Top-rated locksmiths.

Get matched with top locksmiths in Oyster Bay, NY

There are 4 highly-rated local locksmiths.

Need a pro for your locksmith service project in Oyster Bay, NY?
Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY OYSTER BAY, NY HOMEOWNERS

Average homeowner rating star icon4.7
Average homeowner rating
Verified reviews icon55
Verified locksmith services reviews

Locksmiths in Oyster Bay

Avatar for Urgent Locksmith LLC
Urgent Locksmith LLC
1454 East 23 Street
4.61(
33
)
Approved Pro
Urgent Locksmith LLC
1454 East 23 Street
4.61(
33
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
84 local quotes requested
9 years of experience

Urgent Locksmith, LLC was established in New York. The company holds a Locksmith license from New York City Department Consumer Affairs, and specializes in locks, safes, vehicles, and security. ​ We consistently offer reputable security systems to all of our valued customers. High quality locksmith service has been our top priority from the moment we opened our location.

"DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY. They literally wanted to charge me 400 dollars for a lock that’s at Home Depot for 40 dollars to install. The technician literally showed me where the lock was from and no price and proceeded to say it is 400 and a total of 450 to install. Upon me looking it up on Home Depot website and discovering it was 40 dollars all of a sudden the locksmith stated oh well how much you want to pay and if you pay me cash I can do it. As a woman I get that you think you can run game on me and me bot doing my due diligence and even with inflation - that kind of mark up has no sense. He then proceeded to charge me a service fee which will be disputed with my credit company and I will be also putting in a complaint with BBB and the department of consumer affairs"

Tanisha C on May 2024

Urgent Locksmith, LLC was established in New York. The company holds a Locksmith license from New York City Department Consumer Affairs, and specializes in locks, safes, vehicles, and security. ​ We consistently offer reputable security systems to all of our valued customers. High quality locksmith service has been our top priority from the moment we opened our location.

"DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY. They literally wanted to charge me 400 dollars for a lock that’s at Home Depot for 40 dollars to install. The technician literally showed me where the lock was from and no price and proceeded to say it is 400 and a total of 450 to install. Upon me looking it up on Home Depot website and discovering it was 40 dollars all of a sudden the locksmith stated oh well how much you want to pay and if you pay me cash I can do it. As a woman I get that you think you can run game on me and me bot doing my due diligence and even with inflation - that kind of mark up has no sense. He then proceeded to charge me a service fee which will be disputed with my credit company and I will be also putting in a complaint with BBB and the department of consumer affairs"

Tanisha C on May 2024


Key Craft LLC
29 HIGHLAND DOWN,
New on HomeAdvisorNew on Angi
Approved Pro
Key Craft LLC
29 HIGHLAND DOWN,
New on AngiNew on HomeAdvisor
Approved Pro
3 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business!

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business!


America's Key To Security, Inc.
27 Euston Road South
4.84(
537
)
Approved Pro
America's Key To Security, Inc.
27 Euston Road South
4.84(
537
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers
73 local quotes requested

We are a security company providing quality service to Homeowners and Businesses in the New York area. We pride ourselves on expert installations. We offer a Lifetime Warranty on all our installations

"Couldn't open garage door. Lost the key. Contacted Angi on internet. Was able to get someonr to come within half hour. Mitch was the locksmith who came from America's key to security inc. He was very friendly and professional. The door was a little heavy for me to lift up so I thought it was locked. Mike just came and lifted it up. He was kind and friendly."

Shirley D T on July 2025

We are a security company providing quality service to Homeowners and Businesses in the New York area. We pride ourselves on expert installations. We offer a Lifetime Warranty on all our installations

"Couldn't open garage door. Lost the key. Contacted Angi on internet. Was able to get someonr to come within half hour. Mitch was the locksmith who came from America's key to security inc. He was very friendly and professional. The door was a little heavy for me to lift up so I thought it was locked. Mike just came and lifted it up. He was kind and friendly."

Shirley D T on July 2025


Locksmith Men Nassau is based in Plainview, New York and service all Nassau County.


MNE Auto Keys
660
No reviews
MNE Auto Keys
660
No reviews
Free onsite estimate

24/7 mobile assistance Emergency lockouts assistance Car keys replacements All additional locksmith services

24/7 mobile assistance Emergency lockouts assistance Car keys replacements All additional locksmith services


Finelines striping
No reviews
Finelines striping
No reviews

We are two brothers who enjoy taking our jobs seriously and efficiently. Our customers satisfaction is our one and only concern. No job is too large or too small. Please feel free to reach out anytime! -Finelines LLC.

We are two brothers who enjoy taking our jobs seriously and efficiently. Our customers satisfaction is our one and only concern. No job is too large or too small. Please feel free to reach out anytime! -Finelines LLC.


Schneider Lock and Key
No reviews
Schneider Lock and Key
No reviews
22 years of experience

We are a family owned and operated for over 25 years in Business.

We are a family owned and operated for over 25 years in Business.


Donovan Property Service
No reviews
Donovan Property Service
No reviews

Full plumbing, drain cleaning, electrical and all handyman needs service 24/7, 7 days a week, 365 days a year.

Full plumbing, drain cleaning, electrical and all handyman needs service 24/7, 7 days a week, 365 days a year.


CM MAINTENANCE
No reviews
CM MAINTENANCE
No reviews

With over 8 years of competitive experience maintaining & Operating NYC Public Schools & large variety of Commercial Buildings throughout the five boroughs as well as LI, Owner Cole White carries this experience with him & his Crew to give you the results & peace of mind you deserve.

With over 8 years of competitive experience maintaining & Operating NYC Public Schools & large variety of Commercial Buildings throughout the five boroughs as well as LI, Owner Cole White carries this experience with him & his Crew to give you the results & peace of mind you deserve.


BeeOpen Locksmith
10 Townsend Ct. (Mobile Service - Not A Store)
No reviews
BeeOpen Locksmith
10 Townsend Ct. (Mobile Service - Not A Store)
No reviews
20 years of experience

Secure or open your house, business, car or safe. Simplify your life by making one key open all your home or business doors. Our master locksmith has over 20 years in the business fixing, installing and modifying locks, doors, keys and safes for businesses and households throughout New York and now brings his skills to Central New Jersey.

Secure or open your house, business, car or safe. Simplify your life by making one key open all your home or business doors. Our master locksmith has over 20 years in the business fixing, installing and modifying locks, doors, keys and safes for businesses and households throughout New York and now brings his skills to Central New Jersey.

...
Showing 1-10 of 203

FAQs for locksmith service projects in Oyster Bay, NY

The cost to hire a locksmith ranges from $50 to $200 but can cost up to $500. Cost factors vary but may include your location, the urgency of the request (emergencies typically cost more), and the complexity and size of the job. With many homes moving from standard mechanical locks to smart and electronic security and locking systems, locksmiths may charge more for the expertise and equipment needed to do the work required by these systems. 

Yes, many locksmiths can usually program a key fob for your car. The cost for car dealerships to replace lost or stolen key fobs can get expensive. Alternatively, check with a local professional locksmith to review your options and prices. 

Typically, it’s cheaper to rekey your existing locks than to install new ones. The cost to rekey ranges from $80 to $160, while the cost to change locks ranges from $50 to $200, depending on the type of locks. The value of rekeying vs. replacing locks depends on the condition of your locks and whether or not you already want to replace them.

Yes, the cost to hire a reliable, professional locksmith is worth it, especially if you have a larger job like replacing all the locks and doorknobs in your house. If you’re locked out of your home or car, a locksmith has the tools and the knowledge to get you back in without risking damaging your property. You can also hire a locksmith to install or replace a doorknob or lock.

The Oyster Bay, NY homeowners’ guide to locksmith services
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
Woman checks her phone while opening the deadbolt on door
Oct 3, 2024
Oct 3, 2024
How much it costs to install a deadbolt lock depends mainly on the type of hardware you purchase and whether you DIY or hire a professional locksmith.
Mother embracing her children when coming home
May 2, 2025
May 2, 2025
Installing new door locks every seven years can make a home safer and possibly earn you a home insurance discount. Here’s how much it costs to change a lock.
Couple arriving at a vacation home
Jan 7, 2025
Jan 7, 2025
Copying a key can be affordable, depending on the type. Learn about the cost of copying a key and what to do when you need a replacement.
Family walking in front door
Oct 7, 2024
Oct 7, 2024
Know the 5 common signs your locks may have been tampered with and take immediate action to improve home security and prevent a burglary.
Keyless door lock
Oct 14, 2024
Oct 14, 2024
Which is better for protecting your home—smart locks or traditional locks? Use this guide to weigh their differences and decide which is better for you.
woman using phone to smart lock house
Oct 16, 2024
Oct 16, 2024
If you’re wondering if smart locks are safe, we've broken down the pros and cons of smart locks to help you decide if they could add more security to your home.
Share project details to get started.