They did alright, but they had to come back out. Their communication was not that great. I had to call them to see if they were still coming. Then I had to call them back because the guy they sent to do the work --  I thought there were some areas that he did not do. So they came back out. Then I looked and they still did not fix what I told them. They were not professional. Their prices were decent.

I started discussions with Crestmark in mid-April 2013, receiving an actual quote and invoice in mid-May. They performed the roof repair and it was completed by the end of June, with the work crew doing superior work. With the roof complete, there was approximately $8,000 worth of repairs remaining to be completed. When I had not heard from Crestmark by the second week in July, I attempted to contact them by email and phone but to no avail. I finally made contact by phone shortly into September (four months into our repairs!) and expressed such frustration with the owner that a representative emailed me that afternoon, promising to come by and estimate the materials needed for completion. A week later they came out and partially finished the chimney framing but left it unpainted and none of the facia or soffet work done. On September 19, I received an email from the same representative promising to "get a list of what needs to be finished tomorrow and we will get it done". I have not heard from Crestmark since (today is November 9, 2013) nor has any work been performed. While Crestmark Roofing promised much and their price was fair, the lack of communication and follow-up has negated what should have been a relatively easy success. 

UPDATE

 =======

On November 9, 2013, I provided Crestmark with advance notice of my Angie's List review to allow them an opportunity to responds and/or attempt to remediate our concerns. On November 21, 2013, I received an email stating they were ordering the remaining materials and would have the job completed within 2-3 weeks. However, I heard nothing else from my job representative into mid-January. On January 22, 2014, I contacted the Angie's List POC for Crestmark Roofing, Gary Yates. In contrast to my experiences with the prior representative, Mr. Yates was professional, responsive, and extremely disturbed over how the job had been handled. To his credit, he did not fain concern in an effort to win back business; instead, it appears he made a diligent effort to objectively investigate the status of our job and what led to our displeasure. Mr. Yates kept me informed throughout the 23rd, checking for additional information and clarifying points of confusion. On January 24, Mr. Yates and I met in person, where he apologized for the problems with this job and updated me on the results of his investigation. He assured me that this was an isolated incident involving one of his representatives and took full responsibility for the lack of communications and response. He cleared up several misconceptions concerning the repairs and in my view rescued the reputation of this company. Had I thought to contact Mr. Yates earlier, many if not all of these problems may have been averted.