Find top-rated Pros in your area

Enter a zip code and get matched to businesses near you.

Fair and Square Custom Remodeling

General Remodeling, Finished Carpentry and Woodworking, Kitchen and Bath Remodeling,

About us

Fair and Square is a remodeling company in located in Whitefish Bay, accredited with the Wisconsin Better Business Bureau. I have over 25 years experience and am able to manage and execute virtually all of your remodeling requests. From new windows, skylights and doors, residing and insulating your home, to full kitchen, bath and basement makeovers. Being the owner as well as the carpenter allows me to be fully involved in all aspects of your project from estimates to construction clean up and removing debris. Services the Greater Milwaukee area including Racine.

Business highlights

11 years of trusted experience

Services we offer

Full or partial Bathroom Remodeling. Basement Rec Rooms. Kitchen cabinets and tops. Window installation. Door installation. Cabinet installation. Skylight installation. Molding installation.

Services we don't offer

Carpeting. Vinyl flooring. Siding Work.

Amenities

Senior Discount

5%



Accepted payment methods

Check

Photos of past projects

Reviews

5.030 Reviews
Number of StarsImage of DistributionNumber of Ratings
5
100%
4
0%
3
0%
2
0%
1
0%


Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
4.8
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Showing 1-25 of 30 reviews

LISA D.
03/2019
5.0
custom cabinets, remodeling, woodworking
  + 1 more
We could not be happier with the work that Jason and the team at Fair & Square did at our home! As ours is an older house, built in the 1920's, the challenge was to add built in bookshelves and a mantel that would look like they were original to the house. To complicate things the previous owner had stained the hardwood floors with a custom stain. Fair and Square knocked it out of the park and would highly recommend for any custom work you may need.
Description of Work: Mantel & Built-ins

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

Urszula J.
02/2019
5.0
remodeling, woodworking, home remodeling
  + 1 more
If you are looking for quality work done in a timely fashion with attention to detail look no further. Fair and Square did a complete kitchen remodel for me. Jayson is an amazing carpenter and I could not be more satisfied with his work. It was my first major remodeling project and Jayson was extremely patient and professional, answering all my questions, providing me with a timeline for the job and making sure I was satisfied with all the aspects of the remodel. He completed the project in a timely way. He brought in excellent tradesmen who kept my house clean day to day during the process and went above and beyond. If you choose Fair and Square you can be certain that your project will be stress free. Jayson is an expert, does his work honestly, and you can feel confident with him working in your home.
Description of Work: Complete Kitchen Remodel

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

D G.
10/2017
5.0
drywall, remodeling, woodworking
  + 1 more
What a nice experience! Jason did a small project (drywall and woodwork) in my house, and I am completely satisfied! He is good with details; He was neat, clean, and professional. This is the kind of guy that you would want for a neighbor, and you can trust him to work for you around your house. I will ask him back to do other projects.
Description of Work: Carpentry, Drywall

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$1,000

Jennifer H.
09/2017
5.0
custom cabinets, contractors, drywall, remodeling, replacement windows, woodworking, home remodeling
  + 5 more
Jason is meticulous about the work he does and oversees. He went above and beyond to get my job done and to get it done right. I love my new renovations and can't wait to use him for my next project!
Description of Work: Jason redid my porch, including installing new windows, replacing rotted wood, installing new tile on the floor, and painting. He also did a remodel of my bathroom, including installing a new vanity, new tile floor, new medicine cabinet and cabinet over the toilet, and painting.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

Amy Y.
07/2017
5.0
remodeling
  + -1 more
He did a great job, made the patio looked brand new.
Description of Work: Front patio work

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

Patricia B.
06/2017
5.0
contractors, remodeling, woodworking
  + 1 more
Beautiful! On time and professional with attention to detail
Description of Work: Crown moulding

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

mike B.
05/2017
5.0
remodeling
  + -1 more
Could not have gone better. Show up each time right on time and humped it all day long. Fair and Square is the perfect name for this home improvement vendor. Jason is also a great guy and is a very skilled tradesmen. Could not be happier with the work provided.
Description of Work: Interior wall work in condo

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$1,800

Beth A.
01/2017
5.0
remodeling
  + -1 more
Excellent - timely, professional, and great attention to detail. The
Description of Work: Jason transformed an old office over our garage, which had a separate entrance from the garage, into a bonus room attached to the master bedroom with a new French door.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

Michael H.
12/2016
5.0
gutter cleaning, remodeling
  + 0 more
Jason arrived on time to provide the estimate which I felt was very fair. He arrived promptly on the scheduled date to do the work. He actually came in under his bid and even told us that if we had this work done again, we only needed to worry about the front of the house. I would definitely reach out to him again and will probably be using him in the near future for some interior carpentry work.
Description of Work: I needed my gutters cleaned and was having a hard time finding anyone to do the work. I live in an old Victorian home and the gutters are about 14' high. Other contractors would either not show up or would do a drive by and I'd never hear from them again.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$230

Michael M.
12/2016
5.0
doors
  + -1 more
The installation was GREAT. Jason is a personable craftsman. We appreciated his warm personality and effective work. I'd hiring him again for anything -- so long as my budget allows. And if you get what you pay for, you get good service from Jason's craftsmanship.
Description of Work: I had a storm door installed.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
4.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

Jim S.
12/2016
5.0
remodeling, doors
  + 0 more
Jason is very professional and honest. I have hired him several times and never been disappointed. He will do the work on time, do high quality work and is enjoyable to work with. His prices are fair especially for the quality of the experience provided.
Description of Work: Replace door and bathroom shower stall repair.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

Ned S.
12/2016
5.0
remodeling, replacement windows, doors
  + 1 more
Very well. Mr. Sieberg is very talented plus he has a good "eye" for what will look right in terms of material, color, texture, proportion and so forth. I might add that he has done many projects for us in the past which have all turned out well.
Description of Work: Window replacement on first floor of house.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
4.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

Donna D.
12/2016
5.0
custom cabinets, replacement windows, woodworking, home remodeling
  + 2 more
Have never had anyone better, particularly for custom work.
Description of Work: Multiple jobs, mostly involving carpentry/woodworking skillset.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

Laura H.
12/2016
5.0
remodeling, woodworking
  + 0 more
Jason was phenomenal from start to finish. We absolutely love our custom communications board (1/3 chalkboard, 1/3 paint, 1/3 magnet board). He was meticulous in the design and carpentry. We had a rough idea of what we wanted done but Jason added some suggestions we had not considered that made the project even better. He was so easy and fun to work with and he made sure the idea would work in our space, look fantastic, and meet my families needs. We get compliments on it anytime someone comes to our house! We have hired him back for smaller projects which he has completed in equally as professional and meticulous manner and we will not hesitate to have him back for future projects. You can not go wrong with hiring Fair and Square.
Description of Work: Custom communications board in our kitchen. Large kitchen wall spanning at least 10 plus feet. He created separate boards, framed in wood trim. Completed the paint, carpentry and overall execution of the project.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

Zoran L.
12/2016
5.0
remodeling
  + -1 more
Jason had set up a time to look at what I needed and wanted and told me what he could do and how much. I agreed to proceed and when he scheduled the actual build he showed up on time and completed the project the same day. The frame he built for our heavy kitchen exhaust fan along with 8" duct was very strong. He glued and nail secured all the joints. He installed the fan and hooked up the 8" exhaust pipe securely. No rattles or leakage. In my opinion he is a very good carpenter. There were a lot of angles to cut so that everything would come together and look like it belonged. He supplied 2x4's to build the frame and soffit .He also had other ideas and points that I found worthy of consideration. Jason is someone that will listen and then add his experience to your project. I will hire him for my kitchen cabinet install to finish out our project.
Description of Work: We needed a kitchen exhaust fan installed in our 1940's home. There was no existing fan so everything had to be built from scratch so to speak.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$850

Michael B.
12/2016
5.0
remodeling
  + -1 more
High quality work completed with attention to detail. Jason is a true professional who knows his craft. Jason communicated effectively, kept his materials well organized, cleaned up after each day's work, and did fantastic work. The kitchen remodel looks great and I know it was built to last.
Description of Work: Kitchen remodel

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

Response from Fair and Square Custom Remodeling
Hello again [Member Name Removed], thank you for your review. It was an absolute pleasure working for you.

Toni G.
12/2016
5.0
custom cabinets, remodeling, woodworking
  + 1 more
It went extremely well and I consider myself a very particular person.
Description of Work: A built in desk

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
4.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$3,000

Patricia B.
12/2016
5.0
remodeling, woodworking
  + 0 more
What a wonderful experience...beautiful work
Description of Work: Crown moulding

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

Joe D.
12/2016
5.0
gutter cleaning
  + -1 more
Did a great job, very punctual, nice rapport, cleaned up afterwards.
Description of Work: Gutter Cleaning

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$175

Response from Fair and Square Custom Remodeling
Thank yo so much for your kind words, [Member Name Removed]!

Noelle W.
10/2016
5.0
drywall, replacement windows, basement remodeling
  + 1 more
So so great. He is respectful, kind, thorough, and fun to chat with.
Description of Work: When we bought our house, we discovered the finished portion of the basement was not permitted. Upon inspection, we discovered that all of the work needed to be redone. Jason replaced all of the insulation, installed sill plates and drywall, and made our basement look like new again. His work is excellent and he is so easy to work with. We trust him so much that now we often ask ourselves, "What would Jason do?" when considering how to tackle other projects in the home. In fact, we even called him to advise us on what to do with our lintels. He was even able to repair our lintels the same day that we asked him about for advice. He's really great and we can't recommend him enough. We will be calling Jason again!

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

kathy B.
12/2015
5.0
custom cabinets, doors, remodeling, home remodeling, woodworking
  + 3 more
Jason at Fair and Square Custom Remodeling is incredibly reliable and responsive, and the quality of his work is tremendous. He often showed up earlier than expected, and always finished the job on time (or ahead of schedule). We will continue to use Jason for anything we need done around the house, and we would highly recommend him to anyone. A great family man that you can feel comfortable having in your home.
Description of Work: Replaced and painted baseboard and door frame woodwork throughout the house, installed new interior doors, and installed new kitchen back splash. Looking forward to his reno of our main bathroom soon! ...and his replacement of the siding on our house, and some new cabinets in the basement, and so on...

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$8,000

Linda S.
10/2015
5.0
remodeling, home remodeling
  + 0 more
We hired Angie's list member Fair and Square Custom Remoldling to install our new kitchen countertop. It was a small job but the firm's owner Mr. Jason Sieverg devoted his attention to it and did good work in a very timely manner. Likewise, all the subs showed up right on time and did excellent work. The result is a gleaming new kitchen in only about four days once the top was ready and the work started. We recommend Fair and Square highly.
Description of Work: Install limestone countertop, sink, tile wall and separate shelf

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
4.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$5,500

Shelleen G.
07/2015
5.0
remodeling
  + -1 more
Jason's work exceeded my expectations. He provided a consultation with complete measurements for the work and completed the installation on a timely schedule. Jason is a careful, conscientious, meticulous contractor who is attentive to details. He is professional and friendly and all work was completed according to estimates.
Description of Work: Complete kitchen renovation; installation of wood door frame and borders.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$4,000

Wendy V.
02/2015
5.0
drywall, remodeling, gutter cleaning, home remodeling, replacement windows, woodworking
  + 4 more
It was the most professional work I've seen. Jason was timely in his estimate, and in doing the work. He was always punctual and the work was done when he promised. His communication was excellent, he connected with me whenever he had a question or concern. His work ethic is excellent, he works hard and helped me immensely when I was preparing the house for sale. He understood my time frame and did everything he could to work with my timing. The new picture window replacement is just beautiful, he replaced the large window with one fixed and two windows that open for better ventilation and it is just beautiful. His taste and quality of work is superb. The work that Jason and his tile contractor did in the bath remodel was also just beautiful. He noticed that the window sill needed a piece of vinyl to keep water from leaking into it and took time to fix it. He pays close attention to detail it all aspects. He cleaned up the area every time he was working. It was always a pleasure working with Jason and I would recommend him completely.
Description of Work: Jason replaced a large picture window in the living room. The frame had rotted due to a roof leak. He removed the old window and inspected the window opening carefully to see what needed replacing. The structure was repaired, insulated, the new window replaced, new drywall installed, new wood trim installed and painted. He also was the general contractor for a bathroom remodel. He removed an old metal shower in the bathroom, had a new tile shower installed, new tile floor installed, replaced old light fixtures, and replaced the wood trim. He also repaired the window with new vinyl on the sill so it would not leak.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$15,000

Ellie B.
02/2015
5.0
remodeling
  + -1 more
He did a perfect job. He was here on time. He was professional, polite and articulate. He was well dressed and well-groomed. He made sure I understood everything he was going to do even though my knowledge of it was limited. If he came across any problems he brought me up to date. He was very accommodating if there was a weather issue or if I had something going on. His prices aren't cheap or terribly expensive-- they are exactly in line with what you expect to pay for work of this quality. All the corners matched-- everything was done superbly and he cleaned up after himself. In all three jobs he did for us, there was only one problem (he put some spindles in upside down). Unlike others, he brought it to my attention and told me he'd fix it if I wanted him to. And he fixed it!
Description of Work: He redid our second story porch. It was rotten and the whole thing had to rebuilt and leveled.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$2,885
    • 1(current)
    • 2

Contact information

936 E Meadow Pl, WHITEFISH BAY, WI 53217

fairandsquarecustomremodeling.com

Service hours

Sunday:
Closed
Monday:
8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday:
8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday:
8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday:
8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday:
8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday:
Closed

Licensing

Insured
State Contractor License Requirements

All statements concerning insurance, licenses, and bonds are informational only, and are self-reported. Since insurance, licenses and bonds can expire and can be cancelled, homeowners should always check such information for themselves. To find more licensing information for your state, visit our State Contractor License Requirements page.

*Contact business to see additional licenses.


Service Categories

General Remodeling,
Finished Carpentry and Woodworking,
Kitchen and Bath Remodeling,
Cabinet Making,
Windows,
Drywall,
Doors,
Gutter Cleaning,
Unfinished Carpentry,
Basement Remodeling,
Skylights,
Siding

FAQ

Fair and Square Custom Remodeling is currently rated 5 overall out of 5.

Sunday: Closed

Monday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Tuesday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Wednesday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Thursday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Friday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Saturday: Closed

Fair and Square Custom Remodeling accepts the following forms of payment: Check
No, Fair and Square Custom Remodeling does not offer free project estimates.
No, Fair and Square Custom Remodeling does not offer eco-friendly accreditations.
Yes, Fair and Square Custom Remodeling offers a 5% senior discount.
No, Fair and Square Custom Remodeling does not offer emergency services.
No, Fair and Square Custom Remodeling does not offer warranties.
Fair and Square Custom Remodeling offers the following services: Full or partial Bathroom Remodeling. Basement Rec Rooms. Kitchen cabinets and tops. Window installation. Door installation. Cabinet installation. Skylight installation. Molding installation.
Carpeting. Vinyl flooring. Siding Work.

Contact information

936 E Meadow Pl, WHITEFISH BAY, WI 53217

fairandsquarecustomremodeling.com

Service hours

Sunday:
Closed
Monday:
8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday:
8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday:
8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday:
8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday:
8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday:
Closed