The good things; * He was responsive * He followed up on my calls * He showed up on time * He did a good job of clean up of the area that needed to be mulched before it was mulched The not-so-good things: * Jose wanted to give an overall cost for the job - wanted to come out & look at it, said he didn't like to work hourly. This lead to things not getting done that I would've GLADLY paid someone to do. (eg: clean up of outdoor items under my back porch.) * Jose told me things would get done - trim the bushes on the side of the house (never done), pull the weed in the back (sort of done - only because I pushed), edge the landscaping (which I originally said I didn't want done, he kept insisting he'd do, I agreed to & then when the time came...he said he didn't do because I didn't want it - but then he did do it when I pushed). * I wanted someone to come in & just get accomplished what I wanted to be done. But, he didn't write anything down; I felt like I kept having to go out & manage the process, which was frustrating. This lead to having to repeat what I'd told him only the day before when he came out to give me the estimate. * I was having plants dug up from our yard & planted on our neighborhood nature trail. Once Jose got back to the nature trail - I kept hearing complaining that the ground was "not good" for planting. Now, granted, the Homeowners Assn nature trail we have does not have fabulous dirt for planting - but over the years, we've planted trees there, flowers and so on - and they've definitely survived! All he & his brother did were dig SHALLOW holes, barely, skimming the top of the ground and then laid the plants on the holes! (Which, sadly, I didn't realize until the next day.) Some of the other plants he just cut, stuck straight up in a hole & covered with dirt - as you can imagine, they will NOT survive. As well, I showed him where I wanted the lilies transplanted back there, in a straight line - they were all over the place. NOW - I'm going to have to pay someone else to go in and clean up all the dead plants back there. * He plants plants - but doesn't then water them after placing them in the ground. I don't know much about gardening, but I DO know you need to water plants right after planting them - especially on hot days! * When he gave me the estimate - he told me he would be here "for however long it took" - yet, the next day, around noon, he started telling me he needed to get going as he had a lot of other things to do that day. (Which really frustrated me - as that was not the message he'd been giving the day before.) I'd made the comment to Jose (when he was giving the estimate) that I wasn't going to pay $50/hr per person (Jose & his brother) to do the work - which is when he told me he'd be there however long it took to get done what I needed. * Edging was never done in the back yard. * I asked him to trim a large bush next to our garage which has started to show some dead branches. He responded "of course, no problem." But, when I went back & looked at that - I had to point out the still dead remaining branches on the bush, which he'd missed. He then cut a couple of more off. When he was in a different part of the yard, I actually ended up cutting off more of the branches myself, so it would be done correctly, removing all the dead branches. In regard to this bush, I also pointed out how the one "viney" plant was probably strangling this bush & I wanted the "viney" part cut out so it wouldn't continue to wreak havoc on this bush. It was never done. * I told him I wanted a "cusp" removed from a young tree in our yard. He said he thought it (the cusp) needed to be there one more year & I should remove it in the Spring. I wasn't very happy about this - as I'd had an arbolist out in the Spring & he told me to remove the cusp holding up the tree, as it wasn't necessary & wasn't actually good for the tree any longer. As I write this, the cusp is still there, just DANGLING around the tree. (I need to go out & do this myself now - which makes me none too happy.) * He brought his tween-age son with him, which he'd not mentioned the day before. He did do some work, but it seemed that most of the time I saw him, he was standing there, watching or running around to the neighbor's homes, dropping off their business cards. * I had to point out (obvious) weeds for him to pull before he put down the mulch. There were other weeds I'd liked to have pulled - but, you could just tell, he felt he was done with my yard & he was ready to go. Overall, Jose is a nice guy. But...if he doesn't want to do something, he is going to somehow push back to not do it. And - if it something strenuous, such as digging a hole in a touch patch of ground - it won't be done correctly. I didn't mind paying him the amount that I did - what I have a problem with is there were still things which I wanted to have completed in my yard - and they are not. I would've GLADLY paid him more to have it all done & done correctly. Would I hire Jose again? Sadly, no.