The $20,000 Bathroom Remodel in New York, New York

Aka the Classic Mistake in the Classic Six

A collage featuring a black and white baroque style cement tile, a shiny black bathroom faucet, and a tiled shower with a black modern showerhead. Copy overlay says “$20,000 - New York, NY”.
Photo: VU PHAM VAN / brizmaker / Getty Images / midjourney
A collage featuring a black and white baroque style cement tile, a shiny black bathroom faucet, and a tiled shower with a black modern showerhead. Copy overlay says “$20,000 - New York, NY”.
Photo: VU PHAM VAN / brizmaker / Getty Images / midjourney
Get quotes from up to 3 pros!
Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.
Geo Icon

Welcome to Nosy Neighbor, where we ask all the questions you can’t about home projects and money. From incredible deals to domestic dramas, we’re bringing you real stories—and real numbers.

Want to (anonymously) share your own story? Let’s get honest, neighbor.

Age: 37

Location: New York, NY

How much did you pay for your home?

$500,000–$750,000

What was the project, and why did you do it?

My spouse's condition for buying our apartment was that we renovate the extremely tacky pink and black bathroom with crystal lights in which the fixtures barely worked. Fair.

A quote: “I didn't ask for references, read reviews, or even have the contractor sign a contract.”

How many quotes did you get? Did you price shop at all?

I did not price shop AT ALL—I had no idea what I was doing. I went with the first contractor I found (who was referred by an acquaintance of an acquaintance). I didn't ask for references, read reviews, ask for photos of past work, or even have him sign a contract. 

What could go wrong?

What did you think it was going to cost?

$10,000

What did it actually cost?

$20,000

Why the difference?

The contractor barely looked at the drawings I gave him, which were made by my architect brother. At each new step, he seemed shocked by the design, even though it had always been part of the plan, and said he needed to charge more. (Out of anyone's control, there was also water damage below the original tub.) 

We battled so much that by the end of the job, I was threatening to withhold his final payment, and he was threatening me with a contractor's lien (which I was threatening to wait out) until we finally agreed to terms. His final email to me said: "I JUST WANT THIS TO BE OVER."

How did you get the money to pay for the project?

Savings. I've always been a spendthrift.

What did you splurge on that was totally worth it?

Cement tiles. Oh, how I adore them—gorgeous and baroque, with black and white patterns.

What did you splurge on that totally wasn’t worth it?

Same answer: the cement tiles. They were $27.50 per square foot.

Did you cut any corners?

No. The bathroom is tiny. There were not many corners to cut.

What was the most surprising cost?

The water damage under the tub ($3,000).

What was the most stressful, emotional, or exciting part of the project?

Seeing everything completed was wonderful. We used one cement tile on the floor, another on the wall, a small subway tile in the shower, and a third cement tile in the window nook by the shower. The shower and sink fixtures are black, which is striking against the white. I still admire how it all comes together.

Any advice?

Do not do what I did! Don’t hire the first contractor you meet without getting multiple quotes, checking references, and going through the scope in detail to make sure they understand exactly what the job entails. I made all of the most basic, classic mistakes.

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.
The homeowners guide to kitchen and bathroom remodels
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
A half bathroom with a toilet and a sink
Jun 16, 2025
Jun 16, 2025
The cost to add a half bathroom varies based on geography and your choice of additions. Read on to discover just what factors into your total project cost.
Bathroom with black and white patterned floor tile
Jul 1, 2025
Jul 1, 2025
The cost to demo a bathroom depends on its size, complexity, extent of the demo, and whether you DIY or not. This guide will help you budget effectively.
Family in open concept house
May 18, 2025
May 18, 2025
The cost to remodel multiple rooms in your home will depend on what you wish to renovate and the size of the project. Both can affect your ROI.
Modern bathroom with rainhead shower
May 19, 2025
May 19, 2025
Repairing a showerhead is a doable task for all homeowners. This step-by-step guide provides all the information you need to fix your leaky showerhead.
modern luxury bathroom
Jun 29, 2025
Jun 29, 2025
Bathroom remodels are exciting but can lead to costly mistakes if you don’t work with a trusted professional. Ask a remodeling contractor these 9 questions to find the right person for the job.
A freestanding bathtub
Jun 2, 2025
Jun 2, 2025
If you’re installing a new bathroom, you’ll need to rough-in the plumbing. Here’s everything you need to know about bathtub rough-in dimensions.