Raising the roof on a Cape Cod house adds valuable living space. Learn how much it costs to raise the roof on a Cape Cod house and what affects the price.
6 Best Roofing Materials for Cape Cod Homes That Maintain the Charm
Charming roofing materials can be durable, too
Get quotes from roofers near you
No obligation · 100% free
Get quotes from roofers near you
No obligation · 100% free
Need Help With a Project? Connect With a Pro
Asphalt shingles work well for Cape Cod roofs because they resist cold climates, last at least 20 years, and come in neutral colors that highlight your home's charm.
Cedar shake roofing materials offer rustic appeal and energy efficiency for your Cape Cod home, with a life span of 30 years or more when you maintain them properly.
Slate tile roofing delivers timeless beauty and exceptional durability for your Cape Cod home, lasting 100 years or more with minimal maintenance once you install it.
Hiring a local roofing professional helps you choose materials that match your Cape Cod home's design and ensures proper installation for lasting durability.
Get quotes from up to 3 pros!
Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.
Charming is a common description for the Cape Cod home design. The good news is that you don’t have to sacrifice durability in your Cape home’s roof to maintain its personality. Some of the best roofing materials for Cape Cod homes include asphalt, cedar shake, slate tile, metal, rubber, and composite materials. Let’s explore each roofing material to see how they stack up against each other.
| Material Types | Best Feature |
|---|---|
| Asphalt shingles | Cost-effective |
| Cedar shake | Rustic look |
| Slate tile | Timeless beauty |
| Metal | Modern design |
| Rubber | Extremely durable |
| Composite | Mimics any design |
1. Asphalt Shingles
Photo: ma-k / E+ / Getty Images
Asphalt shingles are among the best roofing materials for cold climates, making them ideal for the Cape Cod home design that’s associated with New England. You do have to be on the lookout for ice dams in wintertime, though.
Asphalt shingles will last at least 20 years, which is a good performance level but still lags behind other options. You can select from a wide range of neutral color shades, allowing the design of your Cape Cod home to stand out.
Angi Tip
The many factors that play into choosing a roofing material may surprise you, such as durability, cost, style, and the climate in which you live. Many homeowners choose asphalt, but there are various types on the market. A roofer can advise you on the best materials for your home and region.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Low price point | Prone to ice dams |
| Neutral colors | Can pop off in wind |
| Easy to install | Less durability |
Best for: Those who want a traditional roofing material
2. Cedar Shake
Photo: cbglp2 / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images
Rustic cedar shake or wood shake roof materials nicely complement a Cape Cod home design. They most often are made of cedar wood, but you can also use pine or redwood. They’re energy-efficient, which is helpful during cold winter days. They have an expected life span of 30 years or more, but you do need to perform regular maintenance. Considering the cost of the materials, installation, and ongoing care, the cedar shake roof cost is above average.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| High wind resistance | Pricer than average |
| Insulative material | Requires maintenance |
| Good longevity | Could suffer rot |
Best for: Those who want a rustic design
3. Slate Tile
Photo: jamesforddesign / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images
The slate roof cost can be quite high, as installation is challenging. However, the look of slate is difficult to duplicate among the other best roofing materials for Cape Cod homes. Slate’s longevity can be 100 years or more. Its timeless appeal matches its longevity, making it a perfect pairing with the beauty and charm of the Cape Cod design. You may need to reinforce the roof structure because of the added weight of the slate, which can drive up the cost. If you live in an area with significant hail, you could see damage, but slate doesn’t often come loose in strong wind.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Exceptional beauty | Pricey installation |
| Lasts 100-plus years | Needs reinforcement |
| Low maintenance | Possible hail damage |
Best for: Those who want a “forever” roof that looks amazing
4. Metal
Photo: Sonia De Leon / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images
If you want to add a bit of modernity to the classic Cape Cod design, consider adding a metal roof. You can select among materials like aluminum, copper, and steel, and you can pick almost any color you want. Metal reflects sunlight in the summer, keeping your home cooler. The metal roof cost is above average versus other options. However, it requires almost no maintenance, and it can last 40 years or more, providing a good value over time. Some people will prefer a more traditional type of roofing material with their Cape Cod homes, though.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Highly durable | Pricey to install |
| Modern design | Non-traditional look |
| Multiple colors | May show rust spots |
Best for: Those who want to add a modern look to a Cape Cod
5. Rubber
Rubber roofing is likely not your first choice when you’re seeking a roofing material for Cape Cod homes. It certainly isn’t going to enhance the classic charm of this type of home design. However, rubber roofs are extremely durable, easy to install, cost-effective, and environmentally friendly. Unfortunately, you don’t have a lot of design or color options when you choose rubber, so it’s difficult to match it to the look of your Cape Cod home. You could select a rubber roof that’s made to resemble cedar shake, but this simulated look tends to work better with composite materials.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Highly durable | Minimal styles |
| Easy to install | Unusual for Cape Cod homes |
| Eco-friendly option | Not a charming look |
Best for: Those who want maximum durability in a roof
6. Composite
Photo: DigiPub / Moment / Getty Images
When you want the look of wood shake, slate, or asphalt shingles, but you want a high level of durability, composite materials are the answer. Because they can resemble almost any roof design, you can use them to enhance the classic look of your Cape Cod home, or you can try to create a contrasting look. Composite roofing materials can last 50 years or more. However, the composite shingle roof cost is higher than any of the other options among the best roofing materials for Cape Cod homes.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Eco-friendly | Very expensive |
| Create any design | Still a new material |
| Long-lasting option | May fade in UV rays |
Best for: Those who want a charming look with maximum durability
How Do I Choose the Best Roofing Materials for Cape Cod Homes?
If you still aren’t sure which materials to use with the roof on your Cape Cod home, you may want to reach out to a local roofing company for their advice. The roofer can suggest some roofing materials and colors that will fit in with your home’s design and your budget. The roofer may even be able to show you computer-generated photos of your home with different roof materials on it, so that you can visualize all your options.
When choosing a roofer, make sure that the professional can handle whatever roofing material you want to use with your Cape Cod home. Any roofer can install asphalt shingles, but other materials may require seeking out a roofer with specific experience.
Roofing services reviews from real Angi homeowners in Columbus, OH
4.3★ avg. • 120 total reviews
- Chance R.
D1 Roofing delivers outstanding service from beginning to end, backed by a strong warranty and expert teams. I highly recommend them for their excellence in meeting and surpassing expectations with unmatched communication. Choosing D1 Roofing was flawless decision
Division 1 Roofing LLC - Jeremy P.
This place took $25,000 for a flat roof job with a five-year warranty and never returned to fix the leaks that were caused by their work. These people are not professionals and should not be doing this type of work. They incorrectly changed the pitch of the roof, and caused more damage than...
- David B.
The technician was very professional and friendly. He answered all my questions and was very thorough. He left the fireplace area very clean . He inspected from the roof and advised me as to other work that might need to be done. There was no pressure there. I was very satisfied with the...
Supreme brick & chimney - Kevin S.
I am really impressed with their timeliness and turnaround. Mitchell came out, and we decided to move forward with their pricing. Our roof was on within a week, and we could not be happier with their team! Amazing company, great prices and honest, dependable craftsmanship. I highly recommend...
Window Depot USA of Central Ohio - Rob B.
Manuel Calvillo is the best option in the area for roofing and you won't be disappointed.
- Julie K.
They damaged multiple items on my property, including a marble slab used as a table top, tried to hide it, and refused to pay or replace. Arrived day one without a ladder to access roof & delayed a day. Left a mess in back yard; didn't wear face masks; no show by owner to property to see damages
Grants Tree Service - Marcia L.
I've hired Gary/Cherokee Roofing for two different homes, work quality, responsiveness, and completion have been great both times. And the prices quoted were very competitive. I would definitely hire again.
- Paul F.
Lyle did a great job removing asbestos shingles from our front porch roof. They worked together with our roofer to make sure that the new roof was able to be installed on the same day that Lyle removed the asbestos shingles.
Lyle Environmental - Paul F.
Bradley Builders did a good job replacing the roof on our front porch. They color-matched the existing shingles on the rest of the house and installed a metal ridge roll since we live in a historical neighborhood. They did the job while we were out of town. When we got back, everything was...
Bradley Builders, Inc. - Madison B.
I would absolutely recommend this business. They offer a variety of services, including: painting, roofing, and refinishing wood flooring. I hired them to refinish the original hardwood flooring in my home built in 1874. The job was quite challenging, as the floors were extremely aged and...
The homeowners guide to roofing services
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
Choosing the right roofing material can help your home stand up to snow, ice, and harsh winds. Learn more about the best roofing materials for cold climates.
Blue, tan, black, or red—choosing the right roof color is a tricky game. Consider professional tips on how to match your house's aesthetic with the right complementary roof colors. We'll walk you through making the right choice for your vision.
Who doesn't love a budget-friendly roof? This budget guide will help you choose a roofing material that looks stylish and helps you stay in your price range.
The classic look of a Cape Cod-style house can transport you back to another era. Here's all you need to know about Cape Cod home style and where these houses stand today.
Need a new roof but aren’t keen on it looking like everyone else’s? These alternative roofing materials offer a unique curb appeal, sustainability, and more.