Top-rated exterior painters.

Get matched with top exterior painters in Fishers Island, NY

There are 29 highly-rated local exterior painters.

Need a pro for your exterior painting project in Fishers Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY FISHERS ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.7
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon142
    Verified exterior painting services reviews

Verified Reviews for Exterior Painting pros in Fishers Island, NY

*The Angi rating for Exterior Painting companies in Fishers Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Exterior Painting needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Exterior Painting companies in Fishers Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Exterior Painting needs.

Last update on October 04, 2025

Find Exterior painters in Fishers Island

Avatar for B & B Painting by the Pro's Inc

B & B Painting by the Pro's Inc

287 Lombardy Blvd
4.21(
204
)
•Approved Pro

B & B Painting by the Pro's Inc

287 Lombardy Blvd
4.21(
204
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
41 local quotes requested
43 years of experience

B & B Painting by the Pro's Incorporated in Bay Shore, New York, is a painting contractor that has been providing outstanding services for more than 37 years. We employ workers that are clean, neat, and courteous and provide affordable and quality services. We have acquired many references thanks to our more than 37 years in the industry. Rest assured that we value your business, as clients deal directly with the boss.

"Four-person crew was excellent. All were very reliable, responsible and skilled technicians. They were quite responsive to my queries and requests. They also took considerable time cleaning rooms and restoring furniture to original placement. I would not hesitate to have them back in my home for additional work and will readily recommend to others. Supervisor provided good oversight of the job. He also responded to requests on a timely basis."

Carole N on April 2022

B & B Painting by the Pro's Incorporated in Bay Shore, New York, is a painting contractor that has been providing outstanding services for more than 37 years. We employ workers that are clean, neat, and courteous and provide affordable and quality services. We have acquired many references thanks to our more than 37 years in the industry. Rest assured that we value your business, as clients deal directly with the boss.

"Four-person crew was excellent. All were very reliable, responsible and skilled technicians. They were quite responsive to my queries and requests. They also took considerable time cleaning rooms and restoring furniture to original placement. I would not hesitate to have them back in my home for additional work and will readily recommend to others. Supervisor provided good oversight of the job. He also responded to requests on a timely basis."

Carole N on April 2022

Avatar for MEGA PAINTING & DECORATING INC

MEGA PAINTING & DECORATING INC

183 Edwards Ave
4.86(
14
)
•Approved Pro

MEGA PAINTING & DECORATING INC

183 Edwards Ave
4.86(
14
)
•Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
45 local quotes requested

Mega Painting & Decorating, Inc. is your premier choice for all your painting needs. Specializing in residential painting services, we bring years of industry experience to every project, whether large or small. Our commitment to customer satisfaction ensures that we get the job done right the first time, every time. We look forward to the opportunity to work with you. Contact us today to discuss your next project!

"Phil is a seasoned professional. Would absolutely hire again. He was in and out in a few hours and the work was top-notch. I could not say enough good things about his work. I absolutely plan on using Mega again."

Joanna A on September 2025

Mega Painting & Decorating, Inc. is your premier choice for all your painting needs. Specializing in residential painting services, we bring years of industry experience to every project, whether large or small. Our commitment to customer satisfaction ensures that we get the job done right the first time, every time. We look forward to the opportunity to work with you. Contact us today to discuss your next project!

"Phil is a seasoned professional. Would absolutely hire again. He was in and out in a few hours and the work was top-notch. I could not say enough good things about his work. I absolutely plan on using Mega again."

Joanna A on September 2025

Avatar for UNIVERSE PAINTING LLC

UNIVERSE PAINTING LLC

1099 WEST MAIN STREET UNIT B
5.00(
11
)
•Approved Pro

UNIVERSE PAINTING LLC

1099 WEST MAIN STREET UNIT B
5.00(
11
)
•Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
78 local quotes requested

WE DO ALL KIND OF PAINTING JOB, WE DO STAIN, CABINETS, WALLS, TRIM, HIG GLOSS CEILING AND ANY IDEA YOU WANT TO BRING TO LIFE. WHY CHOOSE US, WELL. WE HAVE BEEN WORKING FOR MORE THAN 10 YEARS DOING HIGH QUALITY WORK ALL OVER LONG ISLAND, AND WE WILL CONTINUE TO DO SO FOR EVEN LONGER. UNTIL OUR WONDERFUL CUSTOMERS ARE SATISFIED.

"Perfectly! Juan and his painters were extremely professional and neat. They did a beautiful job painting the exterior of our home. I highly recommend them!"

Vicki R on September 2025

WE DO ALL KIND OF PAINTING JOB, WE DO STAIN, CABINETS, WALLS, TRIM, HIG GLOSS CEILING AND ANY IDEA YOU WANT TO BRING TO LIFE. WHY CHOOSE US, WELL. WE HAVE BEEN WORKING FOR MORE THAN 10 YEARS DOING HIGH QUALITY WORK ALL OVER LONG ISLAND, AND WE WILL CONTINUE TO DO SO FOR EVEN LONGER. UNTIL OUR WONDERFUL CUSTOMERS ARE SATISFIED.

"Perfectly! Juan and his painters were extremely professional and neat. They did a beautiful job painting the exterior of our home. I highly recommend them!"

Vicki R on September 2025

Avatar for Wallmasters Painting, Inc.

Wallmasters Painting, Inc.

992 Locust Ave
4.88(
111
)
•Approved Pro

Wallmasters Painting, Inc.

992 Locust Ave
4.88(
111
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 95% of Angi customers
Recommended by 95% of HomeAdvisor customers
38 local quotes requested

A craftsman you can depend on - this is what I've built a fine and lasting reputation on. The promise of giving you, my valued customer, a finished product that will last many years beyond that of the status quo paint, stain or wallpaper job. Interior painting and staining, wallpapering and trim installation... every job is done well and done right the first time, all in the name of saving you the anxiety and cost of having to repay to redo poorly done work. Wallmasters Painting, Inc. is fully licensed and insured and serves residential customers in Suffolk County. Call today to schedule your appointment - (631) 300-5605

"I am moving and needed a paint refresh before selling my home. Tom called me personally to speak with me about my needs and was at my house 2 days later for an estimate. He was exceptionally priced and worked with me for what I needed. He truly provided the service that he felt truly was needed for the home and not just to make extra money. Very professional and overall a nice person. Paint came out beautiful. Highly recommend."

Christina F on January 2025

A craftsman you can depend on - this is what I've built a fine and lasting reputation on. The promise of giving you, my valued customer, a finished product that will last many years beyond that of the status quo paint, stain or wallpaper job. Interior painting and staining, wallpapering and trim installation... every job is done well and done right the first time, all in the name of saving you the anxiety and cost of having to repay to redo poorly done work. Wallmasters Painting, Inc. is fully licensed and insured and serves residential customers in Suffolk County. Call today to schedule your appointment - (631) 300-5605

"I am moving and needed a paint refresh before selling my home. Tom called me personally to speak with me about my needs and was at my house 2 days later for an estimate. He was exceptionally priced and worked with me for what I needed. He truly provided the service that he felt truly was needed for the home and not just to make extra money. Very professional and overall a nice person. Paint came out beautiful. Highly recommend."

Christina F on January 2025

Avatar for Just Right Carpentry & Painting

Just Right Carpentry & Painting

10 Byron Pl
4.74(
189
)
•Approved Pro

Just Right Carpentry & Painting

10 Byron Pl
4.74(
189
)
•Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 92% of Angi customers
Recommended by 92% of HomeAdvisor customers
301 local quotes requested

Just Right Carpentry, Painting Inc., has served Suffolk County for decades with pride and integrity. Family owned and specializing in a range of carpentry and painting; we have the knowledge and expertise to recommend the work to truly fit your homes needs. Please call us for a free estimate. We do not use sub contractors. Charge by the job. No travel/trip charges apply.

"Great communication and the work was well done. I had a small project and he was able to fit me in his schedule the best he could and was very pleasant to work with. I will keep him in mind for future projects. Thank you!"

Marie R on August 2025

Just Right Carpentry, Painting Inc., has served Suffolk County for decades with pride and integrity. Family owned and specializing in a range of carpentry and painting; we have the knowledge and expertise to recommend the work to truly fit your homes needs. Please call us for a free estimate. We do not use sub contractors. Charge by the job. No travel/trip charges apply.

"Great communication and the work was well done. I had a small project and he was able to fit me in his schedule the best he could and was very pleasant to work with. I will keep him in mind for future projects. Thank you!"

Marie R on August 2025

LP Painting

5.00(
1
)

LP Painting

5.00(
1
)
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Family owned business with over 20 years of experience handling Painting - Interior - Exterior - Stucco - residential cleaning- deep cleans- housecleaning - VRBO - air bnb -

"Wow!! Luis is A+ in every way! Honest, quick and talented. This is the type of company you keep in your phone for the rest of your life! You'd be nuts not to hire them!!!"

Ingrid M on October 2024

Family owned business with over 20 years of experience handling Painting - Interior - Exterior - Stucco - residential cleaning- deep cleans- housecleaning - VRBO - air bnb -

"Wow!! Luis is A+ in every way! Honest, quick and talented. This is the type of company you keep in your phone for the rest of your life! You'd be nuts not to hire them!!!"

Ingrid M on October 2024

J&R PAUTE CARPENTRY LLC

171 Bellport Avenue
4.50(
6
)

J&R PAUTE CARPENTRY LLC

171 Bellport Avenue
4.50(
6
)
Customers say: Super punctual
138 local quotes requested

Construcción works, interior exterior, remodeling,decks, woodenfloors Remodeling basements general works. Our mission is to be a provider that brings back the personal touch with our customers. We will build a relationship that will last a lifetime after you see our quality work. As a locally owned and operated business, we feel invested in our clients and constantly strive for customer satisfaction. Call or message us to schedule an estimate today!

"Hector and his crew were highly recommended by a friend of ours. We are so happy with the quality of the work and the professionalism. They were prompt and left our home clean. We highly recommend Hector's company and plan to use him for another job."

John K on August 2025

Construcción works, interior exterior, remodeling,decks, woodenfloors Remodeling basements general works. Our mission is to be a provider that brings back the personal touch with our customers. We will build a relationship that will last a lifetime after you see our quality work. As a locally owned and operated business, we feel invested in our clients and constantly strive for customer satisfaction. Call or message us to schedule an estimate today!

"Hector and his crew were highly recommended by a friend of ours. We are so happy with the quality of the work and the professionalism. They were prompt and left our home clean. We highly recommend Hector's company and plan to use him for another job."

John K on August 2025

...
Showing 1-10 of 204
Exterior Painting questions, answered by experts

Yes. A gallon of paint covers around 400 square feet, so two gallons will be enough for one coat in a 400-square-foot room or two coats in an 800-square-foot room. However, if you have a very large room or you’re painting an open space or an entire floor of your home, you may need more than two gallons.

In most cases, paint primer is necessary before painting over wood paneling. A hardy primer formula covers up stains and leaves a grippy surface for the new paint to hold onto. If you don’t use a primer first, you risk poor adhesion, visible blemishes, and a paint top coat that could flake away later. 

There are two primer choices: oil-based or latex-based. Choose an oil-based primer for durability and adhesion, but prepare for extra dry time and more VOC (volatile organic compounds) fumes. Or, pick a stain-blocking latex primer. They’re easy to apply, clean up, and affordable.

While often used interchangeably, flat and matte paints are not the same. Flat paint has no gloss and is completely shine-free, while matte has up to 10% resin, giving it a slightly velvety appearance. That small amount of gloss in matte paint gives it a more elegant, modern appearance than flat paint, though flat paint is ideal for hiding imperfections in even the most dented, scratched, and repeatedly repaired surfaces.

A single coat of primer is almost always sufficient. This is especially true if you’re painting over a smooth surface with minimal to no flaws.

While it is possible for painter’s tape to leave some residue, it is designed specifically not to. If it does leave residue behind, it likely means that the painter’s tape was left on too long after the paint dried.

By submitting this question, I acknowledge and agree that Angi may publicly display my name, city, state, and question on the website for professionals and others to see.

The Fishers Island, NY homeowners’ guide to exterior painting services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles