Orange Peel vs. Knockdown Wall Textures: A Complete Guide
*Orange* you curious to learn the differences?
Orange peel texture is finer and more subtle than knockdown.
Knockdown texture creates a flatter, more dramatic pattern.
Orange peel is easier to apply and repair than knockdown.
Knockdown tends to cost slightly more due to additional labor.
Both textures help conceal drywall imperfections.
Texture plays a key role in your walls’ appearance and durability. Two of the most popular drywall textures, orange peel and knockdown, add character and hide imperfections, but their looks, application methods, and costs vary. Whether you’re remodeling or finishing new drywall, understanding the differences between orange peel and knockdown will help you choose the best finish for your home.
What are the Differences Between Orange Peel and Knockdown Wall Textures?
Orange peel and knockdown textures are both spray-on wall finishes, but they differ in appearance and application. Orange peel is smoother and looks like—spoiler alert—the skin of an orange, while knockdown has a more rugged, flattened texture. Knockdown also takes more time and labor to apply, which often makes it more expensive.
| Feature | Orange Peel | Knockdown |
|---|---|---|
| Texture | Fine and bumpy | Large, flattened splatter |
| Visual style | Spray only | Spray and flatten |
| Repairability | Easier to patch | Harder to blend |
| Cost | Lower | Slightly higher |
| Skill level | Easier to DIY | Often needs a pro |
Appearance Differences
When it comes to visual texture, orange peel offers a smoother, more uniform finish. It adds a subtle dimension without taking center stage. In contrast, knockdown texture is more dramatic, featuring flattened splatters that create a varied, spread-out look. It has more visual interest and a rougher feel, making it a bolder design choice.
In terms of style, orange peel works well in modern and transitional homes that lean toward clean lines and understated finishes. Knockdown, on the other hand, complements bolder styles such as rustic or Mediterranean.
Cost Differences
Both finishes are relatively budget-friendly, but knockdown costs a bit more because there’s an extra step in the application process. Orange peel texture installation ranges from $1.25 to $1.95 per square foot, while knockdown can creep up over $2 per square foot. The added labor for knockdown, which includes spraying the mud and then flattening it with a drywall knife, accounts for the higher price tag. If you’re working on a large area or trying to match existing textured walls, it may be worth hiring an interior painter near you for a seamless finish.
Application and Difficulty Differences
Orange peel texture is applied using a spray gun and left to dry. You can fairly easily apply orange peel texture as a DIY, especially if you want to cover large areas quickly. Knockdown starts the same way—with drywall mud sprayed onto the surface—but then requires you to wait a few minutes before dragging a drywall knife across to “knock down” the peaks. The timing and technique can feel tricky, making it more difficult to apply knockdown texture as a DIY project.
Durability and Maintenance Differences
Orange peel is considered easier to apply to existing walls in need of repair, because you can feather the edges and spray over repaired spots to blend them easily. Knockdown repairs are trickier because the pattern is more irregular, making it harder to match the surrounding areas.
When it comes to cleaning, both textures resist minor scuffs and scratches well. However, knockdown’s deeper grooves can trap more dust, so it may require more frequent wiping or vacuuming.
When to Hire a Pro
You can DIY either texture with the right tools, but knockdown often benefits from a professional touch due to its trickier application. Consider hiring a local drywall pro if:
You’re texturing multiple rooms or high walls
You want to match the existing knockdown texture
You’re concerned about consistency or finish quality
Frequently Asked Questions
Both textures are very common in modern homes, and either option is unlikely to negatively affect resale. Orange peel is slightly more versatile and preferred in newer builds, but knockdown may appeal to buyers looking for a rustic, antique, or more Mediterranean look. It’s often a matter of personal preference.
Knockdown hides imperfections better than orange peel due to its thicker, more varied pattern. The valleys and peaks make flaws less visible under lighting. However, note that knockdown walls will collect more dust and dirt, so be prepared to wipe them away more frequently than you would with orange peel.
Yes, you technically can apply knockdown over existing orange peel, but you’ll need to prep the surface first. Essentially, you’ll need to undo the orange peel before proceeding. This involves sanding down the orange peel texture and applying a skim coat of drywall mud to create a smooth surface before adding the knockdown finish.
Get our Angi-powered app
