Top-rated handymen.

Get matched with top handymen in Middle Island, NY

There are 32 highly-rated local handymen.

Need a pro for your handyman service project in Middle Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY MIDDLE ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.4
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon407
    Verified handyman services reviews

Handymen in Middle Island

The Right Guys
361 Sheep Pasture Road
No reviews
The Right Guys
361 Sheep Pasture Road
No reviews
Free onsite estimate

We are two strong and hard working guys and together we run The Right Guys, a full service home clean out and organizing business. We cover the Suffolk county area here in Long Island. We offer all kinds of support related to your house clean out or organizing needs. We love tackling densely packed and chaotic garages, basements, and attics to name a few and can easily fill a dumpster and demo old furniture to make space for the new or a move. We also do yard clean ups. Call us today for a free home estimate and if you already have a quote I am sure we can beat it. We are committed to your complete satisfaction so contact us to find out how we can help!

We are two strong and hard working guys and together we run The Right Guys, a full service home clean out and organizing business. We cover the Suffolk county area here in Long Island. We offer all kinds of support related to your house clean out or organizing needs. We love tackling densely packed and chaotic garages, basements, and attics to name a few and can easily fill a dumpster and demo old furniture to make space for the new or a move. We also do yard clean ups. Call us today for a free home estimate and if you already have a quote I am sure we can beat it. We are committed to your complete satisfaction so contact us to find out how we can help!


Sure Renovations
36 Meroke Lane
5.00(
5
)
Sure Renovations
36 Meroke Lane
5.00(
5
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Specializing in kitchens, bathrooms, basements, decks, siding, windows and all other phases of residential home improvements. Licensed and insured.

"Hired Sure Renovations to renovate my kitchen. Eddie and his guys did an amazing job! They were on time, clean and did excellent work! They gave me a very fair price and did everything they said they would do. Our Kitchen looks amazing! My wife and I couldn't be happier!"

Keith C on May 2024

Specializing in kitchens, bathrooms, basements, decks, siding, windows and all other phases of residential home improvements. Licensed and insured.

"Hired Sure Renovations to renovate my kitchen. Eddie and his guys did an amazing job! They were on time, clean and did excellent work! They gave me a very fair price and did everything they said they would do. Our Kitchen looks amazing! My wife and I couldn't be happier!"

Keith C on May 2024


Top Tier Fencing
24 Shore Rd
No reviews
Top Tier Fencing
24 Shore Rd
No reviews
Free onsite estimate

We are a family owned and operated company servicing Nassau and Suffolk county for 10+ years. Customer satisfaction is what determines our success. We're particularly focused on the principles of quality workmanship, timely completion, competitive pricing, and integrity in all our business dealings.

We are a family owned and operated company servicing Nassau and Suffolk county for 10+ years. Customer satisfaction is what determines our success. We're particularly focused on the principles of quality workmanship, timely completion, competitive pricing, and integrity in all our business dealings.


Corbin Building Maintenance
Plainview
No reviews
Corbin Building Maintenance
Plainview
No reviews
Emergency services offered

Providing commercial and residential building maintenance and detailed cleaning for more than 10 years. Serving the Long Island and NYC area. Based out of Nassau County.

Providing commercial and residential building maintenance and detailed cleaning for more than 10 years. Serving the Long Island and NYC area. Based out of Nassau County.


Nation Wide Assembly LLC
No reviews
Nation Wide Assembly LLC
No reviews
7 years of experience

Nation Wide Assembly LLC We specialize in A large variety of Assembly and Repairs include: Massage Chair Assembly, Gazebo Assembly, Pergola Assembly, Air Hockey Table Assembly, Greenhouse Assembly, Shed Assembly, All Indoor & Outdoor Furniture, Saunas, Sheds, Pool Tables, Carport "See us for all your DELIVERY, ASSEMBLY, SERVICE & CONTRACTOR needs."

Nation Wide Assembly LLC We specialize in A large variety of Assembly and Repairs include: Massage Chair Assembly, Gazebo Assembly, Pergola Assembly, Air Hockey Table Assembly, Greenhouse Assembly, Shed Assembly, All Indoor & Outdoor Furniture, Saunas, Sheds, Pool Tables, Carport "See us for all your DELIVERY, ASSEMBLY, SERVICE & CONTRACTOR needs."



Total Care Solutions
No reviews
Total Care Solutions
No reviews
Free onsite estimate

"Welcome to Total Care Solutions, your premier destination for top-notch construction, cleaning and handyman services. With our unwavering commitment to excellence and attention to detail, we transform construction sites into pristine spaces, and tackle household repairs with precision and expertise. Trust us to deliver exceptional results, every time."

"Welcome to Total Care Solutions, your premier destination for top-notch construction, cleaning and handyman services. With our unwavering commitment to excellence and attention to detail, we transform construction sites into pristine spaces, and tackle household repairs with precision and expertise. Trust us to deliver exceptional results, every time."


MC South Shore Contracting Inc
No reviews
MC South Shore Contracting Inc
No reviews

All forms of carpentry/handyman work. No job too big or small

All forms of carpentry/handyman work. No job too big or small


Alexander Beltran - Handyman/Construction
No reviews
Alexander Beltran - Handyman/Construction
No reviews
Free onsite estimate

I have worked in the Construction/Handyman field for 20 years in NYC and Long Island. You can always be rest assured you will have knowledgeable and reliable work being done when I am hired. Customer Satisfaction is always my main concern and my focus when you are my customer. You can always count on me for any of your Handyman/Construction needs. For me, the customer comes first. Always count on Alexander! We also offer Cleaning services of any Kind. Hablamos Espanol!

I have worked in the Construction/Handyman field for 20 years in NYC and Long Island. You can always be rest assured you will have knowledgeable and reliable work being done when I am hired. Customer Satisfaction is always my main concern and my focus when you are my customer. You can always count on me for any of your Handyman/Construction needs. For me, the customer comes first. Always count on Alexander! We also offer Cleaning services of any Kind. Hablamos Espanol!


GC Custom Glass
No reviews
GC Custom Glass
No reviews

Custom glass shower door installer - Custom glass shower doors - Fixed panels with hinged doors -Cambridge style sliders -Fixed panel with one slider -All phases of shower enclosures Free estimates 631-579-1988

Custom glass shower door installer - Custom glass shower doors - Fixed panels with hinged doors -Cambridge style sliders -Fixed panel with one slider -All phases of shower enclosures Free estimates 631-579-1988

...
...
Showing 31-40 of 205

FAQs for handyman service projects in Middle Island, NY

The average cost to hire a handyman ranges from about $40 to $140 per hour. Average project cost ranges between $180 and $700, but the cost per hour and per project depends heavily on the type, size, and complexity of the project. The pro’s experience level and your location also factor into how much a handyman charges per hour or per project. You can also expect to pay higher rates or additional fees for emergency services, or around periods of high customer demand, like holidays. 

Tipping a handyman is not a requirement or necessarily expected, as they should build a fair wage into the price of the job. However, some people will tip a handyman around $10 to $20 per hour or the equivalent of a day’s pay, depending on the size of the job. But it’s up to your discretion. There are no set rules for tipping a handyman service, but if they did a great job and you’re so inclined to tip, it’s encouraged and will likely be received with thanks.

There are several questions or things to know before hiring a handyman to do any work in your home.

  • What kind of work do they do?

  • Do they have proper licensing?

  • Do they charge for estimates?

  • Is the estimate for both labor and materials?

  • Do they provide references?

  • Do you provide a guarantee?

  • When can you start and finish the job?

  • Do you have any before and after photos of your work?

  • How long have you been doing this kind of work?

  • Do you clean up and dispose of waste when the job is finished?

Yes, you should hire a handyman who’s licensed, certified, and insured, if possible. States have different requirements for handyman licensing, registration, and certifications. If licensing is required in your area, you may pay more for a licensed handyman with experience than one who is not licensed or certified, but you’re likely to get a better end result for your project. Be sure to check our state licensing tool to review the local handymen guidelines.

The Middle Island, NY homeowners’ guide to handyman services
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
A handyperson shakes hands with a home owner
Dec 18, 2024
Dec 18, 2024
Handyperson prices vary widely since they work on so many different jobs. Using this guide, you’ll get a better understanding of why the cost of a handyperson changes based on the job, size of the project, and where you live.
Toddler and dog looking at backyard chicken coop
Jan 21, 2025
Jan 21, 2025
Find out how much it costs to build a chicken coop—whether you've got a few hens in your backyard or a big, self-sustaining flock—with our expert guide.
Handyman Chris McNeill from C.A. Shamrock LLC  carefully installs a ceiling light fixture, focusing intently on connecting the fixture wiring.
May 1, 2025
May 1, 2025
Handyperson prices vary widely since they work on so many different jobs. Using this guide, you’ll get a better understanding of why the cost of a handyperson changes based on the job, size of the project, and where you live.
A living room with a mounted TV on a brick wall
Aug 13, 2024
Aug 13, 2024
Whether you need to hang a picture or mount a TV, this step-by-step guide on how to drill into brick will make the entire process a breeze.
Home attic space with exposed beams
Jul 21, 2025
Jul 21, 2025
Discover the cost to install faux wood beams. Learn about price factors, installation options, and ways to save on your faux wood beam project.
A set of tools, including a power drill, screwdriver, wire stripper, and electrical socket, are neatly arranged on a concrete floor beside a wall opening.
May 15, 2025
May 15, 2025
Every good handyperson knows that bringing the right tools to the job helps them work smarter and faster. From installing fixtures to assembling furniture to doing repairs and remodeling, we’ve rounded up the ultimate handyperson tool list.