Find top-rated Pros in your area
Enter a zip code and get matched to businesses near you.
Geo Icon

David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin

Appraisal Service,

About us

**$25 for $40 Credit Toward the Repair of any Jewelry** We are a small friendly store carrying a multi-million dollar inventory of the most fashionable Platinum, 18K, 14K, diamond and gemstone jewelry and watches. Some of our best known designers include Claude Thibaudeau, Denny Wong, Ziva, Cordova, Gelin and Abaci, Bellaire, Luminox and one of a kind custom pieces by resident designer Shane Socash. Don't forget we also buy and sell Gold/Silver/Platinum/Palladium in nearly all forms.

Business highlights

53 years of experience

Services we offer

Appraisals - Antiques, Design, Items. Jewelry Sales, Jewelry, Repair.

Amenities

Free Estimates

Yes

Accepted Payment Methods

  • CreditCard
Reviews
5.044 Reviews
Number of StarsImage of DistributionNumber of Ratings
5
98%
4
2%
3
0%
2
0%
1
0%
Showing 1-25 of 44 reviews
Nancy D.
Dec 2020
1.0
no one responded to my request.
Response from David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin

"Ouch [Member Name Removed], this hurts. If you check back through your messages you'll see I responded in less than 24 hours. We buy the items you have as I responded and would love for you to bring them in for us to have a look at them. Flippantly throwing out negative reviews really hurt people that are trying hard. My business is my life and I strive to answer all texts, emails, phone calls, phone messages, texts through our website, texts from Yelp, texts from Angie's List, messages from Facebook, messages from Instagram, messages from Linked In, and clients in our store. There are a myriad of ways for people to reach out to me, and sometimes these systems take time to alert me."


Denise M.
Dec 2019
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
purchase of household antiques. Not what he was buying.

Donna F.
May 2019
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$2,800
Shane Socash, Jeweler and owner of David Reynold's, listened closely to what I said, and was able to restore my grandmother's watch to how I remembered it looked 40 years ago. He listened, he understood and he recreated my grandmother's watch. I had foolishly changed the wide gold cuff band to a silver chain. Shane had only my memory and descriptions to work with. Thank you Shane! I love it!

Ellen C.
Apr 2019
1.0
Save yourself time and stay away from this company. They offered a couple of hundred dollars for a few items and refused to even consider other items for which the next company visited offered tens of thousands for - yes, it's not a type error. They were insulting on a grand scale ! Really seems they are out to get the unsuspecting client. Even their watch battery replacement is not what other companies do better. Based on my experience I would definitely hesitate to buy anything there . It probably is way overpriced.
Response from David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin

"It's disappointing and unfortunate that we let you down. As our reputation would suggest, we get it right dozens of times a day but we are human and in our humanity, we're imperfect. We have always wanted our clients to get the most for their items, historically it's with us, but we're always the first to recommend another company if it's an item we either don't need or think you can do better with elsewhere. I hope that the place that offered you tens of thousands of dollars for your item is one of the places we recommended you visit. While I support our decision to only buy items we have a need for, when we turn down an item we should do it politely and respectfully."


Sharon G.
Apr 2018
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
They did a beautiful job! I've been doing business with them for over 20 years and highly recommend. The jewelers do superb work.

Molly P.
Mar 2017
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$500
I am thrilled!  I took in two rings (one engagement/wedding band and a cocktail ring) with an idea for a whole new ring.  Shane was helpful before my first visit--sending ideas and links to pictures.  When we went into the shop, he walked me through the process.  I was impressed with his professionalism and knowledge--he knows jewelry and design!  I came back to pick up the new rings a few weeks later and was blown away.  The appraisal (completed by Susie) was quick and easy as well.  I will definitely keep Shane in mind for future jewelry needs and will definitely recommend him to others!

Linda S.
Aug 2016
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
Anything that I have that is jewelry related, I go to them. They are honest and reputable.

James M.
Jul 2016
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$20
While waiting for the repair I was able to look at the coins and bills for sale. Ended up getting a few and the prices were very fair. I felt bad that we came in so close to the closing time but was not shooed out like some other places tend to do. I had used their services in the past to repair broken jewelry. Another company recommended them due to the type of metal requiring different technique than most shops have. Very pleased and will go back at an earlier hour to get a better sense of coins and old currency I can get to add to my collection.

Thomas S.
Jun 2016
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro

Shane Socash and his assistants Zach and Brad skillfully examined my estate jewelry, cheerfully answered my questions, explained the difference in pieces as they sorted.

As this was my parents estate, they where especially sympathetic and caring and paid a very good price for the estate.




Karen T.
Apr 2016
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
unknown

Chrissy S.
Jan 2016
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$11,000
I lost my original David Reynolds engagement ring and insurance worked with owner Shane Splash to replace it at a higher quality. It is beautiful.

Ginny K.
Jan 2016
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$20
Shane helped me immediately and took care of my problem. He has done a lot of repairs for me in the past and I would recommend him highly.

Johnn M.
Dec 2015
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
unknown

Dr. E.
Oct 2015
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
Excellen. I was treated with respect and I appreciated the time they gave me while providing excellent tretment. Market gold prices. I trust their interigity.

Geri C.
Sep 2015
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$170
unknown

Mary M.
Aug 2015
4.0
unknown
Response from David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin

"Mrs. [Member name removed], I'm so sorry to hear your concerns you have expressed. Call us right away at 727-327-2646 and I'll see if I can put your grouping back together in case of you are wanting to shop around at other companies. This is our first partially bad review of 58 and I would love the opportunity to help resolve any concerns you have. For over 40 years we have had people come in, get an offer to purchase their estate (coins or otherwise) take it to shop it around, only to return later in the day to ultimately sell it to us because our offer was higher. It's the primary reason our shop is exceedingly busy. Please let us help."


Patricia C.
Aug 2015
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
Shane Socash was very prompt in servicing us, even with a crowded store. I had several gold jewelry pieces to sell. He did each piece one at a time, displayed the item with the price he offered under it on tray so I was able to see in plain view the price. If a piece was 14k, not 10k, I brought it to his attention. He checked, and had no problem in changing price on item. He went 100+. I will go back to David Reynolds in the future. Very fair.

Richard B.
Jun 2015
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$350
From the moment we walked in, the entire staff treated us with respect and service. It was a friendly and professional environment.

Priscilla G.
Jun 2015
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$35
All of the persons I dealt with by email, phone & in person were professional & courteous.  The work was done on time and the work was exceptional. I will be dealing with this company in the future and will recommend them.

James S.
May 2015
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$20
unknown

Ross S.
Feb 2015
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$50,000
Did not miss any commitments!  In fact delivered ahead of schedule and the end results were far more and stunning than expected.

Joel C.
Jan 2015
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$3,400
I highly recommend David Reynolds Jewelry. It was the first
time for me selling my gold and I was very satisfied with the service provided.
Shawn is not your typical sales guy that is doing everything in his power to
sell you a product. Instead, Shawn and his team are genuinely concerned about
their customers. He is honest, ethical, and knowledgeable - you can easily see
that the team is running a high quality small and independent business that is fair
and ethical. Although David Reynolds is not a national jewelry store, they
carry fine jewelry and offer a reasonable selection from some unique designers.


Thank you Shawn!  for
being an honest guy and for going above and beyond for me and my wife. She
loves her new ring and I love the fact that I was able to stay within budget. I
will be back for sure and will recommend your store to my friends.

Donald B.
Dec 2014
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$995
This ring is quite old and did not have any work performed on it in many years. It is a complex diamond ring consisting of many different shaped diamonds. The appearance of the ring was very dull and dirty, missing one of the small round diamonds, and two of the baguette cut diamonds were badly damaged and needed to be replaced along with the center navette cut prong set that was twisted needing to be reset. I took the ring to David Reynolds after reading the reviews realizing they probably have the expertise for the restoration. I was not disappointed, the staff was extremely professional and attentive answering all my questions and addressing the concerns of the ring. The work was completed ahead of schedule and ring looks exceptional. I am totally impressed with the work performed, the ring looks brand new and I couldn't be happier with the results.

Gerrit B.
Oct 2014
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$25
The service was way beyond the call of duty, as the owner himself repaired my glasses, knowing that his service person was already away for the weekend, and knowing that I was going on a week's trip, and would be in trouble without my glasses!

David P.
Aug 2014
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
My parents estate included about 8 rings and/or jeweled pieces.  I had no idea of their worth (if any) and took them to David Reynolds for valuation.  They looked at each piece, informed of their composition and offered a valuation for them at selling price and also at replacement price.  They kindly did this at absolutely no charge. Their own custom made rings and jewelry also looked very nice.  Their staff was attentive and very gracious.  I'd highly recommend them for your jewelry valuation or other jewelry needs.
Showing 1-25 of 44

Licensing

State Contractor License Requirements

All statements concerning insurance, licenses, and bonds are informational only, and are self-reported. Since insurance, licenses and bonds can expire and can be cancelled, homeowners should always check such information for themselves. To find more licensing information for your state, visit our Find Licensing Requirements page.

*Contact business to see additional licenses.

FAQ

David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin is currently rated 5.0 overall out of 5.
David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin accepts the following forms of payment: CreditCard
Yes, David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin offers free project estimates.
No, David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin does not offer eco-friendly accreditations.
No, David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin does not offer a senior discount.
No, David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin does not offer emergency services.
No, David Reynolds Jewelry and Coin does not offer warranties.

Contact Information

4009 Central Ave, St. Petersburg, FL 33713

Share project details to get started.