Top-rated locksmiths.

Get matched with top locksmiths in Oyster Bay, NY

Enter your ZIP and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your locksmith service project in Oyster Bay, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY OYSTER BAY, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.7
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon55
    Verified locksmith services reviews

Find Locksmiths in Oyster Bay

America's Key To Security, Inc.

4.84(
551
)
Approved Pro

America's Key To Security, Inc.

4.84(
551
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: True professional
1981 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

We are a security company providing quality service to Homeowners and Businesses in the New York area. We pride ourselves on expert installations. We offer a Lifetime Warranty on all our installations

"The professional (Mitch) tackled a difficult job. These were heavy patio doors, installed over 25 years ago, with damaged and worn tracking. They are now sliding easily and more securely with a new, secure lock. He is now putting a new lock on our front door. He is reliable, efficient and extremely competent."

William C on November 2025

We are a security company providing quality service to Homeowners and Businesses in the New York area. We pride ourselves on expert installations. We offer a Lifetime Warranty on all our installations

"The professional (Mitch) tackled a difficult job. These were heavy patio doors, installed over 25 years ago, with damaged and worn tracking. They are now sliding easily and more securely with a new, secure lock. He is now putting a new lock on our front door. He is reliable, efficient and extremely competent."

William C on November 2025


Avatar for Aaron's Locksmith Service

Aaron's Locksmith Service

4.93(
22
)
Approved Pro

Aaron's Locksmith Service

4.93(
22
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
2015 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

At Aaron's Locksmith, our mission is to provide our customers with exceptional workmanship, excellent customer service, and extraordinary professionalism. Locally owned and operated, we are backed with years of experience. We provide our services as a continuing part of our focused approach and quality professional service. With fast response times, special tools, and well-trained locksmiths, we can assist you with your automotive, commercial, and residential locksmith needs. We offer same-day 24-hour emergency locksmith service so you will not be waiting for a long time. We service the entire Garden City, NY, the Massapequa, NY area, the Rockville Centre, NY area and beyond.

"Excellent job very pleasantly, quicky and professionally done."

Rick U on January 2022

At Aaron's Locksmith, our mission is to provide our customers with exceptional workmanship, excellent customer service, and extraordinary professionalism. Locally owned and operated, we are backed with years of experience. We provide our services as a continuing part of our focused approach and quality professional service. With fast response times, special tools, and well-trained locksmiths, we can assist you with your automotive, commercial, and residential locksmith needs. We offer same-day 24-hour emergency locksmith service so you will not be waiting for a long time. We service the entire Garden City, NY, the Massapequa, NY area, the Rockville Centre, NY area and beyond.

"Excellent job very pleasantly, quicky and professionally done."

Rick U on January 2022


Avatar for Unlocked by Ari LLC

Unlocked by Ari LLC

4.79(
24
)
Approved Pro

Unlocked by Ari LLC

4.79(
24
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
2022 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality and customer service that we provide to meet every consumer's needs. It is our mission to provide excellent customer service from start to completion of a project. To understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a personal and professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety and quality, regardless of how large or small the job.

"Ari was professional and did the job asap with no problems. Hire with confidence. "

Martin P on November 2025

We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality and customer service that we provide to meet every consumer's needs. It is our mission to provide excellent customer service from start to completion of a project. To understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a personal and professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety and quality, regardless of how large or small the job.

"Ari was professional and did the job asap with no problems. Hire with confidence. "

Martin P on November 2025


"Provided excellent, expert service. Exceeded expectations. Highest recommendation. Very friendly. Committed to providing the best service."

ANDREAS H on August 2023

Total door and locksmith security, safe work as well as alarms,camera systems,gate operators for your house,business We are 25 years in business,and have a storefront location call for store hours

"Provided excellent, expert service. Exceeded expectations. Highest recommendation. Very friendly. Committed to providing the best service."

ANDREAS H on August 2023


Avatar for Guardian Protection

Guardian Protection

4.74(
2,120
)

Guardian Protection

4.74(
2,120
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers

Protecting homes and businesses since 1950, Guardian Protection is one of the nation's largest and most highly regarded security companies. We provide smart technology, 24/7 professional monitoring, and peace of mind to hundreds of thousands of customers. Our products are installed by experts, monitored by real people, and truly make a difference. We do what we do because of one simple truth: life is better when it's safe.

"We hired Guardian to install our security system at our Washington, DC, business. The service and quality of the work was horrible. We had cameras and an alarm system installed; it was a relatively large system. They outsource most of the work to various vendors. They could not manage their vendors; what was supposed to take a week took two months. The sales rep did not return calls, and you could never get anyone in management on the phone. Random people would show up at unannounced times. The few things that an actual Guardian employee did were they made a huge mess of our newly remodeled office and were rude to our staff. We have offices in five markets across the US and have high security at each; we have never had such a poor experience."

William M on December 2024

Protecting homes and businesses since 1950, Guardian Protection is one of the nation's largest and most highly regarded security companies. We provide smart technology, 24/7 professional monitoring, and peace of mind to hundreds of thousands of customers. Our products are installed by experts, monitored by real people, and truly make a difference. We do what we do because of one simple truth: life is better when it's safe.

"We hired Guardian to install our security system at our Washington, DC, business. The service and quality of the work was horrible. We had cameras and an alarm system installed; it was a relatively large system. They outsource most of the work to various vendors. They could not manage their vendors; what was supposed to take a week took two months. The sales rep did not return calls, and you could never get anyone in management on the phone. Random people would show up at unannounced times. The few things that an actual Guardian employee did were they made a huge mess of our newly remodeled office and were rude to our staff. We have offices in five markets across the US and have high security at each; we have never had such a poor experience."

William M on December 2024


ABLE LOCKSMITH INC

4.97(
39
)

ABLE LOCKSMITH INC

4.97(
39
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

In our third generation of service, we here at Able Locksmith Inc. continue to strive for perfection since 1968. Providing service to the local community as well as the entire Metro New York area and surrounding vicinities. Our premier services include but are not limited to closed circuit monitoring systems available with off premises viewing. Access control with technologies such as magnets, electric locks, biometric and retina scans. Additionally, we sell and service safes, burglar alarms, and the highest security locks available. Currently we are the only authorized Mul-T-Lock interactive dealer on Long Island. If it has to do with security, we do it. For a more comprehensive list of our premier services. Able Locksmith Inc. has been there and will continue to be there for your security needs 24 hours a day, 365 1/4 days a year. Above all we are committed to excellence in customer service for both homeowners and commercial cliental. Offering skilled technicians who are consistently updated on the newest innovations and technological advances in the locksmithing field. We use the highest quality materials, installed and backed by a limited one-year warranty from us, even when the manufacturer only offers their standard ninety-days. Your safety and piece of mind is always our top concern, not stopping until achieved. Coupled with our aforementioned goals, we guarantee prompt courteous service that is sure to meet or exceed your standards. You deserve the best for your family and business. Let Able Locksmith Inc. show you how to get just that. “Able is Key”TM

"Chad was on time, professional a completely competent. He went over and above and provided quality repairs. If all contractors were like Chad all of our lives would be a lot easier."

Gregory P on February 2022

In our third generation of service, we here at Able Locksmith Inc. continue to strive for perfection since 1968. Providing service to the local community as well as the entire Metro New York area and surrounding vicinities. Our premier services include but are not limited to closed circuit monitoring systems available with off premises viewing. Access control with technologies such as magnets, electric locks, biometric and retina scans. Additionally, we sell and service safes, burglar alarms, and the highest security locks available. Currently we are the only authorized Mul-T-Lock interactive dealer on Long Island. If it has to do with security, we do it. For a more comprehensive list of our premier services. Able Locksmith Inc. has been there and will continue to be there for your security needs 24 hours a day, 365 1/4 days a year. Above all we are committed to excellence in customer service for both homeowners and commercial cliental. Offering skilled technicians who are consistently updated on the newest innovations and technological advances in the locksmithing field. We use the highest quality materials, installed and backed by a limited one-year warranty from us, even when the manufacturer only offers their standard ninety-days. Your safety and piece of mind is always our top concern, not stopping until achieved. Coupled with our aforementioned goals, we guarantee prompt courteous service that is sure to meet or exceed your standards. You deserve the best for your family and business. Let Able Locksmith Inc. show you how to get just that. “Able is Key”TM

"Chad was on time, professional a completely competent. He went over and above and provided quality repairs. If all contractors were like Chad all of our lives would be a lot easier."

Gregory P on February 2022


White's Locksmith

4.97(
58
)

White's Locksmith

4.97(
58
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

White Locksmiths has primarily earned most of its clients by word of mouth. White Locksmiths has learned from its competitors mistakes and know that in a town like ours it doesn’t matter how many business cards you hand out if you treat people wrong word gets out, and quick! Just know when you call White Locksmiths you will not be treated like a number or a paycheck . We will not sell you products that do nothing but give you a false sense of security, like that other White locksmith. We consider it to be the biggest compliment that can be given to have one of our customers refer us to one of their friends, family members or co-workers.Commercial service We are the White Locksmith company that not only shows up, but shows up on time. The locksmith that not only drills and installs lock hardware, but also cleans up the mess left behind. We take that final step that separates us from the other locksmiths in White. Additional 24 hour emergency phone number: 718-639-4101

White Locksmiths has primarily earned most of its clients by word of mouth. White Locksmiths has learned from its competitors mistakes and know that in a town like ours it doesn’t matter how many business cards you hand out if you treat people wrong word gets out, and quick! Just know when you call White Locksmiths you will not be treated like a number or a paycheck . We will not sell you products that do nothing but give you a false sense of security, like that other White locksmith. We consider it to be the biggest compliment that can be given to have one of our customers refer us to one of their friends, family members or co-workers.Commercial service We are the White Locksmith company that not only shows up, but shows up on time. The locksmith that not only drills and installs lock hardware, but also cleans up the mess left behind. We take that final step that separates us from the other locksmiths in White. Additional 24 hour emergency phone number: 718-639-4101


"Job was well done-very satisfied"

Genevieve N on April 2020

Installation of doors and Hardware

"Job was well done-very satisfied"

Genevieve N on April 2020


Accurate Locksmith

4.87(
30
)

Accurate Locksmith

4.87(
30
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers

Accurate Locksmith Security Center is Ramsey NJ’s trusted commercial and residential locksmith specializing in lock changes, deadbolts and much more! Established in 1963, Accurate Locksmith is the only brick and mortar locksmith in Ramsey. We are insured, licensed and bonded in the state of New Jersey. A full service locksmith, our showroom is stocked with safes, residential and commercial hardware. We have over 5,700 different residential, commercial and automotive key blanks in stock.

Accurate Locksmith Security Center is Ramsey NJ’s trusted commercial and residential locksmith specializing in lock changes, deadbolts and much more! Established in 1963, Accurate Locksmith is the only brick and mortar locksmith in Ramsey. We are insured, licensed and bonded in the state of New Jersey. A full service locksmith, our showroom is stocked with safes, residential and commercial hardware. We have over 5,700 different residential, commercial and automotive key blanks in stock.


America's Key To Security, Inc

5.00(
12
)

America's Key To Security, Inc

5.00(
12
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

We have been established as a Security Company since 1983. We are a full service mobile operation with 2 well stocked vans. We provide services to the Residential, Commercial, and Automotive markets. Our Locksmiths and Door Technicians are licensed, bonded, and insured. We carry New York State Workers Compensation and Disability Insurance. Our Business Liability Insurance carrier is State Farm Insurance. My business address is my home address. No need to worry, as I have never had a disgruntled customer come knocking on my door to complain. We will take the upmost pride in any job you require our services for, just as if we doing the job in our own homes. "WE HAVE A LIFETIME WARRANTY ON ALL RESIDENTIAL INSTALLATIONS-NOT SUBJECT TO ABUSE". Even if a screw comes loose, we will come and take care of it, no questions asked and NO CHARGE TO YOU!!! We also clean up nice after each & every job!!!

"Mitch is a knowledgeable locksmith and a really good guy. The job was done professionally and timely. Mitch goes above and beyond the ask. Would highly recommend his services."

Vitaly F on November 2022

We have been established as a Security Company since 1983. We are a full service mobile operation with 2 well stocked vans. We provide services to the Residential, Commercial, and Automotive markets. Our Locksmiths and Door Technicians are licensed, bonded, and insured. We carry New York State Workers Compensation and Disability Insurance. Our Business Liability Insurance carrier is State Farm Insurance. My business address is my home address. No need to worry, as I have never had a disgruntled customer come knocking on my door to complain. We will take the upmost pride in any job you require our services for, just as if we doing the job in our own homes. "WE HAVE A LIFETIME WARRANTY ON ALL RESIDENTIAL INSTALLATIONS-NOT SUBJECT TO ABUSE". Even if a screw comes loose, we will come and take care of it, no questions asked and NO CHARGE TO YOU!!! We also clean up nice after each & every job!!!

"Mitch is a knowledgeable locksmith and a really good guy. The job was done professionally and timely. Mitch goes above and beyond the ask. Would highly recommend his services."

Vitaly F on November 2022

...
Showing 1-10 of 764
Locksmiths questions, answered by experts

First, maintain composure and avoid forcing it further. Inspect the key to see if enough material remains exposed for extraction. Use pliers or tweezers to grasp and gently pull out the broken piece if possible. Lubricate the keyhole with a graphite-based spray to aid removal. If self-removal proves challenging or risks damaging the lock, seek a professional locksmith's assistance. They possess the necessary tools and expertise to extract the key without causing damage.

The cost to rekey locks on your home is $40 to $100 plus $15 to $40 per lock. Rekeying means you can keep your existing locks but simply change the key. You’ll still need a pro to cut a new key and rekey the lock, but no new hardware is required. Rekeying is a good option if:

  • You need a quick way to upgrade your current locks

  • You have a quality lock that works well

  • You recently moved in and want to ensure you’re the only one with access

  • You lost a key

The benefit of deadbolt locks is that they're much harder to force open than simple locks with pin tumbler mechanisms, so they may offer added security. This feature is why many locksmiths recommend deadbolts for home security. For many households, this added protection and peace of mind is well worth the cost of installing a deadbolt.

Regrettably, entirely pick-proof locks don't exist unless you opt for keyless varieties. Locks advertised as "pick-proof" are, in reality, more resilient against lock-picking and bumping attempts because of complex mechanisms consisting of pins and sidebars. These locks work like this—they assign two tasks to the key, enhancing security by making unauthorized entry more challenging.

A smart lock is a variation of a traditional lock, and since it uses similar locking mechanisms, it’s technically not any safer. The difference is that a smart lock requires a login instead of a physical key. Some smart locks have added safety features, like shutting down after too many attempts with the wrong code. Some smart locks are considered harder to pick than traditional locks, which can further deter intruders.

The Oyster Bay, NY homeowners’ guide to locksmith services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

What do you need done? We’ll find top pros.
  • 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
  • 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
  • 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"