Top-rated contractors.

Best contractors near Cincinnatus, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your contractor service project in Cincinnatus, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

Top-Rated Contractors in Cincinnatus - Updated Nov 2026

Avatar for Renovations Gone Wild
Renovations Gone Wild
5.0(
8
)
Major Home Repairs (General Contractor)

Serving Cincinnatus, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2006

Customers say: True professional

"Gary, and his crew have been amazing from minute one. Price is spot on, timing has been what was promised, quality of work is exactly what i needed; perfection. I will be hiring this organization for my next project as well."
Before
Roof removal
Railing installation
Massive deck
Mid construction

+13

Response time2 days
Response rate100%
10 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Atlas James Construction & Fabrication
Atlas James Construction & Fabrication
4.6(
10
)
Major Home Repairs (General Contractor)

Serving Cincinnatus, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 2022

Free estimates

"Everything is going great! I met with John, Stephen & Sabrina multiple times and their vision and understanding is always aligned with mine. They really make you their #1 priority which to me is really important. Ive hired other contractors that were extremely unprofessional and put other projects between and ahead of mine even though Id been under contract prior to them. I feel confident with Atlas James and excited to finally have found real professionals to get our projects done!"
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+3

Recommended by90%of homeowners
Avatar for Modern Builds and Maintenance LLC
Modern Builds and Maintenance LLC
5.0(
5
)
Major Home Repairs (General Contractor)

Serving Cincinnatus, NY and surrounding areas

Free estimates

"The entire thing was smooth from start to finish! Received an upfront estimate on the flooring install for the entire basement & framing for the basement layout. Prices for material and labor remained fair throughout entire project which was especially important during these trying times. Extremely professional, true craftsmanship."
Fireplace upgrade with white stone
Tile floor install
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+14

Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for Homemade Design
Homemade Design
3.7(
322
)
Major Home Repairs (General Contractor)

Serving Cincinnatus, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 2006

Credit card accepted

"After I approved the drapes, I was sent an invoice for $700. I paid the invoice. It's been over a year and despite numerous emails (over a dozen) with Amanda Zettel of Homemade Design, I still have not received the drapes or a refund. I was very satisfied with all of Homemade Design's work up until this experience."
Pennsylvania Master Bathroom
Boston Small Condo Kitchen
California Client Saves with HMD Designer Discounts
Recommended by54%of homeowners
Avatar for Jill Seidner Interior Design
Jill Seidner Interior Design
3.5(
89
)
Major Home Repairs (General Contractor)

Serving Cincinnatus, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 2006

Credit card accepted

"Once I sent her all the measurements, it took her a little while to get the options back to me.  Overall, they're good designs.  However, they're very simplistic and give general ideas for space planning.  I was hoping to have a better idea for sizes of furniture for the space and some variations on staging.  
Jill was very responsive when I did have a question.  I'm not sure how helpful it is to have a virtual design done.  If we lived in similar cities, I'd probably use her again for help with additional designs.
"
Recommended by55%of homeowners
Avatar for His and Her Flooring & Electric
His and Her Flooring & Electric
4.2(
11
)
Major Home Repairs (General Contractor)

Serving Cincinnatus, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 2017

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"It's still on going but have no doubt in their abilities to finish and follow through and do a great job. Communications is great! Has been a pleasure dealing with Dustin and Destiny. I had some pretty bad experiences choosing a contractor before I found His and Hers. But upon meeting with them I knew I was going to be very happy with them and their work. Not your typical contractor, they are just there to do the best job they can for an honest fee, very honest and no games. I will be using them to install my windows and drywall as well. Highly recommended!"
Lvt flooring install (Susan)
Before picture
Lvt install going into kitchen from dinning room
After pressure washing.
Electrical Project

+65

Recommended by87%of homeowners
Showing 1-10 of 50
Unfinished Carpentry FAQs, answered by experts

Converting a carport into a garage can vary in difficulty depending on its configuration, the condition of the foundation or slab, and its location relative to the house. The process has a lot in common with a home addition, but you can often skip non-essential finishes like fine flooring, trim work, or even drywall and HVAC. The conversion requires experience with drywall, insulation, and other building materials to ensure it’s done safely and correctly. While it might be possible for a DIYer with the proper tools and skills to do the work, it is a complicated and potentially dangerous job. If you’re new to basic construction, it's best to leave this project to the professionals.

Traditionally, bungalows are single-story homes, although having a half or partial story on top of the first floor is common. While adding a second story to a bungalow is certainly possible, the home would no longer be considered a bungalow by the strictest definition.

Bump-out additions can add some space to a closet without requiring any significant structural work. This entails pushing back the existing rear or side of the closet, simply moving the wall into either an adjacent room or unused space. For ground-floor closets, this could even be extended to the exterior of the home, but that has its own complications. Bump-outs are a good discussion to have with your contractor if you’re just looking to increase the space a little—not renovate the entire closet space.

Most Cape Cod houses are two stories tall at the peak, although they’re considered one-and-a-half stories tall because the steep roof pitch cuts off a portion of the living space on the second story. Unless you raise the roof on your Cape Cod house to add a dormer, the interior rooms upstairs will lose some usable living space to the sloped ceilings.

The best way to calculate framing costs is by basing your costs on the square footage of your home. On average, framing your home could cost anywhere between $7 and $16 per square foot. 

To ensure you don’t go over budget, base your estimates on the higher end of the price range. If you know you’re going to use high-end materials or require a custom or complex build, you might even want to tack on an additional 5% of your budget.

The Cincinnatus, NY homeowners’ guide to contractor services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.