Do You Need Solar Tube Repair or Replacement? Expert Advice to Help You Decide

Solar tubes can suffer damage over time or due to improper installation, natural wear and tear, bad weather, and more. They may even begin to leak, allowing water, dirt, dust, or too much heat into your home. Not sure if you need solar tube repair or a full-on replacement? We’ve got you covered.

Things to Check Before Deciding on a Repair vs. Replacement

If you can’t get enough natural light, or there are rooms in your house that cannot support standard windows, a solar tube (also called a sun tunnel) can be a godsend. Solar tubes, as opposed to standard skylights, use highly reflective metallic tubes to channel sunlight throughout the house from a translucent bulb on the roof. When you’re debating whether to call in a skylight pro to replace your entire unit or just repair it, there are a few key elements to consider.  

Review Your Warranty

When you pay for a new skylight, the cost often includes a warranty, some of which last up to 25 years. The cost to install a solar tube runs from $600 to $1,000, so you’ll want to check your warranty to confirm you’re not still covered. This is essential not only because fixing it through an initial warranty will save you money but also because any unauthorized repair work could void your coverage. 

Check Your Insurance Coverage

If natural causes, like a falling branch, damage your skylight or sun tube, your insurance might pick up the tab for repairs. Check your coverage and make sure you understand your homeowners insurance. 

Consider Its Age

Both skylights and solar tubes have an average life span of 10 to 20 years, though higher-end models are said to last as long as 55. Whatever the nature of your problem, it might be wise to opt for a replacement if your feature is getting toward the upper end of this range—or if you plan to replace your roof in the near future.

Common Skylight and Solar Tube Problems

Photo: P A Thompson / The Image Bank / Getty Images

The nature of your problems largely determines whether or not it makes more sense to repair or replace your skylight or solar tube. 

Leakage

Far and away, leakage is the most common issue with skylights and sun tubes. Over time, the features’ various weatherproofing systems will inevitably begin to fail, allowing moisture and dust into your home. 

You should thoroughly inspect the skylight the second you begin to notice water droplets in the house. Catching the problem early on could be the difference between a relatively quick and inexpensive repair and a costly replacement. The leak could be due to an issue with one of a few different components.

• If water seems to come in from the roof, the issue may lie with the flashing. This is the metal that connects the skylight frame to the roof and weatherproofs the gap. You can hire a roofing contractor to provide a short-term repair by reattaching the loose flashing with roof flashing cement. You will ultimately need new flashing, but you can replace the part on its own at a much lower cost than a new installation.

• When water appears to come in through the interior frame, the most probable cause is the gasket seal between the glass pane and the frame. You can repair the skylight by getting a new seal applied.

• The edges of skylight glass are dotted with a series of weep holes, which allow condensation on the glass to evaporate. Over time, these can become blocked with debris, leaving the condensation to drip into your home. When this happens, there is no choice but to replace the skylight.

• When a leak persists for long enough, the frame can corrode. If you catch the issue early enough, you can patch and repair the frame. If, however, the leak has penetrated the drywall, you may have to replace the whole feature.

Cracked Glass

Another source of leakage could be a crack in the glass. Even if they aren’t creating leaks, cracks, and other damage to the glass in your skylight can be unsightly and interfere with the light you’re trying to let into your home. 

In many cases—especially if the skylight is relatively new or the glass is single-pane—you can repair the problem by replacing just the glass, rather than the whole unit, and save time and money. If, however, the glass is double- or triple-pane, or the feature is designed in such a way that disallows the installation of new glass, you may have to replace it. 

Discoloration or Fogging

Over time, the glass in your skylight might begin to appear cloudy or acquire a yellowish hue, diminishing the quality of light entering your home. If the skylight is near the kitchen, you should try cleaning it first, since the discoloration may be due to an accumulation of cooking grease. If this fails, you may be able to simply install new glass. But depending on the specifics of your feature, you may have to call in a skylight company near you to replace the whole thing.

Broken Shade or Blind System

Skylights typically include a set of shades or blinds controlled by either a motor or a hand crank. If either mechanism has failed you, the part can be replaced at a fraction of the cost of a new skylight. Costs could be as high as $1,000 if there are more extensive electrical issues behind your motor troubles—but unless you plan to replace it for other reasons in the near future, there is no cost or lifetime utility advantage to paying for a replacement at this stage.