John McClung Roofing

They replied to my email immediately. Very professional.

McClung roofing was prompt, gave a complete quote and showed up on time. They weren't the highest quote, nor the lowest. We chose this company because of their estimate details...while gathering quotes from different companies, some roofers actually gave quotes on the back of a business card, John McClung was different and was the only roofer to provide a professional estimate in clear language. The roof is new and beautiful and they left my yard clean and tidy. I would most definitely recommend this company to all.

after meeting and receiving estimate on the job, I called the contact person back to do the work, left message. He never returned the call.

Very well. I was short on time and was scheduled to have work done within the time frame I needed. The worker kept in touch with me as to any delays from another job he was working on. He was professional, cleaned up all debris. I would hire this company again for other roofing repairs.

Excellent. Responsive and honest

I have recommended them several times to friends.

.

Excellent!!

Great! My new gutters were up and the old ones were hauled off within just a couple of weeks. The gutters look marvelous and it's great to be back in the dry!

unknown

unknown

It didn't, I never heard back from them

Great job!

It went very well.  The roof looks great.   They cleaned up well and, considering the size of the job and amount of debris they had to fling off of a 2-3 story house, with very little damage to plants and shrubs.   (And I have a lot of plants and shrubs.   They actually built a plywood tepee over some of my shrubs and plants to avoid hurting them.)   I spoke mainly with Jesse, Tina, Russell, and John Paul.   They were very responsive, easy to work with and easy to communicate with.    They are what all housing contractors should strive to be.

It went very well. They did the job they said they would do.

Jesse was on time - although the company is so busy that we waited over 3 months for an appointment- pleasant, informative, familiar with tiled roofs and thorough. Many roofing companies we called did not want to tackle "an attempted fix" - that is, the old sky light leaked and now the new sky light still leaked and a couple of attempts at fixing it had failed. Jesse took off a wide circle of the heavy, concrete tiles around the sky light and spent time looking at the situation to be sure there were not multiple causes for the leak. We had had an infra red study done to prove that the leak was not coming from higher up on the roof but right at the sky light. Jesse saw that the rain channels were damaged and directing water into the sky light well-  when the tiles had been replaced. 
The flashing was replaced and extended. The tiles were replaced and Jesse took the time to tell us exactly what he had done and why. McClung roofing does NOT guarantee roof repairs - just roof replacements, but Jesse promised us that he would come back promptly if there was a further issue - and he did. He needed to come back and seal the sky light glass. The sky light had been moved and played with so much that the seal was damaged.
Part of the $1,000 fee was for a new flashing kit but still the charge for approx 2 hrs of work seemed high. However we had spent far more than that on replacing and repairing this sky light; so if this fix works it will be the best money we ever spent.

We decided to use John McClung Roofing based on a friend's recommendation and their competitive pricing.  Plus they have decent reviews on Angie's List.
After signing their contract we were told that it would be about 5 weeks before they could get to our house.  They called at 7PM one night and said they would be over in the morning to start.  At that time we had not been provided with any color options for the shingles and had to scramble and pick out a color from the Certainteed website.
A crew showed up and did a quick job of tearing off and replacing the shingles.  They did a pro job with the installation and the roof looks good.
They could have done a better job when removing the existing shingles and clean up.  They parked their dump trailer in the driveway very close to white garage doors that are only about two years old.  The doors now have many scratches, scraps, and black markings from the shingles hitting them.  Several places where the vinyl siding wraps the house were also dented and marked.  After they were finished I walked around in our driveway (which is concrete slab) and picked up 20ish nails.
When their guy showed up to collect payment, I showed him the damage to the siding and asked him about using the coupon for $100 Home Depot gift card that they are advertising on the angieslist.com website that comes with paying for a job over $3000.  He assured me that these would be taken care of.  It has been about 9 weeks now since we paid for service and we have not yet received any follow up communication from John McClung Roofing staff.

He did a great job. He is professional and fair priced.

Reliable, professional, and completed the work on time. Stayed in contact while waiting for time to complete. Fixed the leak that another contractor could not. Would call again if needed.

So for so good. We have had some heavy, wind-driven rains since the repair. I haven't had any leaking during or after those events. 
I am hopeful that my problem is at last solved. 
McClung was recommended highly by Angie's List and by my insurance agent. I was very pleased with the initial visit. The other 2 companies that came out wanted to redo 3 mistakes made by the previous company, and Randall from McClung wanted to redo 4. Even though this meant I would be spending more money, what he said made sense to me and I wanted this taken care of once and for all, so I decided to go with him. He seemed to know more than anyone else about how to flash a stone chimney. 
Once they decided to start the job (which was a full 2 months after I signed the contract--they are very busy) it went smoothly and well. They started about 8:30am and finished about 5pm. I'm a female senior citizen so I'm not about to go up on the roof and look the job over. But from the ground I could see that the area around the bottom of the chimney was visibly changed. For the first time in 3 years, it looked to me like chimney flashing should look. The crew obligingly took my suggestion that we should run my hose up on the roof and see if we could see any water coming into the attic. 
Fingers crossed--I think they did a good job! 

Addendum: Regarding the situation with the gutter installation discussed below, two days after this review was posted, a gutter crew came to the house and completed the cleanout of debris and installation of the box gutter and gutter guards. They presented me with an invoice showing that the gutter job had been done at no cost and offered an apology on behalf of the gutter supervisor. While the facts as I have related them are true, I must add that ultimately the company did respond to my concerns, made the situation right and completed the job. This speaks to their professionalism and their concern for customer satisfaction. My thanks to them.

OK, here's the deal. The contract was for roof replacement, installation of gutters and installation of gutter guards. The house is an A-frame with parts that have a very steep pitch, and a part that has a more normal pitch. The scheduler kept calling a wrong number, and as a result, on the day of installation, called at 8 AM to give me thirty minutes' warning that the roofing crew was on its way. I have total respect for that crew.  They were all locals and they had a positive attitude.  No swearing was allowed despite the difficulty of the job. There were a few details left to be worked out at the end of the job, but those were promptly corrected.  They left the site cleaner than it was when they arrived. Great looking new roof, with a lifetime guarantee, they are great. I recommend the roofing department of John McClung without reservation.
However, there were some difficulties.  One is that half an hour after the crew pulled out, I got a call asking to "negotiate" an extra $1200 in the price because there had been more labor cost than they anticipated and they had to use longer nails. I could understand an upcharge if there had been undiscovered rot or they had to replace decking, something like that,  but this was basically a matter of they didn't estimate correctly and they wanted to make it up at the end, without warning me that this was coming. We managed to settle for a lesser amount but if you are concerned that the contract price might not end up being the actual price, you'd be right to worry. Some of the other roofing companies that I interviewed had clauses in their contracts that defined when an upcharge would be added, but this one did not. So buyer beware.
But the worst part of the story is the gutter job. The roof was completed on October 28 and the gutters were to come shortly afterward. The first install date was to be November 2, but they didn't show.  Afterward a series of no shows, calls offering excuses and explanations, rescheduling and more no shows. On November 14 (a Saturday) they showed up and put up most of the gutters and downspouts but no gutter guards. They were going to come the following Monday to finish, but again, no show. I called asking what was going on and was assured I would receive a call from the gutter supervisor, but he never called. Thanksgiving came and went and I wrote a letter essentially detailing the problem and asking them to either finish the job or declare that they would not finish it so that I could hire somebody else. About a week later a crew showed up at 4:20 in the afternoon, put up a ladder and started cleaning out the debris from the gutters but they declared that they didn't have the tools they needed and they left. Again they were supposed to come back on Monday, followed by more no shows, explanations, rescheduling and no-shows. We are now at December 13 and the gutters still have no gutter guards, and one section has a gutter lying on the ground, uninstalled. The gutters have debris in them. I have no clue when they are coming to finish, or indeed, if they are.  I certainly believe that John McClung Roofing is as perfectly capable of timely and professionally installing gutters as they are of doing a great roofing job on a difficult roof, but as of today I don't have the job complete, there is no date scheduled for the job to be completed, and this gutter situation is a complete fail, beyond the fact that there are some unprotected, debris-filled gutters on most of the house. I've been patient and cooperative.  I put my concerns in writing, so none of this should come as a surprise to the folks at John McClung, but all to little avail. Perhaps tomorrow I'll be pleasantly surprised and this will all be a bad memory, but right now I'm feeling pretty disappointed.

unknown

All work was done as promised when promised. No problems.

Provided excellent work, on time. Very courteous and professional.

Project took a long time to start as they are very busy. So about 2 month wait after committing.  Took 4 days. They did a nice job. They recycle the old shingles by taking them to a place that makes them into asphalt for roads. I installed two sun tunnels to try to brighten up the house during the day, I would have preferred that someone would point out to me that the location of the top outlet affects how bright the light is coming through, so one is bright and one not so much as I put the outlets as high on the roof as possible not realizing.  They used a magnet to find the dropped screws. They were punctual and polite. The roof is awesome and I am excited for it to rain. I used the color aged copper, so it is a light green color.