Marble vs. Porcelain Tile: Which Is Better for Your Home?

You cannot get more classic than marble or porcelain tile. There is a reason why these highly durable materials have remained popular since ancient times, from the early porcelain of the Chinese Tang Dynasty to the marble in the Greek Parthenon. 

These materials may carry some of the same benefits, but do not be fooled. They are very different once you (figuratively) crack the surface. From luxe bathroom flooring to decorative kitchen countertops, this guide will help you compare marble vs. porcelain tile.

Marble vs. Porcelain Tile: Key Differences

Though both types of tile are made from natural materials (porcelain comes from clay, while marble is a natural stone), there are a few key differences. Porcelain is more affordable, more versatile, lower maintenance, and generally more durable. Marble has a higher resistance to cracks, is easier to install, and adds more value to your home. Plus, you cannot beat the classic veining, though you can imitate it. 

What Is Marble?

Marble is a metamorphic rock that forms naturally when limestone is exposed to high heat and pressure. This process makes the softer limestone much harder and less porous—exactly the qualities you would want in kitchen or bathroom tile. The coveted veining, the hallmark of the stone, is typically the result of impurities like iron oxide, sand, silt, and clay.

Marble comes in all kinds of different varieties. The classic is white marble with subtle gray veining, but you can find a range of shades from beiges and grays to pinks and blues to black.

Best for:

• Statement features like fireplaces or luxury countertops

• Homeowners who want a natural stone rather than an imitation

• Those who like the elegant and classic look of marble

Pros of Marble Tile

The biggest draw of marble is the high-end look. It is classic but oozes luxury, especially marble tile bathrooms and kitchen countertops. Each stone is truly a unique work of art right from the brush of Mother Nature.

On top of that, marble tiles are highly durable. They can last 20 to 50 years with proper maintenance, and if a tile does crack or chip, you can easily swap it out. It is also one of the best materials when it comes to heat resistance. It can usually withstand a hot pot or pan, though you should always use a trivet because repeated exposure can damage the marble over time.

Cons of Marble Tile

Being a natural stone, marble is porous. This inherently makes it higher maintenance than other types of countertops. It can easily stain if you spill a liquid. It is particularly vulnerable to etching from acidic solutions, so avoid harsh acidic cleaners. Even slightly acidic tap water can cause water spots. To mitigate this issue, you will need to seal marble tile regularly.

Though marble tile is extremely durable, it can crack or chip under impact. The price is also prohibitive. While marble tile is more affordable than a slab, it is still a high-end product that comes with a high-end price tag. On top of that, you may need to reinforce your flooring or cabinets to support the heavy weight of the stone, which adds to installation costs.

What Is Porcelain?

Porcelain falls under the category of ceramics. It is made primarily from refined clay mixed with other natural materials like feldspar and quartz. These materials are fired in a kiln at high temperatures, sometimes even exceeding 2,500 degrees Fahrenheit. The result is an extremely hard, nonporous, and heat resistant product, which is why it is used everywhere from bathroom sinks to kitchen bowls. It is far more durable than its cousin, ceramic tile.

Best for:

• High-traffic areas or high-use countertops

• Outdoor patios, pool decks, and other areas exposed to water

• Homeowners who prefer low maintenance surfaces

Pros of Porcelain Tile

Porcelain tile shines with sheer durability and versatility. This material is scratch resistant and stronger than natural stone. Thanks to the firing process, it is so heat resistant that it can handle hot pots and pans. It is also nonporous. You can easily wipe up spills without the fear of staining, though you will need to seal the grout. 

Cons of Porcelain Tile

Though porcelain is very durable, it can crack or chip if you drop a heavy object. The hardness and weight makes it difficult to install, so if you choose this material, it is best to hire a tile contractor near you. You should also avoid using harsh acid-based cleansers that contain ammonia or bleach, since they can discolor the surface (unless, of course, your porcelain is already white).

Marble vs. Porcelain Tile

There are a few things to keep in mind when choosing marble or porcelain tile for bathrooms, kitchens, and other areas of the home. These are both excellent materials that have different strengths. Your choice should depend on your taste, lifestyle, and budget.

Appearance: Tie

When it comes to appearance, it depends on what you like. Most people think marble has a higher-end look. The veining is particularly desirable, but porcelain tile can come with gorgeous decorative patterns that you cannot get with marble. There are even ultra-glossy options reminiscent of glass tiles. Your overall choice should depend on your preferred design style. 

Options and Customizations: Porcelain

Both marble and porcelain tile come in a variety of colors and finishes. Since marble is a natural material, options are limited to whatever is dug up in a quarry. Color and veining does vary, but it cannot compare to the sheer variety of porcelain.

Porcelain comes in just about any color under the sun, including various decorative patterns, glass-like mosaic tiles, and quirky penny tiles. Porcelain can even mimic wood, concrete, marble, and other natural stones; it all depends on the glaze.

Durability​​: Porcelain

Both porcelain and marble are highly durable, but marble is slightly more prone to scratches, staining, and marks because of the porosity. Porcelain also has higher heat resistance, thanks to the firing process in which it is created. It can hold up to hot pots and pans without damage. 

The only flaw in durability is when it comes to cracks and chips. The same hardness that gives porcelain its strength also makes it brittle. It is more likely to crack if you drop a heavy object. For long-term durability, it is important to purchase a tile with the proper PEI rating. Any rating above three should hold up as flooring that receives regular foot traffic. If you are looking to install porcelain bathroom tile, keep lower grades on shower walls.

Price​: Porcelain

Price is perhaps the biggest difference between porcelain and marble tile. Porcelain is usually more affordable, but it depends on the quality of either material. Typically, porcelain tile costs $5 to $50 per square foot, including materials and labor. Marble tile, on average, costs $8 to $30 per square foot, but high-end or rare varieties can cost up to $350 per square foot.

Ease of Installation/DIYability​: Marble

Tile is generally easier to install than a porcelain or marble slab. That said, porcelain tile is typically a little more difficult to DIY than marble tile because it is harder and more difficult to cut. You will also need a professional installer to evaluate whether or not your home can support the added weight of porcelain or marble and to reinforce areas if necessary. 

The exception is peel-and-stick porcelain tile. This renter-friendly option is generally considered lower quality, but it is a simple (and temporary) DIY for homeowners looking for a change on a budget.

Maintenance​: Porcelain

Because marble is porous, it requires more maintenance than porcelain. You will need to seal the surface regularly. You will also need to clean up spills promptly, especially of acid-based or highly pigmented liquids, to avoid staining. That said, you may have to seal your grout regardless of the type of tile for similar reasons.

Either surface requires regular cleaning and repairs, but typically, repairs are as simple as swapping out a damaged tile.

Length of Life​: Porcelain

Porcelain tile generally lasts longer than marble tile, but either of these materials can last for decades with the proper care. On average, you can expect marble tile to last for at least 25 years (though 50 years is not unheard of with careful maintenance). Porcelain tile will typically last around 50 or 60 years.

Eco-Friendliness/Sustainability​: Tie

Both marble and porcelain are made from natural materials and generally considered eco-friendly compared to surfaces that contain petroleum-based products, such as laminate, which can off-gas volatile organic compounds (VOCs), and engineered stone, which was recently banned in Australia. 

That said, neither are perfect. Porcelain is made through a very energy-intensive process, which does emit carbon dioxide. Marble is mined from quarries, which is energy intensive and can contribute to issues like deforestation and pollution. Both materials are recyclable.

ROI and/or Resale Value​: Marble

One of the more important things to note about porcelain vs. marble is the resale value. Marble is typically considered a luxury product and may be more attractive to potential buyers (at least if it is in good condition). Porcelain is a sturdy and reliable option, but generally will not increase value.