
Get matched with top mailbox repairers in Old Bethpage, NY
Enter your ZIP and get matched with up to 5 pros
Need a pro for your mailbox repair project in Old Bethpage, NY?
TRUSTED BY OLD BETHPAGE, NY HOMEOWNERS
4.5
Average homeowner rating191
Verified mailbox repairs reviews
Verified Reviews for Mailbox Repair pros in Old Bethpage, NY
*The Angi rating for Mailbox Repair companies in Old Bethpage, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Mailbox Repair needs.
*The HomeAdvisor rating for Mailbox Repair companies in Old Bethpage, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Mailbox Repair needs.
Last update on December 04, 2025
Find Mailbox repairers in Old Bethpage

Magic Improvement, LLC
Magic Improvement, LLC
We are extremely passionate about the work that we do. You can depend on us to provide a high quality service at a fair and honest price. We understand that the future of our business depends upon our reputation and that is why customer service is by far our highest priority. If you are looking for a professional you can trust, please call today to schedule a no-obligation estimate!
"We had a few jobs including grouting of shower, reinforcing kitchen cabinets and making a wall opening in our laundry room. Angel and his workers are truly professional, friendly and hard working. They were perfectionists."
John F on October 2025
We are extremely passionate about the work that we do. You can depend on us to provide a high quality service at a fair and honest price. We understand that the future of our business depends upon our reputation and that is why customer service is by far our highest priority. If you are looking for a professional you can trust, please call today to schedule a no-obligation estimate!
"We had a few jobs including grouting of shower, reinforcing kitchen cabinets and making a wall opening in our laundry room. Angel and his workers are truly professional, friendly and hard working. They were perfectionists."
John F on October 2025

Home Solutions Thomas James LLC
Home Solutions Thomas James LLC
We are a locally owned and operated company that values honesty and integrity in all aspects of our business. Our major focus is on the quality our work and producing outstanding results. We are committed to creating a level of value unmatched by any of our competitors. We look forward to building lasting relationships with our clients and guarantee your satisfaction!
"I recently hired Tom to do several projects around my home, and I couldn?t be happier with the results. He was punctual, professional, and his pricing was very fair. He built my gazebo beautifully, installed a few doors with precision, and did an excellent job on both my kitchen and living room floors. Everything came out exactly how I envisioned it. It?s hard to find someone who?s reliable and does quality work, but he delivered on all fronts. I?ll definitely be calling him again for future projects and highly recommend him to anyone needing a skilled handyman."
Julissa J on May 2025
We are a locally owned and operated company that values honesty and integrity in all aspects of our business. Our major focus is on the quality our work and producing outstanding results. We are committed to creating a level of value unmatched by any of our competitors. We look forward to building lasting relationships with our clients and guarantee your satisfaction!
"I recently hired Tom to do several projects around my home, and I couldn?t be happier with the results. He was punctual, professional, and his pricing was very fair. He built my gazebo beautifully, installed a few doors with precision, and did an excellent job on both my kitchen and living room floors. Everything came out exactly how I envisioned it. It?s hard to find someone who?s reliable and does quality work, but he delivered on all fronts. I?ll definitely be calling him again for future projects and highly recommend him to anyone needing a skilled handyman."
Julissa J on May 2025

Blue Whale Handyman
Blue Whale Handyman
Welcome to Blue Whale Handyman! Small family business, owner operated with over 30 years experience. We can handle any project and are fully equipped to tackle all of your needs! Customer satisfaction is our number one goal. ** Fluent in English, Spanish and sign language ** I look forward to working with you.
"Ivan and his crew are very talented and trusty worthy people that do beautiful work! He has done several projects for me and always gives me quality work at a fair price!"
Carol A on October 2024
Welcome to Blue Whale Handyman! Small family business, owner operated with over 30 years experience. We can handle any project and are fully equipped to tackle all of your needs! Customer satisfaction is our number one goal. ** Fluent in English, Spanish and sign language ** I look forward to working with you.
"Ivan and his crew are very talented and trusty worthy people that do beautiful work! He has done several projects for me and always gives me quality work at a fair price!"
Carol A on October 2024

Mr. Handyman of Nassau County
Mr. Handyman of Nassau County
Busy schedules make both major and minor home repairs hard to get to. Now your growing "To Do" list looks overwhelming and unmanageable. One call to Mr. Handyman solves all your home repair headaches.
"Piece of furniture looks great. Great job."
Michael R on October 2025
Busy schedules make both major and minor home repairs hard to get to. Now your growing "To Do" list looks overwhelming and unmanageable. One call to Mr. Handyman solves all your home repair headaches.
"Piece of furniture looks great. Great job."
Michael R on October 2025

I & M Handyman and Cleaning Services
I & M Handyman and Cleaning Services
We guarantee your satisfaction and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Check out our services offered and call or click to schedule a free estimate today.
"The replacement of the exhaust fan was done well and neat. Thank you Ivan"
Maria L on November 2025
We guarantee your satisfaction and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Check out our services offered and call or click to schedule a free estimate today.
"The replacement of the exhaust fan was done well and neat. Thank you Ivan"
Maria L on November 2025

Ruben's Masonry
Ruben's Masonry
Specializing in masonry including: concrete, cement, driveways, patios, stairs, egress windows, entrance to basements, chimneys, stucco, etc.
Specializing in masonry including: concrete, cement, driveways, patios, stairs, egress windows, entrance to basements, chimneys, stucco, etc.

R generation
R generation
We do home renovations anywhere from painting, tile, windows , roofing, drywall , some light landscape 3 brothers renovating homes :)
"I was very satisfied with the work they did , honest and reliable workers , fair price ."
Kimberly R on March 2023
We do home renovations anywhere from painting, tile, windows , roofing, drywall , some light landscape 3 brothers renovating homes :)
"I was very satisfied with the work they did , honest and reliable workers , fair price ."
Kimberly R on March 2023

Limitless Handyman
Limitless Handyman
DURING COVID-19: We are still booking appointments and practicing safety precautions that are in-line with the executive order. Please call for the fastest response and to get more details about how we are able to help you with your home needs. Woodwork, painting, electrical, plumbing, and more. My services might be varied, but they all come with the same promise of quality, dedication, and durability. Bonded and insured, I’m an experienced contractor with knowledge passed down from generations. I can offer a 1-year guarantee for all my services, along with free estimates.
"My experience with Rashad started off pretty well. He was nice, and I felt his pricing was very fair. He came by a little less than 2 months ago to give me an estimate, and we had scheduled an appointment around 2 weeks after the estimate, as he was booked up until then, which was fine by me. The day before he was scheduled to begin the job at my house, he asked if he could reschedule for a week later. I agreed, but I asked if he could come by in less than another week just to do 2 priority tasks such as installing my address number outside my house, as my house had no address number on it for weeks. He agreed and came by the following day for a few hours to do the address numbers and patch up a large hole in my ceiling, which I really appreciated. He came by the following week and completed some of the items he agreed to complete. Then the following week he was scheduled to come back on a Thursday, but the day before that appointment he said he had to reschedule because he needed a helper that was not available until Friday. No problem and we rescheduled to Friday. He was a little late on Friday and they were doing some loud work that sort of delayed our infant son's bedtime, but it was no big deal. That Friday evening before he left my home, I told him I would pay him most of the money we agreed upon for the entire list of agreed upon work even though there was still a significant amount of work left to be done on the list. He said he would be back Friday of the following week, and I paid him via Venmo that same evening he left my home. Unfortunately, after I paid him most of the agreed upon money, he never returned to complete any work, and there was still a number of list items he never completed nor even started. I text messaged him twice the following week before our appointment. Once to send him a list of the remaining items and another time the day before our appointment to confirm, but he never responded. Then at the end of the day of the missed appointment, I texted him again to politely ask when he would be able to come back and complete the job. Again, I received no response. About midway into the following week, I called him and he claimed he never received my text messages, which doesn't explain the missed appointment, but at least he said he would come back the following week to address the remaining work on the list. He then gave me his email address since he said he did not receive my text messages. We then setup an appointment for a Wednesday via text message, as I suppose he was now receiving my text messages. I text messaged and emailed him the day before our Wednesday appointment to confirm and ask what time he planned on arriving. He said he would be there around 10am. Now comes Wednesday 10am, the day & time of our appointment, and he does not show up. He sends me a text message later that morning that says he's stuck in the city on an emergency, he has not headed my way yet, and he will have an update for me soon. As of now, a full week later after that most recently missed appointment, I never received any update nor heard back from Rashad at all. I text messaged, called, and emailed him about 3 times each in the last week in case he would claim his phone or text messaging was not working again, and I have not heard back from him at all. Despite my frustration at this point, my messages to him were all courteous such as asking him if all was well with him and asking that he please get back to me at his earliest convenience, thanks, regards, etc.... I feel pretty stupid for trusting Rashad, as he never returned after I paid him, which was close to four weeks ago. Now, close to two months after finding Rashad, I have to begin the process of finding another handyman and paying money again to a new handyman to fix and complete the work Rashad left unfinished. My apologies for the lengthy review, but I am just astonished by Rashad's actions and unprofessionalism."
Bill T on November 2020
DURING COVID-19: We are still booking appointments and practicing safety precautions that are in-line with the executive order. Please call for the fastest response and to get more details about how we are able to help you with your home needs. Woodwork, painting, electrical, plumbing, and more. My services might be varied, but they all come with the same promise of quality, dedication, and durability. Bonded and insured, I’m an experienced contractor with knowledge passed down from generations. I can offer a 1-year guarantee for all my services, along with free estimates.
"My experience with Rashad started off pretty well. He was nice, and I felt his pricing was very fair. He came by a little less than 2 months ago to give me an estimate, and we had scheduled an appointment around 2 weeks after the estimate, as he was booked up until then, which was fine by me. The day before he was scheduled to begin the job at my house, he asked if he could reschedule for a week later. I agreed, but I asked if he could come by in less than another week just to do 2 priority tasks such as installing my address number outside my house, as my house had no address number on it for weeks. He agreed and came by the following day for a few hours to do the address numbers and patch up a large hole in my ceiling, which I really appreciated. He came by the following week and completed some of the items he agreed to complete. Then the following week he was scheduled to come back on a Thursday, but the day before that appointment he said he had to reschedule because he needed a helper that was not available until Friday. No problem and we rescheduled to Friday. He was a little late on Friday and they were doing some loud work that sort of delayed our infant son's bedtime, but it was no big deal. That Friday evening before he left my home, I told him I would pay him most of the money we agreed upon for the entire list of agreed upon work even though there was still a significant amount of work left to be done on the list. He said he would be back Friday of the following week, and I paid him via Venmo that same evening he left my home. Unfortunately, after I paid him most of the agreed upon money, he never returned to complete any work, and there was still a number of list items he never completed nor even started. I text messaged him twice the following week before our appointment. Once to send him a list of the remaining items and another time the day before our appointment to confirm, but he never responded. Then at the end of the day of the missed appointment, I texted him again to politely ask when he would be able to come back and complete the job. Again, I received no response. About midway into the following week, I called him and he claimed he never received my text messages, which doesn't explain the missed appointment, but at least he said he would come back the following week to address the remaining work on the list. He then gave me his email address since he said he did not receive my text messages. We then setup an appointment for a Wednesday via text message, as I suppose he was now receiving my text messages. I text messaged and emailed him the day before our Wednesday appointment to confirm and ask what time he planned on arriving. He said he would be there around 10am. Now comes Wednesday 10am, the day & time of our appointment, and he does not show up. He sends me a text message later that morning that says he's stuck in the city on an emergency, he has not headed my way yet, and he will have an update for me soon. As of now, a full week later after that most recently missed appointment, I never received any update nor heard back from Rashad at all. I text messaged, called, and emailed him about 3 times each in the last week in case he would claim his phone or text messaging was not working again, and I have not heard back from him at all. Despite my frustration at this point, my messages to him were all courteous such as asking him if all was well with him and asking that he please get back to me at his earliest convenience, thanks, regards, etc.... I feel pretty stupid for trusting Rashad, as he never returned after I paid him, which was close to four weeks ago. Now, close to two months after finding Rashad, I have to begin the process of finding another handyman and paying money again to a new handyman to fix and complete the work Rashad left unfinished. My apologies for the lengthy review, but I am just astonished by Rashad's actions and unprofessionalism."
Bill T on November 2020
- Hicksville, NY Mailbox repairers
- Jericho, NY Mailbox repairers
- Plainview, NY Mailbox repairers
- Bethpage, NY Mailbox repairers
- Levittown, NY Mailbox repairers
- Westbury, NY Mailbox repairers
- Old Westbury, NY Mailbox repairers
- Syosset, NY Mailbox repairers
- East Meadow, NY Mailbox repairers
- Woodbury, NY Mailbox repairers
- Carle Place, NY Mailbox repairers
- Farmingdale, NY Mailbox repairers
- Brookville, NY Mailbox repairers
- East Norwich, NY Mailbox repairers
- Greenvale, NY Mailbox repairers
- Wantagh, NY Mailbox repairers
- Roslyn Heights, NY Mailbox repairers
- Merrick, NY Mailbox repairers
- Uniondale, NY Mailbox repairers
- East Hills, NY Mailbox repairers
- Bellmore, NY Mailbox repairers
- North Bellmore, NY Mailbox repairers
- Mineola, NY Mailbox repairers
- Williston Park, NY Mailbox repairers
- East Williston, NY Mailbox repairers
- Massapequa, NY Mailbox repairers
- North Massapequa, NY Mailbox repairers
- Melville, NY Mailbox repairers
- Seaford, NY Mailbox repairers
- Albertson, NY Mailbox repairers
- Roofing in Old Bethpage
- Tree Service in Old Bethpage
- Electrical in Old Bethpage
- Deck Maintenance in Old Bethpage
- Kitchen And Bath Remodeling in Old Bethpage
- Lawn And Yard Work in Old Bethpage
- Pressure Washing in Old Bethpage
- Concrete Repair in Old Bethpage
- Animal Removal in Old Bethpage
- Plumbing in Old Bethpage
- Cleaning in Old Bethpage
- Upholstery Cleaning in Old Bethpage
- Driveways in Old Bethpage
- Sunroom And Patio Remodeling in Old Bethpage
- Garage Doors in Old Bethpage
- Landscaping in Old Bethpage
- Plaster Plaster Repair in Old Bethpage
- Glass And Mirrors in Old Bethpage
- Lawn Irrigation in Old Bethpage
- Solar Panels in Old Bethpage
- Mulch And Topsoil in Old Bethpage
- Basement Waterproofing in Old Bethpage
- Landscaping Hardscaping And Pavers in Old Bethpage
- Swimming Pools in Old Bethpage
- Siding in Old Bethpage
- Lawn Fertilization And Treatment in Old Bethpage
- Upholstering in Old Bethpage
- Window Cleaning in Old Bethpage
- Painting in Old Bethpage
- Stone And Gravel in Old Bethpage








