***The Price and Quality I put a B, and I do not neccessarily mean that is Comfort Squad's fault. I am more disappointed with Trane on this area****
I tried to search around different contractors when I knew it was time to replace my two units. We have a 3000 sq ft , 1970s home. Original duct work full of dust and falling apart. Ancient heaters, mismatched condensors.
Big name companies were obscenely overmarked in pricing (i had done my research on actual cost of equipment and had debated doing myself or through a AC school for their labor as a work/learn job). Some companies, huge name, said they could not even do the job because "no one could get to the ducts in my small attic). My attic is 6-8 ft headspace, not huge, but far from abnormal (and by the way Comfort Squads crew of 3 big guys got in and out just fine)
Anyways after meeting with Emmanual, he first offered a 15 seer Lennox package with ducts for 10,000 to save me money. That was great. My family came through and chipped in another 6k, so I asked him for best systems to save money, cool and heat, and purify air. Air quality was a huge huge concern above all else. I have lung disease, bad. I asked him if he was confident in putting in Tranes upper level 2 stage systems and all the fine tuning it would need. I told him I wanted Green Ducts, a special duct work that resists mold, bacteria, more rigid, more insulated, etc.
He said he would put in dampers, add returns, registers, and keep adjusting for free for a whole year till fine tuned as close to perfect. He said he would warranty their work for 3 years no additional charge, and Tranes stuff was 10 years.
First hiccup-There was a misunderstanding about the "Green ducts" that I wanted (a type of air duct another company told me about that resists mold and bacteria, firmer and more effecient airflow-special order), but we figured out later that the supply houses call the R9 ducts, green, because energy effecient. Emmanuel and many other companies did not know about the ones I wanted because they are such a special order, not used often around here.
Emmanuel and his crew are polite, hard working and fast. All of my attic equipment was old, really old, and filthy. Most of the ducts fell apart as they removed them from the home and holy cow the coils were horrifying! Even with all the mess the old stuff made, my home was kept clean during the process. First day they showed up they got the entire downstairs system replaced. This included having to cut into ceiling to make room for old units removal and new install-apparently the builders in 1972 decided to put the HVAC systems in first and build house around them!!. Comfort Squad sent a drywall crew out few days later to put in new attic doors and ceiling sheetrock.
Few days later system 2 was installed, and just as before they did a great job keeping all the filth coming out of my attics, off of my house as they removed it all. Indoor air quality was a huge priority for me after all.
Second hiccup- Unfortunately 2 of my ducts that feed the living room could not be replaced with new. Due to design of home, these are supplied by the upstairs unit and the ducts go down 2 outside walls, then across living room soffits on both sides. Basically the only way to replace these would be cutting huge holes througout (while hoping not to hit water, electric, plumbing) and "pull" inchworm style new ducts into place. It was a huge disappointment because I had thought after this big investment I would have all new, clean and pristine hvac works. A bunch more money into wall demo and rebuilding, plus just the fear of hitting something hidden-were risks we could not take.
Both systems got a 5 inch media filter and REME air purifier, which is supposed to be the best out there for killing big bads in the air. My hope is/was this will even help the crappy 2 ducts we couldn't get to!
So tear out and install, quite frankly I was surprised how quickly it was done. Again, an older home and not huge attic space, it was impressive. They stayed past quitting time on each big day to make sure the new one was up and running before heading home, AND they cleaned up behind them on the way out, including taking all those heavy old filthy pieces with them and not just setting on trash curb like I've heard of some companies doing.
Third hiccup-and honestly I think Trane is alot at fault on this one. We decided to go in debt more and get the two stage system for the downstairs since where I stay most of the time. Trane says it runs on low most of the time, which means super long cycles, which in Houston means dropping the humidity alot more inside. Which for any of us here is great, for a lung disease guy who can't handle any mold in air, that is awesome...to me worth the extra money. But in reality, either Trane over states their equipment's ability or both of my two stage setups are duds. First they recommended to Emmanuel that he use a 4 ton for downstairs. Which seemed huge to me since I had a 3 ton there, old piece of blank, and it kept it cool, just ran alot and ineffecient. With new ducts and technology, for sure thought 3 would be fine. And the 4 ton was too big. It blasted temp down in 5 minutes. So would cycle 5-7 mins on, 5-7 off. Emmanuel tried all adjustments, even dialing back to lowest setting, but no effect. So he swapped everything out to the 3 ton. Furnace,coil, condensor, not just one piece. No charge, and no ill will to me the customer.
It was better. Cycles longer, but still seems like the low speed cycle doesn't "sense" the temp or need, it just has a preset 5 mins or so of low speed ramping. Emmanuel adjusted back and forth coming out multiple times on hot days, humid days trying to tweak this thing. Even offsetting thermostat temp and humidity, changing thermostats, etc. One or two cycles it seemed like it would work fine, even got a 35 min cycle once, but it never seems to stay consistent that way. Even my thermostats at both locations never seem to stay accurate, even after adjusting offset, which is bizarre because before I never had this problem. And they changed thermos at both locations back and forth. They double checked thermo wiring, system wiring, tested electrical controls on systems, etc. Checked outside units, tested coolant levels under load and static. According to Trane specs all looked good. But honestly this two stage setup has never been consistent, even one month saving money, next being higher than old one. Emmanuel even called Trane support who SAY they will come out in problem cases to work with the installers and support their own equipment brand, but they never did. Its been 4 months and they never responded to him, and when I called they do not even want to talk to me because I'm not an installer. Emmanuel told me I could hire another company to come and check their work, see if they missed something and he'd take care of it. I still have confidence in Comfort Squad to fine tune this as best it can be, but definitely in my book in the future I won't ever invest in Trane products again. Besides the comfort r control not doing like they advertise or the inconsistency of it all, its weird as can be that no thermostat can be accurate with them! I'd expect that crap service if we'd went with bargain basement cheap set ups, but we didn't. I think even Emmanuel was surprised at how little Trane cared to figure out the issue.
Comfort Squad may be a newer kid on the block in this huge city full of ac contractors, but their willingness to please the customer, patience, professionalism definitely give you alot of what the big companies promise, but WITH OUT the insane mark ups and nickle and dim