How Much Does a Pool Remodel Cost in Indianapolis? [2025 Data]

Remodeling a pool in Indianapolis ranges from $2,700 to $17,000, with an average of $9,850. These costs are close to the national average, but your price can rise drastically if you make serious structural changes to your pool, perform complex repairs, or add a bunch of high-end upgrades.

Compared to sunnier states, Indiana has a high concentration of pools, which are ideal during hot summers. Let’s plunge into potential remodeling costs.

Pool Remodel Cost Factors

A local pool remodeling contractor can help you plan your remodel, from the design to the quality of the materials, which will impact the budget. 

Pool Size

Since Indiana has the largest average property sizes in the United States, some homeowners opt for larger pools. The amount you spend on a remodel depends on how much of your pool you’re remodeling. If you resurface your pool, you’ll spend $5 to $8 per square foot, but it could cost more than $30 per square foot for retiling. Here are some common costs for resurfacing alone, but repairs, reshaping, and added features cost extra.

Type of Repair or Replacement 

Most minor pool repairs cost $250 to $1,200 in Indianapolis, but pool remodels often include more extensive work like resurfacing, retiling, or liner replacement. The more repairs, the more your remodel will cost.

• Pool resurfacing: Pool resurfacing costs $6,000–$15,000, and resurfacing your pool with plaster is the most affordable option. Consider choosing a more durable resurfacing material, like pool aggregate, to handle Indiana’s harsh winters.

• Pool retiling: Replacing pool tile costs $3,000–$20,000, depending on how much you need to replace. The waterline will cost around $3,000, while tiling the entire pool could cost more than $35,000 if you use high-end tile. Most homeowners spend around $15,000 or about $25 per square foot.

• Pool painting: Painting your pool will cost $1,500–$2,500. Epoxy paints can disguise cosmetic imperfections. This type of finish lasts around five years, but you’ll need to apply it while the weather is mild to allow it to cure properly. 

• Pool deck resurfacing or repair: It will cost anywhere from $500–$5,000 to repair or resurface your pool deck. You can do this if you want to switch up the look or fix wear  and tear from years of use.

• Pool liner replacement: Pool liner replacement costs $1,300–$4,000. Make sure you choose a high quality liner that can withstand the frigid off-season in Indiana. 

• Equipment repairs: If you need to repair or replace pool equipment, you’ll spend $300–$4,000, depending on the work your contractor needs to do. Replacing a pump costs around $1,000, but a simple repair costs around $300.

• Plumbing repairs: If you need to make repairs to your pool’s plumbing (like if your pool springs a leak during the off-season), you’ll pay anywhere from $800–$3,500. 

Pool Upgrades

During a remodel, most homeowners install upgrades that modernize their pool or add a little bit of luxury or functionality. In Indiana, where winters are cold, most pools already have a heating system, but you could upgrade to a system with higher efficiency. Additionally, a hot tub can allow you to use your pool area year-round. 

Pool Expansion or Reshaping

Changing the size and shape of your pool during a remodel costs $40,000 to $80,000 in Indianapolis—which is almost the cost of installing a brand-new pool in the first place. This job requires major structural work. If you have an in-ground pool, you’ll need to excavate the new pool area. Fiberglass pools require a new fiberglass shell, and most aboveground pools require demolishing your old pool and installing a new one.

Pool Remodeling Pro Costs

Pool remodeling is best left to a pro, and labor makes up more than 40% of your budget.

Labor

On average, swimming pool contractors in Indianapolis charge $50 to $100 per hour for labor. There isn’t a specific state license for pools, but your contractor will need to hold an electrical or plumbing license to perform this type of work. Nearby jurisdictions have their own contractor licensing regulations, so check your specific area before choosing a contractor.

Permits

In Indiana, you’ll need a permit to remodel your pool. This costs $750, plus an additional $150 if you need to do any plumbing work. Pools have lots of local zoning requirements, but your contractor should create a remodel design that complies. 

Additional Pros to Consider Hiring

Based on the scope of the work, you may need to hire additional contractors. This could include the following costs:

• Electrician’s cost: $55–$120 per hour

• Plumber’s cost: $50–$200 per hour

• Landscaper’s cost: $50–$100 per hour

• Pool maintenance cost: $30–$260 per month

Does a Pool Increase Home Value in Indianapolis?

The return on investment (ROI) for a pool in Indiana is a maximum of 56%, but many different factors determine the overall value. Aboveground pools won’t add much value to your home, while an in-ground pool will add an average of 7%.

Unlike warmer states, a pool is not always an expected or wanted upgrade in Indianapolis. Smaller properties closer to the city center may see less value with a pool, since it will shrink the usable amount of property for much of the year. The cost of maintenance can also turn off buyers in more affordable areas, and you’ll find the most value in the luxury market.

How Angi Gets Its Cost Data

Home is the most important place on earth, which is why Angi has helped more than 150 million homeowners transform their houses into homes they adore. To help homeowners with their next project, Angi provides readers with the most accurate cost data and upholds strict editorial standards. We survey real Angi customers about their project costs to develop the pricing data you see, so you can make the best decisions for you and your home. We pair this data with research from reputable sources, including the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, academic journals, market studies, and interviews with industry experts—all to ensure our prices reflect real-world projects. 

Want to help us improve our cost data? Send us a recent project quote to [email protected]. Quotes and personal information will not be shared publicly.