Top-rated antique and jewelry appraisers.

Get matched with top antique and jewelry appraisers in Caledonia, WI

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your antique and jewelry appraisal project in Caledonia, WI?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY CALEDONIA, WI HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon3.8
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon47
    Verified antique and jewelry appraisals reviews

Verified Reviews for Antique And Jewelry Appraisal pros in Caledonia, WI

*The Angi rating for Antique And Jewelry Appraisal companies in Caledonia, WI is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Antique And Jewelry Appraisal needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Antique And Jewelry Appraisal companies in Caledonia, WI is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Antique And Jewelry Appraisal needs.

Last update on January 18, 2026

Find Antique and jewelry appraisers in Caledonia

Avatar for Johnson Inc Gold & Coin Collection Buyers

Johnson Inc Gold & Coin Collection Buyers

4.87(
84
)

Johnson Inc Gold & Coin Collection Buyers

4.87(
84
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 94% of Angi customers
Recommended by 94% of HomeAdvisor customers

Johnson, Inc. (a Numismatics co.), Nationally known, specializes in Coins, Currency, and Gold & Silver bullion items. We have two categories of service: Online Face to Face personalized service or In-Home for Florida residents. Estate acquisitions and trusts is our specialty. Our ONLINE APPRAISAL Service allows your items and our specialty to meet face to face regardless of distance. We back all our services up with your guaranteed satisfaction! Call or schedule your services today!

"VERY pleasant! Jewelry was appraised, check was issued (later deposited and cleared), and hospitality was a plus."

Ed S on March 2021

Johnson, Inc. (a Numismatics co.), Nationally known, specializes in Coins, Currency, and Gold & Silver bullion items. We have two categories of service: Online Face to Face personalized service or In-Home for Florida residents. Estate acquisitions and trusts is our specialty. Our ONLINE APPRAISAL Service allows your items and our specialty to meet face to face regardless of distance. We back all our services up with your guaranteed satisfaction! Call or schedule your services today!

"VERY pleasant! Jewelry was appraised, check was issued (later deposited and cleared), and hospitality was a plus."

Ed S on March 2021

Blackard & Geiger Ltd

4.88(
57
)

Blackard & Geiger Ltd

4.88(
57
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 94% of Angi customers
Recommended by 94% of HomeAdvisor customers

With a thirty-year history in the valuing estates, collections and personal property, we serve collectors worldwide. Our clientele consists of but are not limited to, private individuals, attorneys, accountants, insurance agents, museum curators, college administrators, executors and personal representatives of estates, estate planners, bank trust officers, real estate agents and corporations. All Certified Appraisals conform with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) of The Appraisal Foundation, Washington, D.C. We are certified by the International Society of Appraisers and are members of The American Society of Appraisers. Written Certified Appraisal Reports: - Fair Market Value for Estates, Guardianships or Trusteeships - Retail Replacement Value for Insurance Scheduling - Fair Market Value for Bankruptcy - Estate Equitable Divisions and Gifts - Retail Replacement Value – Used for Sale - Fair Market Value for Divorces, Donations and Damage/Loss - Insurance Replacement Coverage Consultation Services: - Consulting on Buying and Selling - Collection or Item Assessment and Cataloging - Collection Inventory Management and Curation - Downsizing and planning for a move

"Mr. Keller was very helpful. He listened to our request and then advised us on the least expensive way to accomplish what we needed. He invited us to send information & photos of the item and got right back to us with his assessment of the sale potential, a ballpark estimate of value, and connected us to an auction business that could sell it for us. He did not charge us for his time at all. We could not be happier—he understood better than we did that we didn’t need full appraisal services and met our needs without charging us (though he certainly could have provided services that were unnecessary for our situation and charged us for them, and we wouldn’t have known the difference). This is the very definition of integrity and trustworthiness! We will absolutely call him again."

BRENT & LAUREN W on February 2021

With a thirty-year history in the valuing estates, collections and personal property, we serve collectors worldwide. Our clientele consists of but are not limited to, private individuals, attorneys, accountants, insurance agents, museum curators, college administrators, executors and personal representatives of estates, estate planners, bank trust officers, real estate agents and corporations. All Certified Appraisals conform with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) of The Appraisal Foundation, Washington, D.C. We are certified by the International Society of Appraisers and are members of The American Society of Appraisers. Written Certified Appraisal Reports: - Fair Market Value for Estates, Guardianships or Trusteeships - Retail Replacement Value for Insurance Scheduling - Fair Market Value for Bankruptcy - Estate Equitable Divisions and Gifts - Retail Replacement Value – Used for Sale - Fair Market Value for Divorces, Donations and Damage/Loss - Insurance Replacement Coverage Consultation Services: - Consulting on Buying and Selling - Collection or Item Assessment and Cataloging - Collection Inventory Management and Curation - Downsizing and planning for a move

"Mr. Keller was very helpful. He listened to our request and then advised us on the least expensive way to accomplish what we needed. He invited us to send information & photos of the item and got right back to us with his assessment of the sale potential, a ballpark estimate of value, and connected us to an auction business that could sell it for us. He did not charge us for his time at all. We could not be happier—he understood better than we did that we didn’t need full appraisal services and met our needs without charging us (though he certainly could have provided services that were unnecessary for our situation and charged us for them, and we wouldn’t have known the difference). This is the very definition of integrity and trustworthiness! We will absolutely call him again."

BRENT & LAUREN W on February 2021

Avatar for Fisher Precious Metals

Fisher Precious Metals

5.00(
14
)

Fisher Precious Metals

5.00(
14
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Uncompromising quality and integrity in all of your precious metals purchases and sales. Specializing in gold & silver bullion. Avoid gold and silver retailers selling you their inventory at high premiums! We pay top prices for jewelry, sterling, diamonds and watches! Fisher Precious Metals is a national gold and silver dealer. Listed as a national dealer with the United States Mint, Fisher Precious Metals is a trusted resource for gold and silver coins and bars. Established in 1995, the firm works with individuals on all issues related to buying and selling physical precious metals, storage, security, estate liquidation and long-term exit strategies. John Fisher, the President, is an ICTA Board Member and is approved by the State of Florida to teach Continuing Education courses on precious metals investing to CFP's, CPA's, attorneys and insurance professionals. In addition, John is a frequent guest on various financial radio broadcast programs. Fisher Precious Metals is an A+ rated Accredited Business with the Better Business Bureau.

"It went great! We found Fisher Precious Metals on Angie's List, and after googling them, we found they had very positive reviews across the web. Although it was a 45 minute drive from our home, we felt it might be worth it, and it was. We made an appointment with John via email, arrived at 11:00, and spent just over an hour in his office. He evaluated the sterling silver set we had to sell and gave us what we felt was a very fair price. He'd given us an estimate on the value of the gold coins via email, and although the price of gold had fluctuated since he'd provided the quote, the final price was very, very close to the initial quote. We were happy to learn that they will also buy jewelry, as I have a few pieces I haven't worn in a very long time. We were very pleased with the entire experience and will definitely return to their company when we have gold or silver to sell, and we're happy to recommend them to our friends. One thing to keep in mind is that sterling silver sets are basically worth the price of the silver itself. We knew that going in, so we were not disappointed and, in fact, the price we received was a little higher than we'd expected."

Laura C on February 2018

Uncompromising quality and integrity in all of your precious metals purchases and sales. Specializing in gold & silver bullion. Avoid gold and silver retailers selling you their inventory at high premiums! We pay top prices for jewelry, sterling, diamonds and watches! Fisher Precious Metals is a national gold and silver dealer. Listed as a national dealer with the United States Mint, Fisher Precious Metals is a trusted resource for gold and silver coins and bars. Established in 1995, the firm works with individuals on all issues related to buying and selling physical precious metals, storage, security, estate liquidation and long-term exit strategies. John Fisher, the President, is an ICTA Board Member and is approved by the State of Florida to teach Continuing Education courses on precious metals investing to CFP's, CPA's, attorneys and insurance professionals. In addition, John is a frequent guest on various financial radio broadcast programs. Fisher Precious Metals is an A+ rated Accredited Business with the Better Business Bureau.

"It went great! We found Fisher Precious Metals on Angie's List, and after googling them, we found they had very positive reviews across the web. Although it was a 45 minute drive from our home, we felt it might be worth it, and it was. We made an appointment with John via email, arrived at 11:00, and spent just over an hour in his office. He evaluated the sterling silver set we had to sell and gave us what we felt was a very fair price. He'd given us an estimate on the value of the gold coins via email, and although the price of gold had fluctuated since he'd provided the quote, the final price was very, very close to the initial quote. We were happy to learn that they will also buy jewelry, as I have a few pieces I haven't worn in a very long time. We were very pleased with the entire experience and will definitely return to their company when we have gold or silver to sell, and we're happy to recommend them to our friends. One thing to keep in mind is that sterling silver sets are basically worth the price of the silver itself. We knew that going in, so we were not disappointed and, in fact, the price we received was a little higher than we'd expected."

Laura C on February 2018

THE JEWLERY CENTER

4.73(
15
)

THE JEWLERY CENTER

4.73(
15
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers

The Jewelry Center is a full service Jewelry Merchandiser and Repair Center filled with display items from many vendors. For example, we have Chamilia, Everlon, Citizen, Seiko, and much much more. We stock all types of jewelry including Charms, 10K Gold, White Gold, Rings, Bridal Sets, and Full service repair for all your Jewerly needs. Call us, we can get it. 414-282-7241 We are also the home of the $2.99 Watch Battery Replacement at any of our Stores on any day. Bring in your watches!

The Jewelry Center is a full service Jewelry Merchandiser and Repair Center filled with display items from many vendors. For example, we have Chamilia, Everlon, Citizen, Seiko, and much much more. We stock all types of jewelry including Charms, 10K Gold, White Gold, Rings, Bridal Sets, and Full service repair for all your Jewerly needs. Call us, we can get it. 414-282-7241 We are also the home of the $2.99 Watch Battery Replacement at any of our Stores on any day. Bring in your watches!

Avatar for New England Appraisers Assoc

New England Appraisers Assoc

4.77(
30
)

New England Appraisers Assoc

4.77(
30
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers

We are a national appraisal association of 300 members. We appraise antiques and art. Some members are dealers and gallery owners but all of us are anxious to serve you. Check our websites http://www.newenglandappraisers.org (click) "Find an Appraiser" for names and phone numbers of our members.

"Excellent and very informative"

Onalee A on January 2021

We are a national appraisal association of 300 members. We appraise antiques and art. Some members are dealers and gallery owners but all of us are anxious to serve you. Check our websites http://www.newenglandappraisers.org (click) "Find an Appraiser" for names and phone numbers of our members.

"Excellent and very informative"

Onalee A on January 2021

PAUL'S JEWELERS INC

4.50(
8
)

PAUL'S JEWELERS INC

4.50(
8
)
Customers say: Terrific value
58 years of experience

If you have a jewelry repair question, a jewelry design challenge, need some pieces assessed or just want a new piece of jewelry, contact Paul's Jewelers Incorporated! We are a family owned and operated business serving Milwaukee and the World for over 50 years. We ask you what you have that can be remade or repaired before we try to sell you something new! But if it is unique you are after, we carry European inspired Gems and Jewels from all over the World! Come see our collection.

If you have a jewelry repair question, a jewelry design challenge, need some pieces assessed or just want a new piece of jewelry, contact Paul's Jewelers Incorporated! We are a family owned and operated business serving Milwaukee and the World for over 50 years. We ask you what you have that can be remade or repaired before we try to sell you something new! But if it is unique you are after, we carry European inspired Gems and Jewels from all over the World! Come see our collection.

Avatar for POWERS JEWELRY DESIGNERS

POWERS JEWELRY DESIGNERS

5.00(
4
)

POWERS JEWELRY DESIGNERS

5.00(
4
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Looking for a Jeweler in the Milwaukee area? Powers Jewelry Designers has been in business for over 30 years and is family owned & operated. With a small staff of highly trained employees, we keep prices down while maintaining Quality, Value, & Integrity. We also offer flexible payment schedules. Stop in or check out our website today!

Looking for a Jeweler in the Milwaukee area? Powers Jewelry Designers has been in business for over 30 years and is family owned & operated. With a small staff of highly trained employees, we keep prices down while maintaining Quality, Value, & Integrity. We also offer flexible payment schedules. Stop in or check out our website today!

Avatar for Sell It Now Store

Sell It Now Store

5.00(
2
)

Sell It Now Store

5.00(
2
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

The Sell It Now Store™ is an auction services company that sells internationally both on eBay and live auction. We are A+ rated with the Better Business Bureau and fully insured and bonded. Discover why our experience, reputation, and education makes The Sell It Now Store™ Wisconsin's premiere consignment shop selling on eBay® and Live Auction. We are a WI Licensed Auction House and employ WI Licensed Auctioneers. Sell It Now Radio™ is SE Wisconsin's premier Radio Show where we discuss how to sell and value antiques and collectibles. We also discuss the best venues to sell items, and the unique and hot items in your attic, basement and garage. We hope you tune in! For more details and show schedule, or to be part of the Sell It Now Radio™ community, check out www.sellitnowradio.com Michael Boerschinger, Registered Wisconsin Auctioneer # 2725-52, Nichole Pirolo, Registered Wisconsin Auctioneer # 2726-52, Sell It Now Store, WI Licensed Auction Company #433-53

The Sell It Now Store™ is an auction services company that sells internationally both on eBay and live auction. We are A+ rated with the Better Business Bureau and fully insured and bonded. Discover why our experience, reputation, and education makes The Sell It Now Store™ Wisconsin's premiere consignment shop selling on eBay® and Live Auction. We are a WI Licensed Auction House and employ WI Licensed Auctioneers. Sell It Now Radio™ is SE Wisconsin's premier Radio Show where we discuss how to sell and value antiques and collectibles. We also discuss the best venues to sell items, and the unique and hot items in your attic, basement and garage. We hope you tune in! For more details and show schedule, or to be part of the Sell It Now Radio™ community, check out www.sellitnowradio.com Michael Boerschinger, Registered Wisconsin Auctioneer # 2725-52, Nichole Pirolo, Registered Wisconsin Auctioneer # 2726-52, Sell It Now Store, WI Licensed Auction Company #433-53

Showing 1-10 of 31
Antiques and Jewelry Appraisals questions, answered by experts

In short, yes, a pond can add to your home’s value. However, whether it adds value will depend on the condition and aesthetic of your pond. Having this feature already built into a yard’s home can be appealing to homebuyers who value its aesthetic and would prefer not to build it themselves. But if it is not kept in good condition, it could turn buyers away.

Estate shutters are considered a high-end window treatment that increases home value. As previously mentioned, this project comes with an ROI of up to 75%. Shutters can also improve your home’s energy efficiency, especially if you choose PVC or faux wood shutters, which will lead to long-term savings on your energy bills.

In cases where an appraisal comes in lower than an offer price, sellers might opt to lower their asking price to meet the appraisal, especially if the market is slow, and replacing the offer with a higher one may take a long time. Sellers can also offer to make repairs to boost the appraised value, hire another appraiser to get a second opinion, or just move on to another offer that isn’t contingent on the buyer getting a mortgage or an appraisal inspection.

While a finished basement adds value to your home, it is assigned a different value than space on the main floors. An appraiser will assess the square footage of a finished basement at about 50% to 60% of the value of the square footage for the rest of your home. Appraisal value for a finished basement depends on your location’s real estate market and the specifics of the basement and how it was finished. 

You can be present during a home appraisal, but it’s best to stay out of the appraiser’s way. Make yourself available, but don’t engage or interrupt, and don’t discuss value or your target sales price. If possible, have your agent present in the house instead of being present yourself.

The Caledonia, WI homeowners’ guide to antique and jewelry appraisals

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles

What do you need done? We’ll find top pros.
  • 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
  • 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
  • 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"