Top-rated plaster repair specialists.

Get matched with top plaster repair specialists in New Carlisle, IN

Enter your ZIP and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your plaster repair project in New Carlisle, IN?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY NEW CARLISLE, IN HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.2
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon42
    Verified plaster repairs reviews

Verified Reviews for Plaster Repair pros in New Carlisle, IN

*The Angi rating for Plaster Repair companies in New Carlisle, IN is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Plaster Repair needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Plaster Repair companies in New Carlisle, IN is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Plaster Repair needs.

Last update on November 04, 2025

Find Plaster repair specialists in New Carlisle

Avatar for PatchMaster Serving South Bend

PatchMaster Serving South Bend

517 Edgewater Dr
4.75(
4
)
•Approved Pro

PatchMaster Serving South Bend

517 Edgewater Dr
4.75(
4
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
43 local quotes requested

Dings. Holes. Water damage. There are some things even a well-placed picture can’t hide.  Lucky for you, there’s PatchMaster, The Drywall Repair Specialists. Our skilled technicians can patch holes, replace water-damaged drywall, and fix dings and dents, leaving you with beautiful smooth walls. They’ll even match the texture and paint color of the existing walls. Just one phone call to us and your walls or ceiling will be beautiful in no time. Contact us today to see how we can help.

"Very good. Excellent job and no mess left to clean up. Your representative knew what he was doing and did a terrific job."

Robert G on September 2024

Dings. Holes. Water damage. There are some things even a well-placed picture can’t hide.  Lucky for you, there’s PatchMaster, The Drywall Repair Specialists. Our skilled technicians can patch holes, replace water-damaged drywall, and fix dings and dents, leaving you with beautiful smooth walls. They’ll even match the texture and paint color of the existing walls. Just one phone call to us and your walls or ceiling will be beautiful in no time. Contact us today to see how we can help.

"Very good. Excellent job and no mess left to clean up. Your representative knew what he was doing and did a terrific job."

Robert G on September 2024

Avatar for Bonillas Master Touch

Bonillas Master Touch

Based In
5.00(
17
)
•Approved Pro

Bonillas Master Touch

Based In
5.00(
17
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
119 local quotes requested

I can do drywall and similar repairs. I also provide interior painting. I do any finishing touches to any interior wall. I make sure my customer is satisfied with my work. I always give a 1 year warranty a complete sheet of drywall or more. It is a self owned business. I have been doing drywall for 8 years and painting for 4 years.

"The week long project went very well. They communicated well with me. The project was done very effective and professionally!"

Justin K on April 2025

I can do drywall and similar repairs. I also provide interior painting. I do any finishing touches to any interior wall. I make sure my customer is satisfied with my work. I always give a 1 year warranty a complete sheet of drywall or more. It is a self owned business. I have been doing drywall for 8 years and painting for 4 years.

"The week long project went very well. They communicated well with me. The project was done very effective and professionally!"

Justin K on April 2025

Avatar for Jose's Drywall

Jose's Drywall

16361 Justine Street
4.63(
47
)
•Approved Pro

Jose's Drywall

16361 Justine Street
4.63(
47
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
128 local quotes requested
20 years of experience

We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality, and customer service that we provide to meet the consumer's needs. It is our mission to provide excellent workmanship and complete customer satisfaction from start to completion of a project. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job.

"They did an excellent job. They know what they're doing, and they take their time. with the situation and do it just right too. Of drywalling. The drywalling it was excellent. Patching up a crack, it was Excellent, I bet excellent what they're doing in the drywall area and also Fixing a hole in the kitchen, and they rebuild it. and put new tile ceilings and did an excellent job. Too. I was very impressed with both. two persons, of course."

Mark V on October 2025

We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality, and customer service that we provide to meet the consumer's needs. It is our mission to provide excellent workmanship and complete customer satisfaction from start to completion of a project. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job.

"They did an excellent job. They know what they're doing, and they take their time. with the situation and do it just right too. Of drywalling. The drywalling it was excellent. Patching up a crack, it was Excellent, I bet excellent what they're doing in the drywall area and also Fixing a hole in the kitchen, and they rebuild it. and put new tile ceilings and did an excellent job. Too. I was very impressed with both. two persons, of course."

Mark V on October 2025

Avatar for Elite Stucco & EIFS Solutions

Elite Stucco & EIFS Solutions

12125 E 65th St
4.93(
14
)

Elite Stucco & EIFS Solutions

12125 E 65th St
4.93(
14
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

We want to keep our customers safe, we can come out and do a FREE estimate and the customer does not need to come meet us outside. We will then send the estimate via email. WE FOLLOW SAFE DISTANCING PRACTICES Call us at 317-413-6654 Specialising in Commercial and Residential Exterior Repair, Restoration and installation of traditional Stucco, Synthetic Stucco and EIFS, waterproofing, Painting exterior, Luxury limestone Fireplaces and now Epoxy Flooring.

"Sergio was excellent! He worked through some cold and wet weather to complete a pretty large repair at my church. The results were outstanding!"

Mitchell L on April 2024

We want to keep our customers safe, we can come out and do a FREE estimate and the customer does not need to come meet us outside. We will then send the estimate via email. WE FOLLOW SAFE DISTANCING PRACTICES Call us at 317-413-6654 Specialising in Commercial and Residential Exterior Repair, Restoration and installation of traditional Stucco, Synthetic Stucco and EIFS, waterproofing, Painting exterior, Luxury limestone Fireplaces and now Epoxy Flooring.

"Sergio was excellent! He worked through some cold and wet weather to complete a pretty large repair at my church. The results were outstanding!"

Mitchell L on April 2024

Avatar for Williams Construction

Williams Construction

Unknown
No reviews yet

Williams Construction

Unknown
No reviews yet
Free onsite estimate

Williams Construction specializes in home and business repairs, remodels, improvements, expansions, additions and maintenance. Certified in mobile home repairs and experienced in handicap accessible improvements/upgrades.

Williams Construction specializes in home and business repairs, remodels, improvements, expansions, additions and maintenance. Certified in mobile home repairs and experienced in handicap accessible improvements/upgrades.

Mishawaka Handyman Services

2624 Northwood Dr.
No reviews yet

Mishawaka Handyman Services

2624 Northwood Dr.
No reviews yet
37 years of experience

Life Long Resident of Mishawaka, Indiana. Working in the trades since 1984. Subcontracting and Contracting Since 1988. Studied Building Trades for 2 yeasts ago Mishawaka High School. We had classroom lessons and built 2 houses from the ground up.

Life Long Resident of Mishawaka, Indiana. Working in the trades since 1984. Subcontracting and Contracting Since 1988. Studied Building Trades for 2 yeasts ago Mishawaka High School. We had classroom lessons and built 2 houses from the ground up.

Restoration Xperts

PO B0x 182
No reviews yet

Restoration Xperts

PO B0x 182
No reviews yet
18 years of experience

Who we are I AM THE DIFFERENCE. I MAKE RESTORATION XPERTS THE BEST CONSTRUCTION COMPANY THERE IS. I UNDERSTAND THAT ONE PERSON’S HARD WORK LEADS TO ANOTHER’S ACCOMPLISHMENT. I REPRESENT SO MANY YEARS OF EXPERIENCE IT IS ALMOST EMBARRASSING TO CALCULATE. I PROMISE TO RESPECT YOU AND YOUR PROPERTY TO WORK HARD AND DO MY BEST EVERYDAY. I WANT TO BE YOUR CONTRACTOR, YOUR FRIEND, AND YOUR TRUSTED ADVISOR FOR LIFE. I AM GOING TO COMMUNICATE CLEARLY AND MAKE THE TIME SPENT WITH RESTORATION XPERTS A PLEASURE TO REMEMBER. NO OTHER COMPANY IN TOWN CAN HAVE WHAT RESTORATION XPERTS HAS. RESTORATION XPERTS HAS ME.

Who we are I AM THE DIFFERENCE. I MAKE RESTORATION XPERTS THE BEST CONSTRUCTION COMPANY THERE IS. I UNDERSTAND THAT ONE PERSON’S HARD WORK LEADS TO ANOTHER’S ACCOMPLISHMENT. I REPRESENT SO MANY YEARS OF EXPERIENCE IT IS ALMOST EMBARRASSING TO CALCULATE. I PROMISE TO RESPECT YOU AND YOUR PROPERTY TO WORK HARD AND DO MY BEST EVERYDAY. I WANT TO BE YOUR CONTRACTOR, YOUR FRIEND, AND YOUR TRUSTED ADVISOR FOR LIFE. I AM GOING TO COMMUNICATE CLEARLY AND MAKE THE TIME SPENT WITH RESTORATION XPERTS A PLEASURE TO REMEMBER. NO OTHER COMPANY IN TOWN CAN HAVE WHAT RESTORATION XPERTS HAS. RESTORATION XPERTS HAS ME.

Showing 1-10 of 24
Plaster Repair questions, answered by experts

If you already have plaster walls and ceilings, adding new plaster costs $2 to $10 per square foot. For an average-sized room, that would come out to $1,200 to $10,000. However, the cost to replace plaster with drywall is higher—running between $720 and $1,250 for a 10-by-8-foot wall or ceiling (not including drywall finishing).

The short answer is yes, a sagging plaster ceiling is dangerous. Sagging plaster on a wall is something you should fix immediately, but it isn’t a major concern. If the same type of sagging occurs on a ceiling, however, you could be in danger of your ceiling falling in large chunks. When plaster sags, it loses its strength and ability to hold itself up. The bonds that hold it together are strong, though, so if a sagging area falls, it will take large pieces down with it.

Plaster provides a durable, soundproof, and moisture-resistant finish compared to drywall.

Drywall can be better than plaster if you’re installing a new wall and want to keep costs low. It’s much cheaper than installing plaster and provides a smooth, uniform surface. Many homeowners simply paint over the drywall or add a texture like sand or orange peel. It’s also much easier to DIY than plaster, and if you need to change your layout, it’s much easier to remove.

Plaster is a beautiful finish but is labor-intensive to install and remove. It’s vulnerable to cracking and more sensitive to moisture variance than drywall. Installing plaster on a new wall is an expensive process that can take days to weeks, depending on the scope. Removing a plaster wall can also be quite expensive and time-consuming.

The New Carlisle, IN homeowners’ guide to plaster repairs

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles