Act of God? Who Should Pay for Home Water Damage

Broken water main floods Virginia woman's basement

Get quotes from up to 3 pros!
Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.
Geo Icon

You may want to consider hazard insurance for homes in areas with aging infrastructures because without it you could be on the financial hook for damages.

That’s what Donna Brause of Vienna, Virginia, is learning the hard way.

She’s been battling the town since a recent broken water main caused her basement to flood, resulting in tens of thousands of dollars in damages.

“It’s not our fault,” Brause tells WJLA. “It wasn’t our pipes. It’s nothing that we had done wrong. There was nothing faulty in the way we maintained the home.”

The Town of Vienna is paying for the initial cleanup, but officials won’t cover the full restoration cost. 

Would you expect to pay for damages?

“Anytime that I hear that this happens, I feel bad about that,” Vienna Town Manager Mercury Payton tells WJLA.

He says water main breaks are considered an “act of God,” meaning the township is not legally responsible for the damage.

That may come as a shock to many residents.

“We have protocols that we go through that fall in line with the rest of the state of Virginia and we try to follow those as best we can,” Payton says.

Before something happens to your home, check with your insurance company and carefully read your home owner's policy.

Hazard insurance typically provides protection for a broad number of perils, such as explosions, electrical surges or damage done by vehicles, that may not be included in your main policy.

Start cleanup sooner rather than later

Who’s responsible for what happened is important to figure out, but when water damage is involved the first step is to stop the water flow as quickly as possible and begin cleanup.

Look for companies that specialize in water remediation services for the home and are experienced in removing mold, mildew and other microorganisms associated with water damage.

Unfortunately, basement flooding is not uncommon for those in the Mid-Atlantic region. Learn more about the causes and costs of basement flooding and if basement waterproofing is an option.

Whether an “act of God” or not, a flooded basement still leaves behind a big mess to clean up.

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.
The homeowners guide to basement waterproofing services
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
Pastel blue walls in a basement living room
May 22, 2025
May 22, 2025
Sump pumps are a must for homeowners who live in flood zones. Find out how much sump pump installation costs based on type, location, and features.
farmhouse bathroom with a wood cabinet
Nov 13, 2024
Nov 13, 2024
Sump pump battery backup costs depend on the type and the design of the system purchased. Follow this guide to learn how to budget for your backup battery.
Basement living room interior
May 16, 2025
May 16, 2025
Need to fix basement water problems or safeguard your home from damage in the future? Use this basement waterproofing cost guide to budget appropriately.
A bright wooden bathroom
Jun 5, 2025
Jun 5, 2025
Learn what home flood detection systems are, how they work, where to install them, and why they can help minimize water damage in your home with this guide.
An open-space living room in a house’s basement
Jun 6, 2025
Jun 6, 2025
A basement offers additional living or storage space, but if it leaks, it can become a significant headache. Learn how to fix a leaky basement and prevent water damage.
Children playing outside
Nov 11, 2024
Nov 11, 2024
You may be concerned if you find your sump pump running constantly after heavy rainfall. Read up on possible reasons why your sump pump won’t shut off.