Find top-rated Pros in your area
Enter a zip code and get matched to businesses near you.
About us
Anderson Amish Cabinets features authentic handmade cabinetry of Old Order Amish craftsmen from Central Illinois. Kitchen and bathroom cabinets are all individually handmade with the highest craftsmanship for your home. Cabinet are constructed using solid woods and traditional construction methods such as mortise tenon joinery and dovetailing, providing quality cabinets that will last long and install easily. The wonderful part about working with Anderson Amish Cabinets is that you are creating a custom kitchen for your home! . By appointment only.
Business highlights
20 years of experience
Services we offer
Cabinet dealer & design firm.
Amenities
Free Estimates
Yes
Reviews
5.084 Reviews
| Number of Stars | Image of Distribution | Number of Ratings |
|---|---|---|
| 100% | ||
| 0% | ||
| 0% | ||
| 0% | ||
| 0% |
Showing 1-25 of 84 reviews
Rick S.
Apr 2025
We recently had our kitchen redone and used Catherine and Amish Cabinets. We loved our cabinets when we first saw them, and we continue to love them several months on. Catherine worked with us to make sure we had just what we wanted for our kitchen. She showed great patience, listened to us and offered a few helpful suggestions that improved our design. She was incredibly timely with her responses to our questions and revisions. The custom-made cabinets are sturdy and very high-quality. They have made it through two major holidays with a house full of people (including little ones who like to slam doors). We highly recommend Catherine and Amish Cabinets!
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Thank you for including pictures of your gorgeous new kitchen! It's wonderful working with people who have lived in their home for a while. The transformation is magical. You've been awesome to work with throughout the process. I appreciate working together with you and your review."
Kate A.
Feb 2025
If you’re looking for exceptional craftsmanship and attention to detail, Anderson Amish Cabinets and Catherine Anderson are the best. From our first conversation, Catherine’s patience and thorough approach made it clear she truly cares about her work. She took the time to understand our needs, guiding us while ensuring every detail was just right. The workmanship is second to none—flawless finishes, durable construction, and thoughtful design. You can tell every piece is crafted with care. What’s more, whatever ideas I had, Catherine said, “We’ll make it happen—and did!” The entire process was seamless, and when our cabinets arrived, they exceeded every expectation—stunning, functional, and built to last. If you want high-quality, beautifully designed cabinetry from a team that takes pride in their craft, Anderson Amish Cabinets is the way to go!
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Working with you on this amazing project has been pure joy. Your vision and inspiration pictures made it easy to communicate your dream kitchen to the Amish. It's easy to have such gorgeous results working with a client like you. Thank you for letting me part of this wonderful transformation."
Theresa A.
Feb 2025
Amazing and so happy with the completed project! I highly recommend Anderson Amish Cabinets and would use them again!!
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"What an amazing transformation to your kitchen. Your hood and glass front cabinetry with the "x" mullions are breathtaking. You have been a joy to work with. Thank you for your review."
Mark M.
Feb 2025
After getting 5 or more quotes we heard about Anderson Amish Cabinets. When Catherine walked in we knew things were going to be different. Absolute complete customization She Listened to us. Asked about our wants needs and desires. She gave us SO MANY unique ideas that were practical and functional. She prevented us from making mistakes and offered great suggestions for what we were trying to accomplish. Catherine and Alex managed the design, measuring and installation coordination. Installation was a dream. We reviewed the designs countless times to make sure everything was designed to perfection. The installation team paid so much attention to every little detail. Alex was here the day the cabinets arrived and installation started, and Catherine came the next day to check the progress.Every cabinet is perfectly level, and every little nailhead was filled in with perfect color match. I do a lot of cooking and canning and this kitchen is my dream come true. It is absolutely beautiful and completely functional. I have a place for everything. The price was very very fair considering it’s a 23.5 foot wide kitchen with one wall of cabinet cabinets, a 15‘ x 4‘ deep island, a beverage center that is 4‘ x 18“, a balustrade that is 8 foot wide designed by an artist, all the wood trim for the windows and door in the entire Great Room, and a bathroom vanity and linen closet door. I still randomly, six months later, text Catherine how much I love this kitchen. Use Catherine and Alex and you will be the envy of all your friends with your super high-quality, stunningly, beautiful cabinets.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Thank you for your wonderful review. Working with you has been a pure joy for Alex and me from start to finish. Your ideas and specific needs for the space made the whole process that much more smooth and enjoyable. You had the vision for the balustrade...and the result gives such unique beauty and usefulness to an otherwise boring dividing wall. I so appreciate collaborating with you both on this transformation."
Todd C.
Sep 2021
We were building our 7th home and were getting frustrated with the builders contractor for cabinets because they were not able to give us what we wanted. We were walking through the house under construction one evening when a neighbor bumped into us and asked how things were going. We told them our frustration with the cabinet selection process and he mentioned Anderson Amish Cabinets (Catherine Anderson) is who they used and I am so grateful he did. I contacted Catherine immediately and she answered the phone while on vacation in the Pacific Northwest...we talked and the rest is history. All the frustration with the builders cabinet supplier was eliminated and we could not be happier with our cabinets throughout our house. If you want a "partner" who helps guide you, has patience, answers the phone/email, proactively communicates, gives honest feedback, handles all issues that come up (even after the sale/install), is pleasant, stays positive, and has a smile on her face, then look nowhere else...just call Anderson Amish Cabinets (317-697-9289). You will not be disappointed...I have experienced why she is a multiple Angi's award winning company...she does not just "talk the talk"...she "walks the walk" and delivers the WOW experience to customers. Something that does not happen very often in today's business climate. If you are building or doing a remodel, I highly recommend Catherine Anderson (Anderson Amish Cabinets)…you will not be disappointed and you will be extremely pleased with the finished product and the journey.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Thank you for including the pictures of your gorgeous home. You both made this process a delightful partnership. Your ideas ,talents and patience made this a joyful process. You have created a warm and wonderful space for memory making for your loving family. Thank you for involving my company in this transformation and for your enthusiastic endorsement."
Steven K.
Aug 2021
We heard about Catherine from an recent client while we were in the process of cabinet selections with our builder. They highly recommended Catherine and invited us to their new home to see their cabinets. After reviewing Catherine's cabinet designs, samples and pricing we selected Anderson Amish Cabinets and are very happy we did. Catherine was a pleasure to work with, very responsive throughout the entire process and the Amish crafted cabinets are of excellent quality. We highly recommend Anderson Amish Cabinets.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"You and your wife were a pleasure to work with throughout the building process. Your choices and finishes resulted in a gorgeous new home. Clients like you make my job a joy. Thank you for your review."
Chad H.
Aug 2021
Catherine did a fantastic job. She worked with us throughout the entire process. Her professionalism was outstanding. The cabinets are top line. The contractor who did the remodel said he would use her again. She was extremely helpful and responsive throughout the remodel. The cabinets are beautiful and well crafted. She worked really well with us and the remodel team. We would use her again without hesitation.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Your project was so much fun from start to finish. The transformation this remodel brings to your family will be enjoyed for years to come. My favorite part is the unique island that provides oodles of both storage and seating space. Both of you have been a delight to work with. I so appreciate being part of your team. Thank you for your review."
JEFF B.
Feb 2021
Working with Catherine was a wonderful experience from beginning to end. She was easy to work with, had great ideas, is a stickler for details, and makes sure that her product is delivered and installed as expected. I can't say enough great things. This kitchen remodel was a huge project, but working with Catherine took a lot of stress off of me because I knew she would deliver on quality and professionalism. The cabinets are beautiful- real wood and hand made. This is our second project with her. Several years ago, she custom designed a gorgeous fireplace mantle for us.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Your kitchen transformation is amazing. It's changed the whole feel of your home. Not only is it beautiful and light filled, but also has a flow and function that fits your family. Your unique island that seats 8-9 people is gorgeous and will be a focal point for memory making and laughter. You have been a joy to work with and I appreciate your review."
Dhiren P.
Jan 2021
Catherine was very helpful and professional thru the whole process. We were kept up to date on the progress and the delivery was on schedule as planned.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"I so enjoyed working with you both to create a kitchen that exactly fits your needs. You did an excellent job on the installation. You have transformed your space into a haven of warmth and beauty that will be enjoyed by your family for many years to come. I appreciate your review."
Mike M.
Jan 2021
Catherine was awesome. Preliminary discussions centered on what was the purpose of the project and what our expectations were and how to provide the product and service to meet our needs. Catherine offered design ideas, options for customized cabinets, and ways of saving on costs. She provided drawings and prints so there were no questions on how the project would be completed. A very professional, honest, and friendly person to work with.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Your new kitchen is gorgeous! I enjoyed working with you every step of the way. Though all the decisions to be made over style, features, appliances, tile, etc can seem overwhelming at first, you both did an excellent job of weighing options and deciding on every detail. The doughnuts you provided at delivery were an extra kindness and much appreciated. Thank you for your review."
Polly M.
Jan 2021
Catherine was extremely helpful in showing us the possibilities available in Amish cabinetry for our kitchen. She was always on time and had her products available for viewing. Catherine carefully listened to our needs and wants and shared a variety of ideas. We were able to select the options that would work for our family without any pressure. She measured and remeasured and was flexible if changes were made. Catherine was a delight to work with and was always available for any additional questions we had throughout the process. We would definitely work with Catherine on future projects and would highly recommend her to others.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"I love working with people that have lived in their home for a while...and are ready for a change. Removing the bulkhead and opening up the doorway so beautifully transformed your space. You were both pure joy to work together with. You did an excellent job in your design choices. I appreciate your review and look forward to working together again in the future."
Linda M.
Jan 2021
We could not have asked for a better more positive experience. With Catherine's knowledge and expertise in her field, along with a customer driven "can do" attitude, she made the whole process an amazing experience. We have only positive things to say about working with Catherine! Her price was much better than others, quality of craftsmanship is exceptional and we love our kitchen!
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Thank you for including pictures of your spectacular kitchen. Your tile, paint and hardware choices brought everything together beautifully. You'll never miss the wall that was removed between the kitchen and the dining room...and with love the warm, open design. I so enjoyed working with you and appreciate your review."
Brian P.
Jan 2021
Catherine Anderson was referred to us by our general contractor in preparation for a kitchen remodel. It was the best referral we could have received. Catherine was professional and easy to work with. She came to the house several times to measure and understand what we wanted to with the kitchen and the features and functions of the cabinets and drawers. Her project plan worked well with the general contractor's and the cabinets and drawers came in on time and were beautiful. We plan to use her again for a potential bathroom remodel and would highly recommend her.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"It was a pleasure working with you both from start to finish. Your new kitchen is beautiful...the Naval blue island looks great with your white cabinets and hardwood floors. Removing the desk area really gave you oodles of useful storage. Thank you for your review. I look forward to working together again in the future."
Harry O.
Jan 2021
Went to Home Depot and Lowe's for estimates before contacting Katherine. By the time you added in all of the extra cost from those vendors, Anderson Amish Cabinets was the clear choice for both quality and price.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Wow... your new kitchen space is amazing! Taking down the wall between your kitchen and dining room so opened up your home and made wonderful space for entertaining and family gatherings. Your color choice and attention to detail made this project a huge success. You're a joy to work with . Enjoy your new space."
Melissa K.
Dec 2020
Catherine was recommended to us by a friend. We are extremely happy with our cabinets, they are very high quality and beautiful. I shared my vision of what I wanted and Catherine created it. Our office is transformed and adds value to our home. Highly recommend!
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"It was so fun transforming your ordinary office space into extraordinary office space! Your Naval blue cabinets are gorgeous. It was a pleasure working with you. Thank you for your review."
Dianne M.
Oct 2019
Has gone very well. Catherine was great to work with and Jim has been a busy beaver getting drawers in, and removing my oven and microwave in preparation for my new appliances. Very happy with it all. Highly recommend.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"It was fun adding functional roll outs to your pantry. So much room for dependable storage! You were a joy to work with. Thank you for your review."
Gary R.
Oct 2019
The team was on time, professional and delivered the highest quality product. We will use them again when we remodel our master bathroom.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Thank you for your review. Your new kitchen with the bank seating is amazingly beautiful. Your choices for tile and countertop were perfect. Thank you for your business."
Allyn C.
Oct 2019
AAC did our kitchen, bathrooms, bookcases and trim for our home. After we were done we decided to modify cabinets and add some extra storage into the toekicks. I found some online pictures and it went from there. Everything was executed flawlessly. We Love working with Catherine.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Its amazing how you've maximized the space in your kitchen. I appreciate you posting a pictures as well. You're always a delight to work with. Thank you for your review."
Doug B.
Oct 2019
Catherine Anderson was very personable and helpful and very responsive. We had a few snags, but she was very accommodating.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"You were wonderful to work with . I so appreciate your patience while we solved some details in your unique cabinet. Your new bathroom is gorgeous and the three drawer design under your vanity sink will be reused in future projects. Thank you for your review and business."
Kenneth K.
Oct 2019
This is the third time that I have used Catherine and, as usual, the results were absolutely perfect. You cannot see any difference between the original trim, panel and shelves with the new doors which were also crafted with quarter sawn red oak.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"The Amish showed their amazing ability to match stain on this project. Your new living room has gorgeous breakfronts with glass doors, giving you the space to display your beautiful collectibles. It has been a joy working with your one your three separate projects. You are a valued client and I appreciate your business and review."
Rose P.
Oct 2019
Catherine helped us determine what we needed to achieve the look we wanted for our bathroom. The vanity was the focal point for our other decisions. When it arrived, we were extremely pleased with the quality of the workmanship, the color and the perfect fit. It arrived when expected and care was taken to assure that it was not damaged in any way. Great value for the money spent. We could have this vanity forever. Catherine was very professional and responsive to any questions along the way. We would use her services again and would not hesitate to recommend her.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Your inset gray cabinets are gorgeous. Thank you for the opportunity to work together and transform your owner's bathroom into a serene getaway room in your home. I appreciate your review and business."
Charles F.
Sep 2019
Catherine was very easy to work with. She was very careful to get measurements correct. The final product matched are existing cabinet doors extremely well. We are pleased with the final look.
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Making three of your cabinets doors with glass fronts and mullions really added light and beauty to your kitchen. the Amish are true craftsman with matching stains. You were a delight to work with. Thank you for your review."
Joy A.
Aug 2019
What a wonderful experience it has been working with Catherine of Anderson Amish Cabinets. She provided suggestions, insights, and designs that work for us beautifully, despite the fact that the footprint of the kitchen and laundry had limitations. Her knowledge of the cabinetry is surpassed by her love of kitchens and what makes it work. So many pieces we didn’t think of were addressed by Catherine. Beyond that, Catherine worked so easily with our contractor in planning around pipes and the kitchen limitations of our century old house. This was a blessing for us! Our kitchen is filled with storage and beautiful, well built cabinets.....in a design that allows us ease in using our kitchen and loving our time spent in it. We wouldn’t change a bit if the design or cabinetry! Thank you! PS. Her pricing was below our expectations...another welcomed surprise!
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"What an amazing transformation your new kitchen is to your home! I love the challenge of fitting cabinets around and in between plumbing features of an older home. The Amish craftsmanship shines through when there's a need for custom cabinet widths and depths. It was a total delight working with you and your outstanding contractor. His expertise and teamwork attitude assured that the cabinet installation would run smoothly despite the fact that I live in Indiana, the cabinets were made in Illinois and the cabinets were installed in Massachusetts! Thank you for your review and the opportunity to work together."
CHRISTOPHER A.
Mar 2019
It went great. Very satisfied.
Keith P.
Nov 2018
Great! Professional, punctual and good product, real wood! Catherine is an absolute pleasure to work with!!
Response from Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC
"Thank you for your review. You are a delight to work with. You did an excellent job on your paint, flooring and tile selection. You new bathroom is gorgeous!"
Licensing
State Contractor License Requirements
All statements concerning insurance, licenses, and bonds are informational only, and are self-reported. Since insurance, licenses and bonds can expire and can be cancelled, homeowners should always check such information for themselves. To find more licensing information for your state, visit our Find Licensing Requirements page.
*Contact business to see additional licenses.
FAQ
Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC is currently rated 5.0 overall out of 5.
Yes, Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC offers free project estimates.
No, Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC does not offer eco-friendly accreditations.
No, Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC does not offer a senior discount.
No, Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC does not offer emergency services.
No, Anderson Amish Cabinets LLC does not offer warranties.