my friends and family. Security is definitely important and this locksmith company gives you piece of mind. 5 stars"
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Request Quote
Avatar for M&D Locks and Keys
M&D Locks and Keys
4.6(
5
)

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Emergency services offered

Credit card accepted

"I was accidentally locked out of my bathroom that morning.    
Everything went very well with M&D when I called for their help.  The customer rep who answered the telephone had great customer service skills.  M&D were quick to respond and they managed my expectations around the locksmith's time of arrival.  M&D sent a very competent worker named Daniel who assessed the situation and described all my options and prices before moving forward.  Of course, I would have liked the total price to be lower but the locksmith was so professional that I decided to replace other old/missing locks in the house as well.  
Daniel went back to the store, collected the additional door knobs and locks and returned to complete the rest of the job. He moved quickly and efficiently and was very pleasant to interact with.  In addition, he gave me quick tutorials on a couple of the new locks.  I was very pleased to have so much work done after having postponing the lock changes for so long.  M&D turned my bathroom lock-out accident into a positive experience! 
"
store
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Request Quote
Showing 1-10 of 22

FAQs for locksmith service projects in Pine Island, NY

The cost to hire a locksmith ranges from $50 to $200 but can cost up to $500. Cost factors vary but may include your location, the urgency of the request (emergencies typically cost more), and the complexity and size of the job. With many homes moving from standard mechanical locks to smart and electronic security and locking systems, locksmiths may charge more for the expertise and equipment needed to do the work required by these systems. 

Yes, many locksmiths can usually program a key fob for your car. The cost for car dealerships to replace lost or stolen key fobs can get expensive. Alternatively, check with a local professional locksmith to review your options and prices. 

Typically, it’s cheaper to rekey your existing locks than to install new ones. The cost to rekey ranges from $80 to $160, while the cost to change locks ranges from $50 to $200, depending on the type of locks. The value of rekeying vs. replacing locks depends on the condition of your locks and whether or not you already want to replace them.

Yes, the cost to hire a reliable, professional locksmith is worth it, especially if you have a larger job like replacing all the locks and doorknobs in your house. If you’re locked out of your home or car, a locksmith has the tools and the knowledge to get you back in without risking damaging your property. You can also hire a locksmith to install or replace a doorknob or lock.

The Pine Island, NY homeowners’ guide to locksmith services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles