Find top-rated Pros in your area
Enter a zip code and get matched to businesses near you.
Geo Icon
Default business cover photo

PAUL'S JEWELERS INC

Appraisal Service,

About us

If you have a jewelry repair question, a jewelry design challenge, need some pieces assessed or just want a new piece of jewelry, contact Paul's Jewelers Incorporated! We are a family owned and operated business serving Milwaukee and the World for over 50 years. We ask you what you have that can be remade or repaired before we try to sell you something new! But if it is unique you are after, we carry European inspired Gems and Jewels from all over the World! Come see our collection.

Business highlights

57 years of experience

Services we offer

GOLD, JEWELRY SALES & REPAIR. GRADUATE GEMOLOGIST APPRAISALS. DIAMONDS, WATCHES. DISTINCTIVE CUSTOM JEWELRY DESIGN & MANUFACTURING. JEWELRY & WATCH REPAIR ON PREMISES.

Accepted Payment Methods

  • CreditCard
Reviews
4.58 Reviews
Number of StarsImage of DistributionNumber of Ratings
5
75%
4
13%
3
0%
2
13%
1
0%
Showing 1-8 of 8 reviews
Richard J.
Jan 2014
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$279
Very knowledgable on product. Have made purchases previously at Paul's and will continue to.
Response from PAUL'S JEWELERS INC
"Thanks, [Member Name Removed]... We only now understand the in's and out's of reviews and that it would be great to receive a response. Sorry so long but only now am getting the hang of this! Thanks for the great write up!"

Peggy K.
May 2011
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$130
I called ahead about bringing in an engagement ring with wedding band to appraise. Over the phone, I was given appraisal prices of $50 for the first piece and each additional piece was $20. The owner spoke with me and said she would count the ring set as one piece. I decided to bring in several additional pieces for appraisal at the discounted price. I wanted to stay while my jewelry was appraised and it appears that's the way they do buisiness. I was invited to pull up a seat while my pieces were inspected and the jeweler/owner explained different things to me as she went along. At the end of an hour and 10 minutes, I walked out with written appraisils for my pieces that fully detailed/descriped my jewelry and, in some cases, included a hand drawn diagram. The jeweler also suggested a band for an oversized antique ring she appraised after hearing from me that I never wear it because it is too big. I bought that for $12 and she attached it before I left the store. My appointment started on time but we were interrupted several times by customers and phone calls. That is the reason I only gave a "B" on punctuality. The disruptions weren't terrible and the jeweler made it clear to the callers/customers that she only had a few  minutes to answer questions before returning to my appraisal. When I first placed my call, I didn't expect to pay as much for the first appraisal, so again I gave a "B" for cost. That being said, I really have no idea what the market price is and the one other jeweler I checked with charged less but did not give the discount on subsequent pieces. I found that discount to be a good incentive. Also, I noted that I should have brought in one other piece of jewelry that I had overlooked, and the jeweler said she would give me the discount price on it if I returned. I appreciate that and plan to go back for that and to have my own wedding set sized. All in all, I felt well served.
Response from PAUL'S JEWELERS INC
"Thanks,[Member Name Removed]. We only now understand the in's and out's of reviews and writing a response. Sorry took so long but only now am getting the hang of this! Thanks for the great write up and hope you come again."

Elizabeth N.
Apr 2008
4.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$50
While shopping for my engagement ring Paul's in West Allis served as our starting shop. While we did not end up buying our ring through Paul's, I was impressed by their willingness to explain cuts and costs of both my engagement ring and options for his wedding band. I went back to them for an appraisal of the ring I did get, from another retailer and they were kind and understanding and did a through inspection of my ring.
Response from PAUL'S JEWELERS INC
"Thanks, [Member Name Removed]. We only now understand the in's and out's of reviews and writing a response. Sorry took so long but only now am getting the hang of this! Thanks for the great write up and hope you try us again."

Mark R.
Oct 2007
2.0
They could not do it and directed me to another company which was basically part of a pawn shop. While I was able to get the battery replaced, I was not terribly pleased with the experience.
Response from PAUL'S JEWELERS INC
"Dear [Member Name Removed], only now are we seeing this review. I am sorry we could not have helped you with your watch but we are glad you were able to find a battery for it. Sometimes, we just can't do a repair and would rather be honest and try to help you. After being in business for, now, 53 years, we try to make a habit of directing people toward our business. We hope to see you sometime again."

Blair C.
Feb 2007
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$45
I looked for a jeweler on Angie's List and was impressed by the reports on Paul's Jeweler's. Also, the business was nearby. I brought in the ring and told the person behind the counter about my apprehensions of damaging a sentimental object. The jeweler came out from the back (I believe she was the owner) and assured me about the size and the job. They were VERY sympathetic and promised to do the work for $45.00 within the next two weeks. I had brought the ring in on a Saturday, and they called me on the following Monday at 1:14pm to tell me that the work was completed. They did exactly what I had asked them to do AND they shined that ring up better than it had ever looked in my lifetime. I am so glad that I went there. Thanks so much, Angie's List and Paul's Jewelers.
Response from PAUL'S JEWELERS INC
"Hi [Member Name Removed], Just wanted to get in touch with you. Was never aware that Angie's list did reviews and only now are finding this here. Thanks for the great words. We appreciate it. Please try us again!"

PAT W.
Dec 2005
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$200
Vivian, the owner on National avenue, was very helpful and repaired the prongs for $15.00 each. The work was done within the week and is taken care of by an in-store goldsmith. I appreciate the fact that my rings were not sent to another store for repair. I brought my daughter in to purchase diamond earrings and she is extremely happy with the quality and service. I highly recommend Paul's jewelers and will be a repeat customer in the future.
Response from PAUL'S JEWELERS INC
"Hi, [Member Name Removed], thanks for the great review. I only now have seen this and am sorry we did not respond earlier. Come back soon!"

SUSAN Z.
Feb 2005
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$20
NICE STORE, NICE FOLKS. JOB WAS COMPLETED QUICKLY.
Response from PAUL'S JEWELERS INC
"Dear [Member Name Removed], Each review is so important, and we are sorry we did not see this earlier to thank you for taking time to write it up. We look forward to helping you again!"

ANN S.
Nov 2003
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$56
THE OWNER WAITED ON US AND EXPLAINED THAT SHE HAD A WATCH EXPERT THAT DID ALL WATCH REPAIRS. WE FELT VERY COMFORTABLE HANDING OVER OUR VALUABLE WATCH. THEY ARE VERY HONEST PEOPLE, PROFESSIONAL AND TRUSTWORTHY. I WOULD FEEL COMFORTABLE BUYING JEWELRY FROM THEM ALSO.
Response from PAUL'S JEWELERS INC
"Dear [Member Name Removed], thanks for the great write up. I am sorry that we did not see this earlier to thank you for taking time to write it up. We hope to see you again soon."

Licensing

State Contractor License Requirements

All statements concerning insurance, licenses, and bonds are informational only, and are self-reported. Since insurance, licenses and bonds can expire and can be cancelled, homeowners should always check such information for themselves. To find more licensing information for your state, visit our Find Licensing Requirements page.

*Contact business to see additional licenses.

FAQ

PAUL'S JEWELERS INC is currently rated 4.5 overall out of 5.

PAUL'S JEWELERS INC accepts the following forms of payment: CreditCard

No, PAUL'S JEWELERS INC does not offer free project estimates.

No, PAUL'S JEWELERS INC does not offer eco-friendly accreditations.

No, PAUL'S JEWELERS INC does not offer a senior discount.

No, PAUL'S JEWELERS INC does not offer emergency services.

No, PAUL'S JEWELERS INC does not offer warranties.