The owner of this company, David Harder, was recommended to us by a local seller of hardwood floor stock. We had a kitchen/dining area that was half hardwood and half linoleum and we wanted the entire floor to be hardwood. The owner made a great first impression and seemed to know a lot about wood floors. We agreed that he would cut the linoleum-covered part down to the sub-floor and replace it with the same kind of red oak, piecing it into the old floor in such a way that you couldn't tell that half of it was new. The worker who did that part of the work did a decent job and, indeed, you can't tell that the new half of the floor is newer than the old. I was also impressed that the man who installed the new floor took great care to see that everything was straight, fit tightly, etc. However, I find it inexplicable that one piece of the new floor has a staple at one end of it, right through the face of the board. I am perplexed that someone who did an otherwise good job would do that.
While the new floor installation was acceptable (except for the staple), we were not so lucky on the finishing work. The first time they finished it, there were severe brush marks in the stain across the entire floor. The floors basically looked striped perpendicularly to the direction of the seams. I asked the worker who did the stain about them while he was staining and he assured me there would be no brush marks when they were done. (This was a different person than the one who installed the floor, and the owner, David harder was nowhere to be found.) When he came back to do the polyurethane coat, I again pointed out the brush marks and he again said I wouldn't see them when it was finished.
The next morning Harder came by and I complained about the brush marks. He agreed and said he would be back the next morning to sand the floor back to the wood and refinish it himself. Although I was frustrated that the worker had ignored my earlier concerns, I was pleased with the owner for agreeing to redo the work without hesitation. He did come out the next morning, as promised. My only point of contention at that point was that he admonished me for not having called him about the stain problem in the first place. I expressed that I hired him and it's his job to send competent people and to supervise their work. If he had come out after the stain coat and before the first polyurethane coat, he would have seen the problem in time to correct it without sanding.
The next day, he came and did the work himself. I felt confident that it would be right this time because it was the owner doing it and he never hesitated to tell me how good he is. After a few more days of sanding, staining and coating, when we could finally go back into the kitchen, we were distressed to find several problems with the work. There were waves in the floor from the sander... not just the old floor that one might argue has been sanded before, but also the brand new floor that he had just installed. Harder's response was that no one can get a floor flat because the sander is so heavy.
That's nonsense, but we really couldn't face another four days of work... and there was no reason to think he'd do a better job if he did it again, since he thought this job was acceptable in the first place. Equally disturbing, there were stray brush bristles and some small debris sealed into the floor in about a dozen or so places, and there was one large spot where it looked like he had spilled the stain and never brushed it. Finally, there was bubbling in the polyurethane. Harder accepted responsibility for the bristles, but blamed me for the bubbles and debris. The room was sealed with plastic from the rest of the house and the debris was from their work, so I am amazed that he thinks that's my fault. He blamed me for the bubbles as well, because I turned the air conditioner off that evening. The work was done in the morning and the AC was on all day, but the temperatures dropped into the low 60s that night, so we did turn it off (since it wouldn't run anyway). It was dry to the touch before we did that, and we turned it back on for the entire day the next day when he put on the second coat of polyurethane. We did not cause any bubbles nor introduce any debris. The debris was clearly small pieces of wood from the floor they had cut out at the beginning of the job.
Things became quite heated, with him insisting that he be paid before fixing any of these problems, and with me refusing. He finally agreed to patch-fix the bristles and debris marks immediately and I did pay after he did that. Although I should have withheld part of the payment until I saw how it turned out when the patches dried, he was so rude and aggressive that I just wanted him out of my home. As it turned out, the places he patched look pretty bad and do not blend in with the rest of the floor, so I am now trying to decide whether to sue him for the cost of having someone else come and fix the mess he made. I note that the reviewer from Feb 20, 2012 didn't manage to collect after doing that, so I'm not sure whether it's worth it. Still, I may just have to do it as a matter of principle. I haven't decided yet.