Top-rated bathtub restoration pros.

Get matched with top bathtub restoration pros in Holley, NY

Enter your ZIP and get matched with up to 5 pros

Find Bathtub restoration pros in Holley

Avatar for Bath Fitter of Buffalo

Bath Fitter of Buffalo

4.72(
130
)

Bath Fitter of Buffalo

4.72(
130
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers

Bath Fitter of Buffalo is your local expert in bathroom remodeling, specializing in custom bathtub and shower solutions designed to fit your space perfectly. With over 40 years of experience and millions of installations completed nationwide, we’ve built a reputation for quality, reliability, and lasting results. Our exclusive PermaFit™ system allows us to install premium tubs and showers over your existing setup, often in as little as one day, with no messy demolition. From bathtub replacements and shower installations to tub-to-shower conversions and walk-in showers, every project is backed by our lifetime warranty and handled start to finish by our own factory-trained installers—never subcontractors. Whether you’re looking to modernize your bathroom, improve accessibility, or simply refresh your space, Bath Fitter Buffalo delivers seamless, low-maintenance designs that homeowners across Western New York trust.

"Amazing job covering a 45 year old bathtub and ceramic tile. Justin was prompt, organized, totally professional, answered all my questions. Completed the whole job in just one day. Was able to raise our shower head to a comfortable height for my taller children. Very pleased with the results."

Mark T on June 2023

Bath Fitter of Buffalo is your local expert in bathroom remodeling, specializing in custom bathtub and shower solutions designed to fit your space perfectly. With over 40 years of experience and millions of installations completed nationwide, we’ve built a reputation for quality, reliability, and lasting results. Our exclusive PermaFit™ system allows us to install premium tubs and showers over your existing setup, often in as little as one day, with no messy demolition. From bathtub replacements and shower installations to tub-to-shower conversions and walk-in showers, every project is backed by our lifetime warranty and handled start to finish by our own factory-trained installers—never subcontractors. Whether you’re looking to modernize your bathroom, improve accessibility, or simply refresh your space, Bath Fitter Buffalo delivers seamless, low-maintenance designs that homeowners across Western New York trust.

"Amazing job covering a 45 year old bathtub and ceramic tile. Justin was prompt, organized, totally professional, answered all my questions. Completed the whole job in just one day. Was able to raise our shower head to a comfortable height for my taller children. Very pleased with the results."

Mark T on June 2023


Avatar for Adam Solutions LLC

Adam Solutions LLC

4.78(
46
)

Adam Solutions LLC

4.78(
46
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers

.Home Improvement, Specializing in kitchen/bath remodeling ,tiling, flooring, Fully insured. Flat $$$ fee pricing. I don't believe in separate fee's for different services for the same job. I do offer special promotions for jobs over 3 days. Cash, checks and credit cards are accepted.

"Hard working, professional and knowledgeable. They are also extremely neat. Hiring them for more work."

Wendy T on April 2023

.Home Improvement, Specializing in kitchen/bath remodeling ,tiling, flooring, Fully insured. Flat $$$ fee pricing. I don't believe in separate fee's for different services for the same job. I do offer special promotions for jobs over 3 days. Cash, checks and credit cards are accepted.

"Hard working, professional and knowledgeable. They are also extremely neat. Hiring them for more work."

Wendy T on April 2023


Comfort Windows

4.72(
117
)

Comfort Windows

4.72(
117
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 95% of Angi customers
Recommended by 95% of HomeAdvisor customers

Comfort Windows is Upstate NY's Premier Home Improvement Company. Local experts for windows, doors, bathrooms, basements, insulation, sunrooms, siding and more.

"We were blessed when we bought our home 4 years ago that all the previous homeowners did an amazing job with maintenance and upgrades over the years. The only deficiency was that the home still had its original 30 year old windows. We knew from day one that we needed to replace them sooner than later. We saved up and finally called highly-recommended Comfort Windows last August. Our salesperson, Don, was very thorough and knowledgeable. He explained all our options in great detail without any pressure tactics. We chose the window line manufactured by Comfort Windows themselves in Syracuse. 20 windows, triple-paned, one layer of Low-E coating and argon filling. Our house is a traditional colonial so we stuck with the grids on the front but left them out in the rear. We even changed some windows to picture windows. Wow! What an amazing great decision. The light and views are just gorgeous. We also replaced a sliding door between the house and a sunroom addition. Comfort Windows are great quality and affordable. The craftsmanship is top notch. Great value for the product. Like many others acknowledged, our project was delayed by 3 months due to the pandemic. We were originally given a November installation time frame, but didn’t get them installed until February. The real heroes of this project were Paul and Chris. Temperatures in the teens, thick snowpack, heavy lake effect snow, nothing stopped these guys. They were very professional, polite, COVID conscious, and did quality workmanship through some really tough weather conditions. A few other guys popped in here and there to lend a hand, but I didn’t get to meet them. Paul and Chris were “our guys” and we welcomed them into our home like family. When all said and done, we absolutely love our new Comfort Windows. The energy efficiency ratings are spectacular and we can’t wait until we stick it to RG&E. We used a thermometer to check the difference. While it was 12-degrees outside, our original double-paned windows averaged 40 degrees on the face. Imagine, that’s like leaving multiple refrigerators wide open 24/7. The new Comfort Windows were 60 to 65 degrees on the face of the glass. What a difference! We actually had to turn down our thermostat because we were sweating at night. The windows are gorgeous and you can just tell that they were built to last well into the future. A great investment with no buyers remorse. You just can’t beat Comfort Windows. Don’t believe the hype of the overrated national brand. How can a window made to be “one size fits all” serve the climates of California, Florida, Arizona and the winters of New York? These windows are made in New York. These windows are made for New York. Support local businesses and local hard working men and women."

David B on February 2021

Comfort Windows is Upstate NY's Premier Home Improvement Company. Local experts for windows, doors, bathrooms, basements, insulation, sunrooms, siding and more.

"We were blessed when we bought our home 4 years ago that all the previous homeowners did an amazing job with maintenance and upgrades over the years. The only deficiency was that the home still had its original 30 year old windows. We knew from day one that we needed to replace them sooner than later. We saved up and finally called highly-recommended Comfort Windows last August. Our salesperson, Don, was very thorough and knowledgeable. He explained all our options in great detail without any pressure tactics. We chose the window line manufactured by Comfort Windows themselves in Syracuse. 20 windows, triple-paned, one layer of Low-E coating and argon filling. Our house is a traditional colonial so we stuck with the grids on the front but left them out in the rear. We even changed some windows to picture windows. Wow! What an amazing great decision. The light and views are just gorgeous. We also replaced a sliding door between the house and a sunroom addition. Comfort Windows are great quality and affordable. The craftsmanship is top notch. Great value for the product. Like many others acknowledged, our project was delayed by 3 months due to the pandemic. We were originally given a November installation time frame, but didn’t get them installed until February. The real heroes of this project were Paul and Chris. Temperatures in the teens, thick snowpack, heavy lake effect snow, nothing stopped these guys. They were very professional, polite, COVID conscious, and did quality workmanship through some really tough weather conditions. A few other guys popped in here and there to lend a hand, but I didn’t get to meet them. Paul and Chris were “our guys” and we welcomed them into our home like family. When all said and done, we absolutely love our new Comfort Windows. The energy efficiency ratings are spectacular and we can’t wait until we stick it to RG&E. We used a thermometer to check the difference. While it was 12-degrees outside, our original double-paned windows averaged 40 degrees on the face. Imagine, that’s like leaving multiple refrigerators wide open 24/7. The new Comfort Windows were 60 to 65 degrees on the face of the glass. What a difference! We actually had to turn down our thermostat because we were sweating at night. The windows are gorgeous and you can just tell that they were built to last well into the future. A great investment with no buyers remorse. You just can’t beat Comfort Windows. Don’t believe the hype of the overrated national brand. How can a window made to be “one size fits all” serve the climates of California, Florida, Arizona and the winters of New York? These windows are made in New York. These windows are made for New York. Support local businesses and local hard working men and women."

David B on February 2021


Comfort Windows & Doors

4.72(
47
)

Comfort Windows & Doors

4.72(
47
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers

Comfort Windows is Upstate NY's Premier Home Improvement Company. Local experts for windows, doors, bathrooms, basements, insulation, sunrooms, siding and more.

"Improperly installed windows leading to a hand injury requiring medical attention. Customer service presented false claims, and accused me of lying about my injury"

Joyce C on September 2020

Comfort Windows is Upstate NY's Premier Home Improvement Company. Local experts for windows, doors, bathrooms, basements, insulation, sunrooms, siding and more.

"Improperly installed windows leading to a hand injury requiring medical attention. Customer service presented false claims, and accused me of lying about my injury"

Joyce C on September 2020


Sunny Days Painting

4.74(
23
)

Sunny Days Painting

4.74(
23
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers

SUNNY DAYS PAINTING was created in 1997 by Brian Beachner. Brian started out painting in the early nineties as a “weekend warrior” helping a childhood friend with his own painting business. What was supposed to be a way to make a little extra money turned out to be much more. He realized he was good enough to start his own business, one that emphasized customer service. Sunny Days has been growing since the beginning with a client list that includes well known doctors, lawyers, THE Mayor, Deputy Mayor, city councilman, county legislators, business owners, fellow contractors, and many, many homeowners all over NY state. Our crew of employees represent over 70 years experience in painting and home improvement and are all dedicated to their craft as artisans. We have been recognized as a preferred contractor by the LANDMARK SOCIETY and have worked closely with several neighborhood associations. Most Recently Brian made the tough decision to leave the business due to health and family reasons. After Careful consideration Ray Colon, a long time painter with Sunny Days decided to keep the legacy and reputation for quality work and customer service alive at Sunny Days. Ray has assumed all the day to day activities and is the proud owner of Sunny Days Painting! Brian will consult with Ray during the transition.

SUNNY DAYS PAINTING was created in 1997 by Brian Beachner. Brian started out painting in the early nineties as a “weekend warrior” helping a childhood friend with his own painting business. What was supposed to be a way to make a little extra money turned out to be much more. He realized he was good enough to start his own business, one that emphasized customer service. Sunny Days has been growing since the beginning with a client list that includes well known doctors, lawyers, THE Mayor, Deputy Mayor, city councilman, county legislators, business owners, fellow contractors, and many, many homeowners all over NY state. Our crew of employees represent over 70 years experience in painting and home improvement and are all dedicated to their craft as artisans. We have been recognized as a preferred contractor by the LANDMARK SOCIETY and have worked closely with several neighborhood associations. Most Recently Brian made the tough decision to leave the business due to health and family reasons. After Careful consideration Ray Colon, a long time painter with Sunny Days decided to keep the legacy and reputation for quality work and customer service alive at Sunny Days. Ray has assumed all the day to day activities and is the proud owner of Sunny Days Painting! Brian will consult with Ray during the transition.


Avatar for New York Flooring and Interior

New York Flooring and Interior

5.00(
6
)

New York Flooring and Interior

5.00(
6
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

New York Flooring is a reputable company that has been serving the Rochester area for over 20 years. Specializing in floor refinishing, custom staining, installation as well as flooring repairs. We take pride in our work, Costumer satisfaction is our priority.

"Wonderful! We love our floors in our new home"

Jan C on June 2024

New York Flooring is a reputable company that has been serving the Rochester area for over 20 years. Specializing in floor refinishing, custom staining, installation as well as flooring repairs. We take pride in our work, Costumer satisfaction is our priority.

"Wonderful! We love our floors in our new home"

Jan C on June 2024



Avatar for GSD Contracting

GSD Contracting

5.00(
4
)

GSD Contracting

5.00(
4
)
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

We have the experience and dedication to bring your dreams to reality! Specializing in Handyman and Home Repair Services, we guarantee your satisfaction, and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Call or click to schedule a free estimate today! *20% MILITARY DISCOUNT!

"Very professional did good work and easy to work with!"

Rob G on January 2021

We have the experience and dedication to bring your dreams to reality! Specializing in Handyman and Home Repair Services, we guarantee your satisfaction, and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Call or click to schedule a free estimate today! *20% MILITARY DISCOUNT!

"Very professional did good work and easy to work with!"

Rob G on January 2021


Erie Construction Midwest - Toledo

3.87(
77
)

Erie Construction Midwest - Toledo

3.87(
77
)
Customers say: Quality work
1975 years of experience

Trusted, Bonded and Insured, Erie Construction has grown to become one of the nation's largest home remodeling companies. We offer best-in-class products aimed at improving the value of your home while saving money on your home energy bills. We've been truly dedicated to the products we offer, and we're happy to back them up with warranty's to match. Since opening our first location in 1975, Erie Construction has serviced over 100,000 customers, with over 50,000 returning to us for additional projects. Read what our customers have to say about us at GuildQuality: http://www.guildquality.com/erieconstruction You can always schedule your free estimate by dropping us a line at 1-800-536-4200 or visiting us online at http://www.erieconstruction.com Erie Construction services locations in nearly 26 states to bring the highest quality home products to you.

"Very high pressure sales. For your own sake have cameras rolling during sales pitch. Don’t let them make you believe that the installation is done by Erie. Totally subcontracted. Talked us into choosing them even though they were 7k higher than other roofers with the promise of higher quality service that didn’t happen, job site was a mess had to inspect gutters they were not cleaned. They came back out cleaned said it was done got back up on ladder gutters still full and found damaged siding on back of chimney. After filling with BBB repairs and cleanup were done just not worth the higher price. Price started at $26 a square for metal and $15. For fiberglass after 4 hours of sales it came down to $21 metal and $10.5 a square foot fiberglass. I surely have buyers remorse hopefully this review helps someone in their decision. Also suggest reading this [*** Link removed ***] prior to reading all the A+ ratings on BBB Also make sure proper permits were pulled they did not pull one till after the install when I questioned it. Good Luck"

Scott C on January 2023

Trusted, Bonded and Insured, Erie Construction has grown to become one of the nation's largest home remodeling companies. We offer best-in-class products aimed at improving the value of your home while saving money on your home energy bills. We've been truly dedicated to the products we offer, and we're happy to back them up with warranty's to match. Since opening our first location in 1975, Erie Construction has serviced over 100,000 customers, with over 50,000 returning to us for additional projects. Read what our customers have to say about us at GuildQuality: http://www.guildquality.com/erieconstruction You can always schedule your free estimate by dropping us a line at 1-800-536-4200 or visiting us online at http://www.erieconstruction.com Erie Construction services locations in nearly 26 states to bring the highest quality home products to you.

"Very high pressure sales. For your own sake have cameras rolling during sales pitch. Don’t let them make you believe that the installation is done by Erie. Totally subcontracted. Talked us into choosing them even though they were 7k higher than other roofers with the promise of higher quality service that didn’t happen, job site was a mess had to inspect gutters they were not cleaned. They came back out cleaned said it was done got back up on ladder gutters still full and found damaged siding on back of chimney. After filling with BBB repairs and cleanup were done just not worth the higher price. Price started at $26 a square for metal and $15. For fiberglass after 4 hours of sales it came down to $21 metal and $10.5 a square foot fiberglass. I surely have buyers remorse hopefully this review helps someone in their decision. Also suggest reading this [*** Link removed ***] prior to reading all the A+ ratings on BBB Also make sure proper permits were pulled they did not pull one till after the install when I questioned it. Good Luck"

Scott C on January 2023


"Very poor work. Seal didn't hold. Promised the work for 5 years but wouldn't resolve the issue. I am not the first victim of this I'm now seeing. My guess is the positive reviews are clients that didn't wait a couple months for the work to fall apart."

benjamin h on April 2025

Owned & operated.

"Very poor work. Seal didn't hold. Promised the work for 5 years but wouldn't resolve the issue. I am not the first victim of this I'm now seeing. My guess is the positive reviews are clients that didn't wait a couple months for the work to fall apart."

benjamin h on April 2025

Showing 1-10 of 27
Bathtub Restoration questions, answered by experts

The cost to refinish a bathtub is $490 for most homeowners. However, this cost can range from $200 to $1,000 or more, depending on your tub's material and condition. 

For example, enamel and cast-iron bathtubs are pretty straightforward to refinish, costing between $350 and $600. However, if you have an antique claw-foot tub, you can expect to pay between $500 and $1,200 for refinishing costs due to the care and complexity needed.

They provide a cost-effective way to update a bathroom, prevent leaks, and improve aesthetics without a complete remodel.

While tubs are fairly sturdy, you may notice cracks or holes. This kind of damage can happen from someone accidentally dropping something heavy into the tub. You might also see damage if you drop something heavy into the tub over and over again (like your extra large bottle of body wash). While you might only notice a small dent at first, this can later turn into a crack or a hole.

Also, certain cleaners that are harmful to your tub can cause damage. And if you have a fiberglass tub, you might see cracks if it was not installed properly with the right support.

A bathtub liner can be a good idea if your budget is your top concern when planning a bathroom remodel. Installing a new bathtub liner can give your bathroom the look of a complete renovation without the high price tag. But, it’s somewhat of a band-aid fix and won’t work for all homes, like if you have a freestanding tub.

It is worth it to refinish a bathtub if your current tub is in good shape. Refinishing your tub can remove scratches from wear and tear, cover blemishes and stains, and fill small cracks. However, consider replacing your tub if it’s severely damaged, has large cracks, or leaks.

The Holley, NY homeowners’ guide to bathtub restorations

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.