Top-rated custom home builders.

Best custom home builders near Codorus, PA

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your custom home building project in Codorus, PA?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

Top-Rated Custom home builders in Codorus - Updated Nov 2026

Avatar for Millstone Co
Millstone Co
3.9(
7
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Codorus, PA and surrounding areas

Approved

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"Matt and Laura at Millstone had great ideas for my renovation. Their team did excellent work and did it all with professionalism and courtesy. I will definitely call Millstone for my next project."
18 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Sherman Builders LLC
Sherman Builders LLC
4.7(
15
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Codorus, PA and surrounding areas

In business since 1990

Free estimates

"Outstanding workmanship. Sherman builders tore the roof off of my house and built an entire second floor on to the house effectively doubling the size of my home. The second floor addition included new electrical, heat and AC, bathroom with tile shower, bedrooms, closets etc. The work was done within budget and on time."
Plumbing Project
Plumbing Project
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+18

Recommended by92%of homeowners
Colmar Contracting
4.7(
7
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Codorus, PA and surrounding areas

Credit card accepted

"Colmar Contracting is the best. We contacted four separate contractors in May/June for estimates to paint our home this summer. We were reluctant to bring in others to work on our home as we try to do all of our own house projects. Painting is not one of our strengths and therefore we decided to contract out for quality of work and timely completion of such a large project. With most estimates being fairly similar, we decided to work with Colmar and were not disappointed. Along with listening to our ideas as to what we wanted, they also provided expert insight into those ideas and helped shape our final decisions. The painters showed up promptly and ready to work hard every day. They were very accommodating to me as I was off work and home during the time frame they were working in our home. The painters were friendly, courteous, and attentive to our requests. They finished painting our entire home in only eight days. Our biggest concern was attention to detail and we are very impressed with the quality of their wok as well as their willingness to meet our demands and go above and beyond expectations. We look forward to working with Colmar Contracting in the future and recommend their services without reservation!
"
Recommended by83%of homeowners
Avatar for Choice Home Warranty
Choice Home Warranty
4.0(
5,680
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Codorus, PA and surrounding areas

In business since 2008

Emergency services offered

Credit card accepted

"Bruce Dixon was very nice and helpful in providing exceptional customer service and making sure I had the best experience. I purchased my home warranty and feel confident in the choice I made. Thank you Bruce. Sincerely, Kimberly"
Recommended by81%of homeowners
Avatar for Crawford Construction
Crawford Construction
4.8(
22
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Codorus, PA and surrounding areas

In business since 2016

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Jesse and his team did a great job installing a new roof for my home. Pricing was fair and within budget. The project was completed in only a few days and was scheduled efficiently to avoid rain. I was more than satisfied with the project and also hired Crawford Construction for replacing windows."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+52

Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for Kc Nicole Construction
Kc Nicole Construction
5.0(
6
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Codorus, PA and surrounding areas

In business since 2022

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"My grandfather and I were very pleased with the service we received. We contacted Kc Nicole Construction about fixing our roof, since it was weathered and animals were able to get in. On the phone they were very professional, they gave us a good estimate and we’re able to communicate what they planned to do. The service was phenomenal! They did an amazing job on our roof and we couldn’t be more pleased. If you have any roofing needs i would highly recommend Kc Nicole construction!"
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for Worley & Obetz Inc
Worley & Obetz Inc
4.3(
27
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Codorus, PA and surrounding areas

In business since 1946

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"We sought bids for installing a central air conditioner and we chose them for several reasons.  We like their quality, pricing, and competence.  What got them this job was that their bid was in line with our budget.  They did not know that so they didn’t try to underbid everyone else; their pricing was right.  I got a good sense that the salesman did not try to oversell us.  Some of the other companies oversold what we need.  He was able to show me the numbers and justified why he recommended the system that he did. The crew that is in the house is neat, clean, and tidy.  They are very personable and they are doing good work.  They are trustworthy characters that I would leave at home alone.  They’re always on time and have been here when they said they would be.  We will continue to use them; there’s a reason we keep going back.  They end up winning their business back.  They don’t realize that’s what they’re doing, but they do."
HVAC Install & Repair
W & O Products & Services
Fleet Fuel & Propane Services
100% American Fuel
Fleet Cards

+2

Recommended by84%of homeowners
Avatar for Five Star Contracting llc.
Five Star Contracting llc.
4.3(
6
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Codorus, PA and surrounding areas

In business since 2012

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Five Star Contracting LLC will not disappoint! They completed a paint project that included trim repair and wall patching due to my destructive paw baby the mud area, along with painting the mud room, living room /kitchen along with bedroom, in addition they changed out my lights completed a fix by adding on the the tile work in my kitchen and painting my kitchen island. I am particular about the work done and wanted to ensure there were crisp paint lines. They worked with me to ensure i was satisfied with the final product. The team came through nicely! I would definitely recommend them to others and plan to do a bathroom renovation with them soon!!"
Before
After Exterior
After Interior
Before
After Bathroom

+54

Recommended by83%of homeowners
Showing 1-10 of 37
Custom Home Builders FAQs, answered by experts

One of the best ways to negotiate with a homebuilder is to forgo price reductions. Instead, negotiate over upgrades and incentives, as many builders are more willing to go down that road than to decrease their own fee. Even if they were willing to take a cut, a reputable homebuilder often knows their worth, so a willingness to negotiate could be a red flag. Beyond that, builders are typically willing to negotiate closing costs instead of offering a discount on the base price.

Modular homes can go up or down in value depending on a few factors. In areas where real estate is appreciating, the value of modular homes is likely to increase, and vice versa. Additionally, the value of modular homes depends partially on the area. In cities where every other home is stick-built, modular homes might be considered a functional obsolescence, in which case they could be less desirable and go down in value. In either case, though, modular homes can still be a good investment, especially since they provide housing at a lower upfront cost.

Modular homes last an average of between 50 and 75 years, and high-quality modular homes can last for 100 years with proper maintenance. For comparison, a standard home lasts 50 to 100 years and can push to 150 or longer with good maintenance. Modular homes provide better long-term value in that they are significantly more affordable and can last almost as long, but some buyers are wary of modular home longevity, so the actual value if you sell could be lower.

While many different factors determine whether a house is classified as a villa, many villas are detached homes with a European design influence, often with an emphasis on luxury and comfort. Modern villas often feature outdoor spaces such as terraces, gardens, or patios.

There are energy-efficient options when building a cottage. Select green building materials, high-performance insulation, and energy-efficient windows when designing your cottage. Options such as solar panels, efficient HVAC systems, and LED lighting can lower your utility bills and reduce your environmental impact. Many builders offer energy-efficient upgrades as part of the design process.

The Codorus, PA homeowners’ guide to custom home building

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.