Top-rated property appraisers.

Get matched with top property appraisers in Montauk, NY

Enter your ZIP and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your property appraisal project in Montauk, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY MONTAUK, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.2
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon29
    Verified property appraisals reviews

Find Property appraisers in Montauk

Avatar for Mary Soper Appraisals

Mary Soper Appraisals

4.97(
29
)
Approved Pro

Mary Soper Appraisals

4.97(
29
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
1996 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

I am a Certified Real Estate Appraiser who has 27 years experience. My coverage areas are Suffolk, Nassau and Queens. I specialize in all the communities on Fire Island. My turn time is 48 hours from the inspection date. I look forward to hearing from you.

"G.reat job! efficient and timely, and a very pleasant person as well"

Bruce A on November 2025

I am a Certified Real Estate Appraiser who has 27 years experience. My coverage areas are Suffolk, Nassau and Queens. I specialize in all the communities on Fire Island. My turn time is 48 hours from the inspection date. I look forward to hearing from you.

"G.reat job! efficient and timely, and a very pleasant person as well"

Bruce A on November 2025


Avatar for Dennis Aarons & Associates, Inc.

Dennis Aarons & Associates, Inc.

4.87(
31
)
Approved Pro

Dennis Aarons & Associates, Inc.

4.87(
31
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
1979 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Aarons & Associates, Inc. has been a trusted name in residential and commercial property appraisals since 1979. As a family-owned business, we take pride in delivering accurate, reliable, and professional appraisal services backed by decades of experience. We proudly serve all five boroughs of New York City, Nassau and Suffolk counties on Long Island, and Westchester, Putnam, and Rockland counties. Whether you need an appraisal for buying, selling, refinancing, or estate planning, our team provides thorough evaluations and personalized service you can count on. Call today to schedule your property appraisal with a company that values integrity and precision.

"Dan is the consummate professional: responsive; communicative; thorough; honest; and reliable. Hired for a residential appraisal with intricate constraints, Dan clearly explained upfront what to expect, then delivered exactly as he described, all with friendliness and ease. He is undisputably the best contractor I've hired in Westchester in 25 years."

D M on October 2025

Aarons & Associates, Inc. has been a trusted name in residential and commercial property appraisals since 1979. As a family-owned business, we take pride in delivering accurate, reliable, and professional appraisal services backed by decades of experience. We proudly serve all five boroughs of New York City, Nassau and Suffolk counties on Long Island, and Westchester, Putnam, and Rockland counties. Whether you need an appraisal for buying, selling, refinancing, or estate planning, our team provides thorough evaluations and personalized service you can count on. Call today to schedule your property appraisal with a company that values integrity and precision.

"Dan is the consummate professional: responsive; communicative; thorough; honest; and reliable. Hired for a residential appraisal with intricate constraints, Dan clearly explained upfront what to expect, then delivered exactly as he described, all with friendliness and ease. He is undisputably the best contractor I've hired in Westchester in 25 years."

D M on October 2025


"Erik was great. I called him on Friday and he came the next day. He took the time to explain things to me the day of his visit and even after we received our appraisal. He even had our appraisal ready within the week. Thank you Erik"

Shannon C on December 2019

EBJ Associates LLC is proud to serve New York's Appraisal needs! Owner and operator Erik has over 20 years of experience in the industry. They're excited to take on new clients immediately. Call today for a free estimate on your next project!

"Erik was great. I called him on Friday and he came the next day. He took the time to explain things to me the day of his visit and even after we received our appraisal. He even had our appraisal ready within the week. Thank you Erik"

Shannon C on December 2019


Avatar for Akrivis Real Estate Valuations

Akrivis Real Estate Valuations

4.43(
14
)
Approved Pro

Akrivis Real Estate Valuations

4.43(
14
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
2018 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Welcome to the future of real estate valuation solutions with Akrivis. We combine innovation and evolving technology with our exclusive network of photography contractors to deliver accurate real estate valuations in less than five days. No stress, no fuss, just fast and reliable property values.

"Hired to do valuation of a manufactured home - not on land. Gave appraisal comparison properties included land. therefore not an accurate valuation. Thought salesperson understood nuance. "

Melissa P on October 2025

Welcome to the future of real estate valuation solutions with Akrivis. We combine innovation and evolving technology with our exclusive network of photography contractors to deliver accurate real estate valuations in less than five days. No stress, no fuss, just fast and reliable property values.

"Hired to do valuation of a manufactured home - not on land. Gave appraisal comparison properties included land. therefore not an accurate valuation. Thought salesperson understood nuance. "

Melissa P on October 2025


Avatar for Mike Murgatroy CrossCountry Mortgage

Mike Murgatroy CrossCountry Mortgage

4.94(
503
)

Mike Murgatroy CrossCountry Mortgage

4.94(
503
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

Mike Murgatroy has 24 years of lending experience and is an Angi Super Service Award recipient 2012-2022. Mike is also ranked in the top 1% mortgage originators in the United States. With integrity at the core of his values, you can rest assured that Mike Murgatroy will give you informed detailed mortgage advice, the same he would recommend to his own family. We pride ourselves on having a transparent process which we will walk you through every step of the way. Start your application process today by visiting themurgteam.com and find out why so many others continue to bring their business to Mike Murgatroy. NMLS ID# 60099; http://www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org

"It went great again. I am a repeat customer. They are professional, organized, and they perform like a well oiled machine. From the application process to the closing A+++++++ They do what they say they are going to do in a timely manner. I cannot say enough about this team. Thank you for another great experience Michael, Peter, Monica, and Connie."

joseph v on March 2022

Mike Murgatroy has 24 years of lending experience and is an Angi Super Service Award recipient 2012-2022. Mike is also ranked in the top 1% mortgage originators in the United States. With integrity at the core of his values, you can rest assured that Mike Murgatroy will give you informed detailed mortgage advice, the same he would recommend to his own family. We pride ourselves on having a transparent process which we will walk you through every step of the way. Start your application process today by visiting themurgteam.com and find out why so many others continue to bring their business to Mike Murgatroy. NMLS ID# 60099; http://www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org

"It went great again. I am a repeat customer. They are professional, organized, and they perform like a well oiled machine. From the application process to the closing A+++++++ They do what they say they are going to do in a timely manner. I cannot say enough about this team. Thank you for another great experience Michael, Peter, Monica, and Connie."

joseph v on March 2022


Roof Renew Pros LLC

4.93(
59
)

Roof Renew Pros LLC

4.93(
59
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers

Roof Renew Pros LLC. Was the first Roof Cleaning Company In NJ. We have over 25 years of combined education in all areas of cleaning. We are a professional exterior cleaning and preservation company that has very unique services. Selling your home? We offer " Exterior Staging" to get that curb appeal you need. " You never get a 2nd chance to make a 1st Impression". Roof Renew Pros offers cleaning in all phases of roof cleaning, no high pressure, and no bleach, phosphates, chlorine, or lye's. No Watering down of shrubs before we clean, our technicians do not need or wear respirator masks. There are no chemicals and no harmful products to people, water flow ,flowers, grass, children, pets, etc. We consistently stay abreast of new green cleaning products being released so that we may stay green longer and keep up with the changing surfaces and elements that the environment throws at us. We have a 100% guarantee on our work. Call today for a free estimate and 10% off any of our services.

"As an environmentally conscious household, it was important to us to hire a service that used neither harsh chemicals, nor bleach products for roof cleaning. I previously received Roof Renew Pros’ mailer and held onto it for this occasion as we had gotten moss and lichen growth on our roof. I kept the mailer as it stated their use of organic products, as well as no pressure washing, which was very important to us. After reading reviews, we decided to call RRP. Barbara came and inspected our roof, explained what was growing on it and took photos for us to see what was going on up there. There was more moss on our roof than we had initially thought. Barbara went over the process, what would be done on the day of and next day, gave us the price, so we booked our cleaning. The RRP crew arrived on the day, cleaned our roof in a timely manner and applied a sealer to prevent new growth anytime soon. Our roof is now lichen/moss-free and winter ready. It looks like it did when we first moved in. The crew was thorough and very helpful. The price fell within what we expected to pay for such a service and the fact that RRP use organic products, was HUGE to us. We’ll definitely use RRP in the future and totally recommend this company for your roof cleaning! Quality and eco consciousness matters to us, since our home is our biggest investment."

Gosia G on November 2025

Roof Renew Pros LLC. Was the first Roof Cleaning Company In NJ. We have over 25 years of combined education in all areas of cleaning. We are a professional exterior cleaning and preservation company that has very unique services. Selling your home? We offer " Exterior Staging" to get that curb appeal you need. " You never get a 2nd chance to make a 1st Impression". Roof Renew Pros offers cleaning in all phases of roof cleaning, no high pressure, and no bleach, phosphates, chlorine, or lye's. No Watering down of shrubs before we clean, our technicians do not need or wear respirator masks. There are no chemicals and no harmful products to people, water flow ,flowers, grass, children, pets, etc. We consistently stay abreast of new green cleaning products being released so that we may stay green longer and keep up with the changing surfaces and elements that the environment throws at us. We have a 100% guarantee on our work. Call today for a free estimate and 10% off any of our services.

"As an environmentally conscious household, it was important to us to hire a service that used neither harsh chemicals, nor bleach products for roof cleaning. I previously received Roof Renew Pros’ mailer and held onto it for this occasion as we had gotten moss and lichen growth on our roof. I kept the mailer as it stated their use of organic products, as well as no pressure washing, which was very important to us. After reading reviews, we decided to call RRP. Barbara came and inspected our roof, explained what was growing on it and took photos for us to see what was going on up there. There was more moss on our roof than we had initially thought. Barbara went over the process, what would be done on the day of and next day, gave us the price, so we booked our cleaning. The RRP crew arrived on the day, cleaned our roof in a timely manner and applied a sealer to prevent new growth anytime soon. Our roof is now lichen/moss-free and winter ready. It looks like it did when we first moved in. The crew was thorough and very helpful. The price fell within what we expected to pay for such a service and the fact that RRP use organic products, was HUGE to us. We’ll definitely use RRP in the future and totally recommend this company for your roof cleaning! Quality and eco consciousness matters to us, since our home is our biggest investment."

Gosia G on November 2025


Avatar for AMERICAN FEDERAL MORTGAGE CORP

AMERICAN FEDERAL MORTGAGE CORP

4.86(
96
)

AMERICAN FEDERAL MORTGAGE CORP

4.86(
96
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers

Although new to Angie's List, American Federal has been a recognized leader in the mortgage lending industry for 26 years. We offer an incredible combination of the lowest rates and fees guaranteed in writing along with excellent customer service. Whether you are buying a home or refinancing, our goal is provide you with the most enjoyable and stress-free experience as possible. We strive to be the same type of trusted company that Angie's List is, which is what will make us such a great fit for you! Click on the following link to get a first hand account from our Zillow reviews: http://www.zillow.com/profile/American-Federal/Reviews/

"Great! Easy and fast."

Alice H on August 2019

Although new to Angie's List, American Federal has been a recognized leader in the mortgage lending industry for 26 years. We offer an incredible combination of the lowest rates and fees guaranteed in writing along with excellent customer service. Whether you are buying a home or refinancing, our goal is provide you with the most enjoyable and stress-free experience as possible. We strive to be the same type of trusted company that Angie's List is, which is what will make us such a great fit for you! Click on the following link to get a first hand account from our Zillow reviews: http://www.zillow.com/profile/American-Federal/Reviews/

"Great! Easy and fast."

Alice H on August 2019


Avatar for BOE Mortgage

BOE Mortgage

5.00(
28
)

BOE Mortgage

5.00(
28
)
Customers say: Terrific value
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

At Bank of England Mortgage, we take pride in being there when our borrowers need us, day and night. Our mission is to deliver total value to our customers. This means competitive rates, STRESS-FREE closings, extensive product knowledge, and a friendly helpful attitude. Since our doors opened in 1898 in England, Arkansas, Bank of England Mortgage has been providing down home service. Along with powerful nationwide mortgage loans, we offer clients peace of mind knowing they are working with a credible national mortgage banker. We understand you're making a commitment when buying a new home, refinancing or cashing out the equity in your home. You can be certain that we'll do our utmost to answer all of your questions quickly, so you can be confident that you have the best loan to fit your financial goals. Our mortgage professionals stand by ready to give you the personal attention you deserve and treat you with the respect due a valued customer. Bank of England Mortgage is a division of Bank of England. NMLS 418481. Member FDIC. Equal Housing Lender.

"Excellent. Got me the best rate for the lowest costs"

Randy L on August 2019

At Bank of England Mortgage, we take pride in being there when our borrowers need us, day and night. Our mission is to deliver total value to our customers. This means competitive rates, STRESS-FREE closings, extensive product knowledge, and a friendly helpful attitude. Since our doors opened in 1898 in England, Arkansas, Bank of England Mortgage has been providing down home service. Along with powerful nationwide mortgage loans, we offer clients peace of mind knowing they are working with a credible national mortgage banker. We understand you're making a commitment when buying a new home, refinancing or cashing out the equity in your home. You can be certain that we'll do our utmost to answer all of your questions quickly, so you can be confident that you have the best loan to fit your financial goals. Our mortgage professionals stand by ready to give you the personal attention you deserve and treat you with the respect due a valued customer. Bank of England Mortgage is a division of Bank of England. NMLS 418481. Member FDIC. Equal Housing Lender.

"Excellent. Got me the best rate for the lowest costs"

Randy L on August 2019



Avatar for Auto Transporters Online

Auto Transporters Online

4.89(
36
)

Auto Transporters Online

4.89(
36
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 94% of Angi customers
Recommended by 94% of HomeAdvisor customers

Best Nationwide Car Shipping with affordable rates and superior customer service. Plan ahead and save money. No deposit required. Ship your car safely and affordably. Established over 15 years. A+ rated with BBB. Open & enclosed, door to door auto transport. MILITARY, STUDENT, SENIOR, MULTIPLE CAR DISCOUNTS. Family owned and will work directly with the owner from start to finish. We provide honest quotes and spend the time it takes with our customers to offer a rate that meets their needs. Superior customer service throughout the entire shipping process, until your car is delivered. Contact us or call for a quick quote @ 1(855) 813-2002. Always happy to answer your questions or just to review how the business works. You owe it to yourself to try us first. Call directly for best quote 1(855) 813-2002

"They were responsive to the inquiry and price competitive. The car was picked up in short order and arrived a couple of days later. I've been through this drill before and been unhappy, but these folks were very good!"

Larry W on July 2018

Best Nationwide Car Shipping with affordable rates and superior customer service. Plan ahead and save money. No deposit required. Ship your car safely and affordably. Established over 15 years. A+ rated with BBB. Open & enclosed, door to door auto transport. MILITARY, STUDENT, SENIOR, MULTIPLE CAR DISCOUNTS. Family owned and will work directly with the owner from start to finish. We provide honest quotes and spend the time it takes with our customers to offer a rate that meets their needs. Superior customer service throughout the entire shipping process, until your car is delivered. Contact us or call for a quick quote @ 1(855) 813-2002. Always happy to answer your questions or just to review how the business works. You owe it to yourself to try us first. Call directly for best quote 1(855) 813-2002

"They were responsive to the inquiry and price competitive. The car was picked up in short order and arrived a couple of days later. I've been through this drill before and been unhappy, but these folks were very good!"

Larry W on July 2018

...
Showing 1-10 of 693
Property Appraiser questions, answered by experts

While a single shelf here and there doesn’t add value to your home, a built-in bookcase can increase your home’s value under the right circumstances. Not every built-in bookcase works in your favor here—those built from high-quality materials tend to provide a better ROI. If you’re looking for your bookcase to work for your home’s value, consider having a professional build it with luxury hardwood.

While a finished basement adds value to your home, it is assigned a different value than space on the main floors. An appraiser will assess the square footage of a finished basement at about 50% to 60% of the value of the square footage for the rest of your home. Appraisal value for a finished basement depends on your location’s real estate market and the specifics of the basement and how it was finished. 

Home and property appraisals cost about $355 on average, ranging from $250 to $500, depending on the size of the home and property, age of the property, comparability to nearby homes, and location. While single-family homes typically cost between $300 and $400 to appraise, multi-family home appraisal can cost $500 to $1,000 due to the increased size and building complexity.

Land doesn’t depreciate in the same way that a house, vehicle, or other property does, but it can lose value based on various factors. Environmental changes, nearby development, zoning changes, and economic downturns can all cause land to lose value over time. Value is a comparative figure, so as other related factors change, so can land’s value.

In most cases, installing a tennis court on your property will drive up your property taxes. Property taxes are determined, in part, based on improvements made to your property, which includes anything with a permanent foundation. Since most home tennis courts include a large concrete foundation, your property taxes will likely increase following the installation. A general rule of thumb is that if your project requires permits—like for a foundation or fencing for a tennis court—then your property taxes will be affected.

The Montauk, NY homeowners’ guide to property appraisals

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

What do you need done? We’ll find top pros.
  • 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
  • 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
  • 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"