Find top-rated Pros in your area
Enter a zip code and get matched to businesses near you.
About us
Worthington Jewelers is your source for one-of-a-kind engagement and wedding rings, designer and estate jewelry. We carry an extensive selection of fine and fashion jewelry gifts to celebrate the most important moments of your life. Or work with our jewelry designers to create a one-of-a-kind piece that will last a lifetime. With a certified gemologist and several goldsmiths on staff, we also offer a full range of on-site appraisal and repair services.
Business highlights
25 years of experience
Services we offer
Custom jewelry design, jewelry appraisals, jewelry repair, watch batteries.
Amenities
Free Estimates
Yes
Accepted Payment Methods
- CreditCard
Reviews
4.961 Reviews
| Number of Stars | Image of Distribution | Number of Ratings |
|---|---|---|
| 95% | ||
| 3% | ||
| 2% | ||
| 0% | ||
| 0% |
Showing 1-25 of 61 reviews
Alex V.
Aug 2022
Courtney helped us choose the perfect engagement ring! She was very knowledgeable, patient, kind, thorough, and you can clearly tell she truly cares about providing the customer with their perfect ring. This jeweler allows you to customize features you like from different rings, show them to you through images/CAD, and other tools that they use to make sure you love every bit of the ring. We had no idea what we wanted at first, but Courtney helped us harrow down the features that we liked, constantly responded to our additional requests with enthusiasm, and made our experience truly memorable. I would highly recommend this jeweler and Courtney specifically because you will receive genuine customer service at its best.
Amy C.
Jan 2020
My bracelet broke a week before Christmas. They gave me a price and promised a reasonable turnaround time which they beat by a day. Although it was a very busy time of year for them, they respected the importance of a medical alert bracelet and performed the service quickly and very well. I appreciate that they have in-house jewelers to do the work. I'm very satisfied.
Karyn P.
Jan 2020
The jeweler did an assessment on the spot and provided a reasonable quote. The repair was done in less than a week and the ring looks as good as new.
Cinda W.
Jan 2020
Each time the results were beautiful and the work was done ahead of the expected date. When I had questions I was able to talk to the designer who was doing the work.
Gary S.
Dec 2019
My wife's engagement ring Diamond fell out due to all the prongs breaking. They rebuilt the prongs and resized the ring and she was very pleased said it look better the new.
Laura W.
Nov 2019
I love Worthington Jewelers. I will always have a soft spot in my heart for this team of very high end professionals. My husband created my engagement ring and we bought our wedding bands here over a year ago. I go in every six months to have my rings cleaned and the staff is consistent with their service every single time. I cannot get over how fantastic they are - plus you get to know them - they keep their talented people. You don't have to worry if someone you connected with before is now gone - this isn't a typical jewelry store. Worthington Jewelers is exceptional. Super service super staff and super jewelry. Very satisfied!
Nona N.
Apr 2019
I bought a broken pearl bracelet in to be fixed (it was purchased elsewhere) and Worthington did a great job. The piece was re-designed into a necklace and bracelet and the bracelet was made stronger to prevent further breakage. I had a tough time, however, getting the clasp to work so I could put the bracelet on. I took it back and the added another jump ring and a new clasp. Problem solved. I love both pieces and wear them often. I would highly recommend Worthington Jewelers for fast, professional service.
Tammy J.
Jan 2019
I had my husband’s, who recently passed away, wedding band and a diamond pendant he game me for our anniversary that I wanted made into a necklace. The gentleman who helped me was very kind and offered suggestions as he helped me come up with a design. I had my own gold chain also. The cost was much less than I thought it would be and it was done within a few days even though it was the week before Christmas. They polished everything and it came out beautiful. I’m so thankful for their help in making this cherished keepsake.
AUTUMN P.
Dec 2018
Theresa and Bob are unbelievable at what they do and so great to work with. We’ve purchased a number of items from them over the years including a custom designed necklace and pendant for my wife when our daughter was born. They have become my family’s exclusive jeweler and I promise you won’t be disappointed.
Sam R.
Oct 2018
Worthington Jewelers gave wonderful service and I would absolutely recommend! I had a diamond ring completely redone for my engagement band. Lori was so helpful and knowledgable and followed up with me every step of the process. She went above and beyond making sure I got exactly what I was looking for. There were no surprise charges and the bill was exactly what I was quoted. If you want enthusiastic and timely service you should definitely go Worthington Jewlwers!
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"Thank you so much for your wonderful review! Lori and the rest of the team are thrilled to hear how happy you are with your experience. We appreciate your trusting us with such an important task and hope to get the opportunity to serve you again!"
Brad S.
Jul 2018
Friendly competent staff performed the work on time and the workmanship is great. I appreciate a local company with excellent service and would use them again.
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"We're so glad to hear this. Thank you so much for your business and great feedback. We hope to serve you again!"
C B.
Jun 2018
Amazingly. So happy with the result. Return customer for sure.
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"That is wonderful to hear! Thank you for sharing your experience with a review. We look forward to serving you again!"
Patricia M.
Jun 2018
I'm very happy
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"We're so pleased to hear that you are happy with the work we did on your missing stone. Thanks for the great review and we hope to see you again soon!"
Kim H.
Apr 2018
Excellent! They do great work!! They are a “family” that you can trust!
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"Thank you so much for the wonderful feedback! We want our customers to feel like they are part of our family and we're so glad that it shows. Please come back to visit us again soon!"
Laura W.
Mar 2018
Kathryn is beyond the best sales person you will find at Worthington Jewelers. I cannot say enough about her service, her professionalism and her knack for helping us design my engagement ring and our wedding bands to our liking and budget. She was responsive when we reached out via email and via phone. When she was out of the shop on her off weekend, she help share this information and honestly, that one weekend she was off we REALLY MISSED HER! :) We will always remember how kind and professional she was during this amazing journey. Both of us work in service industries so experiences are super key to each of us and we were both super happy with Kathryn's partnership. Kathryn is a gem at Worthington Jewelers. Please consider asking for her when you visit. You will not be disappointed. :)
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"On behalf of Kathryn and the entire Worthington Jewelers team, we thank you for your sparkling review! We're so pleased to hear how happy you are with your experience. Thank you for making us part of your special story. We hope you'll stay in touch and come back to see us again soon!"
Nancy B.
Jan 2018
good everything looked good
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"Thank you for the review, [Member Name Removed]! We're glad you're satisfied with the repair of your bracelet. We appreciate your business!"
Caitlin W.
Jan 2018
The service was great!
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"Thank you, [Member Name Removed]! We're so pleased that you had a great experience with getting your ring resized. Your business and recommendation are appreciated!"
Melissa H.
Nov 2017
Excellent! Will certainly go back.
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"[Member Name Removed], we appreciate the great feedback. We were honored to repair your grandmother's wedding setting. Thank you for trusting us with such an important task and for sharing your experience."
Pam P.
Sep 2017
Great! It was done within a few hours
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"Thank you for trusting us to resize your ring. We appreciate the great rating and hope you'll come back to see us again soon!"
Marilyn K.
May 2017
If I would have known how easy it was to get these rings resized, I would have done it years ago. I took the rings in to their store on High St in old town Worthington, along with my Angies List coupon. They measured each ring and then we measured my finger. After trying different sizes, we decided that the larger ring need to come down 1 1/4 sizes and the smaller one needed to go up a half size. They promised the rings for 10 days but they called me in less than a week. The rings were ready when I came back to the store. I tried them on and was one happy customer. They were very helpful and professional during the entire transaction. They took off the coupon with no fuss.
Eve B.
May 2017
Perfect! Great service by everyone we encountered at the facility. Fast turnaround, loved that the work was done in house.
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"Thank you for the five-star review. We're so happy to hear you had a great experience purchasing and sizing your wedding bands. Thank you again for choosing [Member Information Removed] Jewelers!"
Renee H.
May 2017
All in order
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"[Member Name Removed], our team appreciates the great review. We're glad to hear you are happy with the repair of your jewelry. Please let us know if there is anything else we can do for you!"
MIKE N.
Apr 2017
Great from start to finish.
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"Thank you for your business and review! We sincerely appreciate your recommendation."
Isac K.
Jan 2017
Amazing! Custom made ring, beautiful!
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"Thank you, [Member Name Removed], for the great feedback on your custom ring. We're so pleased to hear that you are happy with the finished product. We hope to see you again soon!"
Leonard B.
Sep 2016
We came in with an idea of what we liked, and had some of our own loose stones we could use for the custom ring. We worked with Katherine, who spent several hours with us, presenting settings and showing us options in several catalogs. Over a few weeks, we emailed designs back and forth until we hit on the perfect one. When the ring arrived, we realized that our stone was not right for the setting, and Katherine helped us pick one out that was both bigger and within our "stretch" budget. It truly set off the overall look without being over-the-top. We loved the ring, and the service we received from WJ brought me back when it was time for my wife's birthday. I worked with Katherine again, who remembered our prior conversations about our very casual lifestyle, and she pointed me to a different, less expensive gift than what I had in mind, but that would be more appropriate for my retired wife. I am not surprised that I was directed away from the more expensive gift - a true sales professional helps the client with what works best for them, which isn't always what they ask for! My wife loved her gift, and I was thrilled with her reaction. I would HIGHLY recommend Worthington Jewelers for anyone looking to purchase jewelry at any price point. They have a great onsite selection as well as having the ability to make or order custom pieces, and their service (before and after the sale) is unparalleled in my experience.
Response from WORTHINGTON JEWELERS
"Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts on your experiences with Worthington Jewelers. It's great to know that you enjoyed working with us as much as we enjoyed working with you. Katherine and our entire team truly appreciate hearing your feedback. We hope we get the opportunity to help you find the perfect gift again soon!"
Licensing
State Contractor License Requirements
All statements concerning insurance, licenses, and bonds are informational only, and are self-reported. Since insurance, licenses and bonds can expire and can be cancelled, homeowners should always check such information for themselves. To find more licensing information for your state, visit our Find Licensing Requirements page.
*Contact business to see additional licenses.
FAQ
WORTHINGTON JEWELERS is currently rated 4.9 overall out of 5.
WORTHINGTON JEWELERS accepts the following forms of payment: CreditCard
Yes, WORTHINGTON JEWELERS offers free project estimates.
No, WORTHINGTON JEWELERS does not offer eco-friendly accreditations.
No, WORTHINGTON JEWELERS does not offer a senior discount.
No, WORTHINGTON JEWELERS does not offer emergency services.
No, WORTHINGTON JEWELERS does not offer warranties.