Top-rated real estate agents work.

Get matched with top real estate agents in Indianapolis, IN

There are 22 highly-rated local real estate agents.

Matching on Angi

Share some details about your home project.
Within moments, match with highly-rated local Pros.
Compare quotes and choose the best Pro for the job.

Recent Real Estate Agent Reviews in Indianapolis

  • Steve Rupp - Real Estate Agent
    We never would have received an offer as high as we did without Steve’s help. He and his team were phenomenal through the whole process. They should be your only choice for a realtor in Indiana.
    Jason C.
  • Teresa Kohl, Century 21 Scheetz
    Teresa helped us find our forever home. She went above and beyond to be flexible and available to answer any questions that we had. All while very pregnant and it didn’t slow her down one bit. We have been completing some updates to the house and have not moved in just yet and can’t wait to get to actually move in
    Elizabeth W.
  • Indy Homes Team - Kristie Smith
    Amy McIntyre and the Indy Homes team are truly the best of the best! Amy is an excellent listener and heard everything that we were looking for in a house - she even heard all of the things that we didn't mention. She just knew! Her sense of humor and honesty made her so much fun to work with! She educated us along the way, she was patient, and the listings she sent us were spot on. She was available quickly when we liked a house and she was great at keeping us in the loop throughout the process. Amy truly made us feel like we were her one and only priority at all times, which is exceptional, especially in this housing market. She went above and beyond to utilize resources to find hidden gems for us. She has great insight into remodeling and renovations ideas plus the cost of them. Amy has great connections with contractors and was able to make things happen quickly to get issues resolved. I can honestly not say enough about Amy, Kristie, and Mariah - they were great throughout. The one last thing I will say about Amy is her ability to think differently to help us write a great offer and then delicately negotiate during the stages after made ALL the difference in the world. If it wasn't for that we never would've closed on the home we'll spend the next 20+ years
    Christine S.
  • Kyle Dickson with Coldwell Banker Kaiser
    I have known Kyle for quite a while and was wowed by his outgoing personality and attentiveness to each person he communicated with. I chose to work with him because of his extensive realty experience and extensive network. He was an excellent and thorough resource in helping me sell my mothers house. Thanks, Kyle I will recommend you to anyone
    Benjamin T.
  • Todd Cook Team - Keller Williams
    I couldn’t of asked for a better team to work with. The Todd Cook Team made the process easy and stress free from beginning until the end. Every member of the team helped me along the way. Makayla was amazing to work with and made the process fun.
    Amanda E.
  • Indy Homes Team - Kristie Smith
    It's been 16 years since we last purchased a home, so when we started this process we felt like first-time buyers again. In search of our forever home, our agent, Amy McIntyre helped us find the perfect house, in our desired neighborhood, for the best price. She was attentive, prompt, and always available. Since we lived in Florida, Amy was extremely accommodating and would take us on virtual showings. Amy demonstrated her thorough knowledge of home construction and local market value. Her assessment of homes we visited was methodical as she pointed out the quality of interior and exterior construction, finishes, the need for maintenance and upkeep and potential problems. She also cautioned us against falling for overpriced homes and making unreasonable offers. Amy was ALWAYS on our side. Her focus was always on keeping us within our price point, staying in our desired neighborhood and finding the home that met our needs. We knew helping us find the perfect home was more important than making the sale. Amy maintained daily communication as she sent daily emails and texts with updates. Her overall responsiveness was beyond compare. We appreciated her advice. The entire Indy Homes staff was extremely professional and detail oriented. We started with Indy Homes on Sept 1 and closed on Nov 16. Our closing day was a breeze. We are so happy in our new home and so grateful for Amy and associates. If ever anyone asks for an affordable, dedicated realtor, I am definitely sending them to see Amy McIntyre at Indy Homes
    Marion C.
  • The Paula Smith Group - Smith Family Realty
    Very quick find for her, she picked the perfect house she knew it checked all of requirements and goals.
    JD M.
  • Indy Homes Team - Kristie Smith
    After contacting Kristie about buying a home she quickly got me into contact with one of her agents and Amy was able to help me purchase my first home. Amy was great to work with! She was in constant contact and lined up showings quickly. She helped answer all of my questions and made me feel more comfortable in the buying process. The whole Indy Homes team made the buying process smooth especially for a first time buyer. Andrew also was in constant contact and continued to follow up with any concerns after purchasing. Extremely happy with Indy Homes and my new home
    Suzannah S.
  • The Paula Smith Group - Smith Family Realty
    David Lehenbauer was excellent! He answered all the questions we had, and helped us through the home buying process. You really couldn't ask for a better realtor! He has even stayed in touch to help remind us to file our exemptions with the county. I would highly recommend David to anyone looking to buy a home in the Indianapolis area
    Andrew S.
  • Indy Homes Team - Kristie Smith
    I have never met a real estate agent like Kristie Smith! She and her team of professional are absolutely amazing! If I were to sell another home, I would unequivocally choose Kristie and her team again! At our first meeting, Kristie determined the primary objective regarding the sale of our home. She and her team spent the next two months guiding us toward the accomplishment of this goal. Kristie suggested minor cosmetic changes to our home (i.e. painting, updating of lighting and plumbing fixtures, and staging of some rooms) to update our home and command a higher price. She listed our home at exactly the right price, ensuring an impressive number of showings (approximately twenty-three showings in two days). Kristie listed our home on a Saturday morning, and by Sunday evening we had three offers - all exceeding the asking price. She guided us in selecting the best offer, and by Monday morning, the deal was done! Kristie and her team go "above and beyond" the call of duty! The quality of workmanship completed by her team of professionals was exceptional - from the painters, to the plumber, to the stagers! They were all extremely professional and exceedingly conscientious! It was a pleasure to have them in our home! Even after the closing had been completed, Kristie continued to offer her assistance. She called back immediately when I phoned to ask for her help regarding finding temporary housing while our home was being built in another state. Her dedication to her clients is remarkable! Kristie sets a very high standard for herself and her team! They are, quite simply, the BEST! In the two months we worked with them, we came to regard them not only as professionals, but also as friends
    L R TRES & JOAN S.

Last update on April 27, 2022

See all 22 highly rated companies in Indianapolis
Join Angi now

Explore our Solution Center for helpful real estate agent articles

real estate agents in Indianapolis

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, join Angi now!

Rate Angi’s Real estate agent in Indianapolis

Featured Rating:

Real estate agent in Indianapolis are rated 4.8 out of 5 based on 2,886 reviews of the 27 featured Indianapolis pros

The Angi rating for Real estate agent in Indianapolis is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Real estate agent needs. Angi’s review system takes into account ratings on price, quality, timeliness, responsiveness and feedback for Angi Certified Pros.