So this is a long convoluted story, but I'll tell the whole thing. I came home Tuesday morning from work (I work night shift) to the sound of rushing water coming from underneath the sidewalk beneath my house (where the drainage line meets outside). Thought it was odd that I could hear it from out there because I've never heard it that loud before (For example: Never heard it when coming and going from the house with the dishwasher running). When I went inside and upstairs to the bathroom, I found the water in the toilet bubbling and gurgling like a cauldron. It WAS NOT just running. There were pieces of what looked like green leafy bits and pieces of brown diarrhea-like bits in the otherwise clear water. I checked downstairs in the basement and the drainage pipe outside to the street sounded like it was rumbling and grumbling -- much more than it usually sounded when you flush the toilet or take a shower. I decided to risk it, and flushed the toilet -- thank goodness it didn't overflow but it kept bubbling and gurgling. I had to leave to go out for the day but I looked up bubbling/gurgling toilets online and everything said it was probably a partial clog. My house has a home warranty ( I just bought it) so I called my home warranty service and they gave me the number of Resolve Rooter. I set up an appointment for them to come the next day (my choice -- they could have come that afternoon if needed), Wednesday between 2-4pm. I didn't come back to the house until Wednesday morning. When I came home, the toilet was no longer bubbling, but it was running. I KNOW THE DIFFERENCE between bubbling and gurgling coming from the hole in the toilet and the water quietly running down the sides of the toilet. I've fixed a running toilet before so I opened the top of the toilet and the filler float (balloon) was at a right angle (downwards) to the wand. When I lifted up the wand to stop the water from running, the balloon just snapped off the end-- actually more like fell off, there was no noise to it. That's all I did. I wasn't playing around with the toilet and didn't purposely manipulate it to make it snap off. I didn't know how to turn off the water at the base (and didn't have a wrench) so I just wedged the balloon under the wand to keep the water from flowing and waited for the plumber. When the Resolve Rooter plumber got there at 4:15pm, he came in and asked me what was wrong. I started explaining my story and he looked amused with me. Then he stopped me and said he had to go park his car because he was double parked out front. (Did he think he was just going to run in and out in 30 seconds and not need to do any work?) When he came back, I reiterated my story and tried to stress the bubbling/gurgling and he went upstairs to look at it. As soon as he saw the toilet, he basically got very short with me. He said that the inner workings of the toilet needed to be replaced. When I asked him how it could have happened and how I could prevent it from happening again, he said very sarcastically, "Don't touch anything." Yes, he really said that. When I asked about the diarrhea/green leafy bits and the gurgling he looked very amused with me and said it must have already been in there and that it was impossible for stuff to come back into the toilet because it was on the 2nd floor. Not to be crass, but I haven't had diarrhea anytime recently and have had NO issues with the toilet up until the bubbling/gurgling, so I felt like he was implying I had loose stool and there were flushed bits left over when I KNOW that was not the case. I live alone and I'm the only person that uses the toilet and I'm well aware of my bodily functions so I'm not sure where the nasty bits came from. They weren't there when I left for work Monday night. I was a bit irritated so I went downstairs as he was fixing the toilet. He shouted down to me about 5 minutes later that he was going to use the bathroom while he was up there and then shut the bathroom door. Now, I'm perfectly ok with contractors using my bathroom, but the way he did it on top of his attitude was just icing on the cake. When he came down the steps a few minutes later, he had the old, wet pieces from inside the toilet in his hand and he handed them to me and said, "Can you throw these out?" He didn't ask where the trashcan was, just handed them to me. I went to the kitchen to throw them out and to wash my hands and then came back. He still seemed really amused with me, so I felt the need to stress that I didn't break the inside of the toilet, that I hadn't TOUCHED the inside of the toilet since I bought the house (except that morning), and reminded him he still hadn't explained why my toilet was bubbling/gurgling the day before. He said, still very amused, "I'm not saying you broke it but somebody did. Bubbling was from the overflow from the broken toilet." That was it. I asked about the excessive noise from the drainage pipe and he said, "It's supposed to sound like that when water's coming out." I made the mistake of asking him if he'd heard anything when he came in, forgetting I had already stopped the water, and he got even more amused, talking to me slow. "Well, the water was off and the water would have to be on for you to hear it, right?" I'm young, single, and female and I know NOTHING about plumbing. I'll be the first to tell you that. I may not be particularly handy, but I know the difference between a running toilet and a the bubbles that were in there yesterday. I felt like he thought I broke the toilet and made up an elaborate story to hide it. If something had simply broken in my toilet, I would have gone to Home Depot and gotten parts, then called my dad and had the both of us try to fix it before I called a plumber. I sincerely thought there was a problem and a clog! Now I have new toilet parts, but I'm not sure why the toilet broke in the first place, how to prevent it from happening again, and don't have enough trust in the plumber to believe him when he was so sarcastic and condescending from the start. I would NEVER voluntarily call this company and if anyone asks me about plumbers I'll tell them NOT to use Resolve Rooter. Maybe my questions were stupid and maybe the problem was laughingly simple but it all felt very serious to me and instead of getting reassurance and explanation, I was simply laughed at. My biggest fear is that something else will break with my plumbing and I'll have to use them again because they're contracted with my home warranty service. [Oh, and just for info: I have a $100 deductible for the home warranty but he told me the work would have cost $289 without it.]