Top-rated bathtub replacement pros.

Best bathtub replacement pros near Pine Island, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your bathtub replacement project in Pine Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY PINE ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.5
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon436
    Verified bathtub replacements reviews

Top-Rated Bathtub replacement pros in Pine Island - Updated Nov 2026

Avatar for Bath Fitter
Bath Fitter
3.6(
205
)
Bathtub Liner or Shower Surround - Install or ReplaceBathtub Install or ReplaceBathtub Install or Replace - For Business

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1995

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"This was the second attempt to install my tub liner as the first installer cut the liner short and may have damage a couple of wall tiles in the process. A new tub liner had to be reordered and a different installer by the name of Paul Norton came out to the house to complete the job with a new liner. Paul was very courteous and professional in explaining everything that had to be done and even was able to repair the damaged tiles in a satisfactory manner. Except for the inconvenience of needing to have Bath Fitter come to my house for a second time to complete the job that should have been completed on the first try, I am happy with the final result and Especially the installer (PAUL NORTON) that came to the house the second time and finished the job. A Big Thank You to PAUL NORTON for a job well done."
Bathtub Installation
Bathtub Installation
Bathtub Installation
Bathtub Installation
Bathtub Installation

+42

Response time1 day
Response rate94%
145 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for HR DRYWALL AND HOME IMPROVEMENT INC.
HR DRYWALL AND HOME IMPROVEMENT INC.
5.0(
23
)
Bathroom - RemodelBathroom - Remodel - For BusinessBathtub Install or Replace+1 more

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1999

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"I would hire this company over and over again! Humberto, his son and their guys are amazing! Our bathroom and laundry room had gotten water damage due to a backed up sewer line. Humberto, his son, and their team replaced drywall, baseboards, primed and painted both rooms. They redid the laundry room floors, and the vanity in the bathroom. Everything looks amazing, and we have already discussed with them if they can redo the rest of downstairs, paint upstairs and my kitchen cabinets. They are VERY NEAT workers, always cleaning as they go. They’re reliable, trustworthy and you can tell they aren’t just in it for the money. Humberto is really compassionate."
start
done
tile
marble
Bathroom floor ....before

+9

Response time1 day
Response rate100%
1 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Mad City Windows & Baths
Mad City Windows & Baths
4.4(
838
)
Bathroom - RemodelBathtub Install or ReplaceBathtub Liner or Shower Surround - Install or Replace

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2001

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"We replaced our bathtub with a walk in shower, and are extremely happy with the work that was provided. In only took one person 6 hours to complete the job, and he was very professional and the quality of work was great. Would hire them again."
windows
siding
siding
siding
windows

+20

Response time10 mins
7821 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by89%of homeowners
Avatar for Henry's Handyman Service
Henry's Handyman Service
4.9(
40
)
Bathroom - Remodel

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2020

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"He remodeled two bathrooms and did an excellent job! He was very professional, paid attention to detail, and left the work area clean. I’m extremely happy with his work and would highly recommend him to anyone looking for a reliable and professional handyman."
10 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by58%of homeowners
Avatar for D Rohde Home Services
D Rohde Home Services
4.6(
473
)
Bathroom - RemodelBathtub Install or ReplaceBathtub Install or Replace - For Business

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2010

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Kevin and Mike arrived right on time. It was obvious that Kevin was new to the company as Mike was giving him a lot of direction. I am okay with that, everyone has to learn. Both were very professional. While there, Mike also looked at an issue I had with a dripping shower faucet. My wife did not want to cut open the sheetrock in her closet so Mike suggested that we replace the tub with a new fiberglass shower that way they could replace the valve in the wall and replace the valve in the wall and also add a new faucet. I am waiting on a price."
Mitsubishi Hyper heat (Low Temp) Multi Head Heat Pump
Additional Photos
Mitsubishi Mini Split
Mitsubishi Mini Split
Additional Photos

+22

Response time11 hrs
Response rate100%
41 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Lilco Construction Inc
Lilco Construction Inc
5.0(
10
)
Bathroom - Remodel - For Business

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2001

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"Lilco was a great company to work with! They are easy to communicate with and answered all of my questions and concerns. They are reliable and trustworthy. My kitchen and bathroom came out better than I could have imagined. I couldn’t be happier and hope to be able to remodel my other bathroom in the near future."
1 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by50%of homeowners
Avatar for M.L. Plumbing
M.L. Plumbing
5.0(
4
)
Bathtub Install or ReplaceBathtub Install or Replace - For Business

Serving Pine Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

I’ve been working in plumbing and Drain Cleaning for over 7 years, currently serving the greater Hudson Valley Area of NY, Northern NJ and Pike County PA. I take real pride in doing things the right way, not the easy way. Whether it’s a simple fix or a full system overhaul, I treat every job like it’s my own home. My goal is straightforward, show up on time, do clean work, and leave you with zero headaches.

...
Showing 1-10 of 502
Bathtub Replacement FAQs, answered by experts

Installing a clawfoot tub with a minimum of 6 inches of clearance from surrounding walls allows ample room for the faucet and pipework, makes cleaning easier, and reduces the chance of moisture being trapped between the tub and the walls. It might need to be closer if the faucet comes directly out of the wall.

The cost of installing a new bathtub is considerably more expensive than refinishing an existing one, so if you’re looking to upgrade your tub on a budget, you might be better off refinishing it for now. Additionally, if your tub has only minor damage, refinishing it will make it look new again without the extra demolition and time. 

What you include in your bathroom remodel will depend on your budget, personal preferences, and the current condition of your bathroom. Bathroom renovations often involve changing out the shower or tub, faucet, showerhead, tiles, flooring, mirrors, sink, cabinets, and vanities. You may also want to upgrade the wallcovering, adding new wallpaper or paint.

Yes. Common materials for Roman tubs are acrylic, fiberglass, cast iron, and stone resin. The choice you make can depend on various factors, including weight, cost, durability, style, heat retention, and aesthetics. Ultimately, it really depends on your space to determine the best option.

Different bathtub materials have various advantages and disadvantages. Cast iron and copper are considered the most durable materials because they are dense and resistant to damage from scratches or dents. However, cast-iron tubs are heavy, expensive, and may not be suitable for upper floors. Copper offers unique benefits but requires regular chemical treatment to prevent a patina from forming, making cast iron a less maintenance-intensive option. Porcelain is a good second choice for durability. For those on a budget, acrylic is a popular option, though it is less durable.

The Pine Island, NY homeowners’ guide to bathtub replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.