Not well. 3 things were proposed and discussed that would solve the issue for a cost of $875, with a down-payment of $290. 1. Gutter: I interpreted my discussion with Mr. Ray as indicating that the front gutter needed to be rehung, a reasonable action in light of the problem. The agreement I signed, however, did not so state but instead stated "refastening existing gutter.” I interpreted that as rehanging since one could not refasten without first unfastening. That I was expecting the gutters to be rehung was clear from my inquiry: I accept the terms of the proposal. I assume, although it is not documented, that when you replace the gutters that you will also caulk the miter joints. Response: Yes, any dismantled gutter components will be re-caulked (i.e., end caps). Notably, instead of clarifying any existing misconception on my part prior to the work being done, my comment re replacing the gutters was not addressed. My illusion continued when the worker, Chris, showed up alone. I questioned how he could accomplish this by himself. His response “I plan on being here most of the day”. I accept full responsibility for signing an agreement that did not precisely state what I expected to be done but I also feel that my interpretation was based on several incidences that could have easily been corrected. What was done was to install two screws to re-attach the gutter at the site of separation. 2. Drip-edge: The proposal included installing a new drip-edge. When I asked “I don’t have one?” the response was he don’t know because the gutter guards prevented that determination, and he would send someone out to check. Instead of focusing on the fact that they enhanced the cost of the project by proposing a “fix” that I may or may not have needed, I was impressed that they were going back to check. In retrospect, that was probably not the best move. After Chris had been working for about 45 min, I went out to tell him I was going to run a quick errand and would be back to observe what he was doing since he was going to be there most of the day. It was then I saw him ripping out my existing drip edge. Before I said a word, he grinned widely, stating “now it will be white instead of brown” I was too startled, and pressed to do my errand, that I just left. When I returned, Chris was gone. Apparently “most of the day” is about 1 1/2 hr. 3. I was also informed that the shingles did not extend sufficiently over the gutter guards. Thus I inferred from the statement in the agreement that any new shingles used will match as closely as possible as meaning that they will address this issue. That this was a “major problem” leading to the dripping of water behind the gutter was confirmed by Chris when he arrived to work on the gutter. As Chris was not at the house when I returned I did not see him install the drip-edge or the new shingles. Given the gutter guards were in place I couldn’t tell if he did the former, but I could definitely say that no new shingles were added to fix the “major problem”. My concerns were addressed to Mr. Ray who sent another crew to my home. When Scott arrived, I requested that he determine if they actually fixed the problem I hired them to fix by demonstrating that the gutters were functioning correctly. So I handed him a hose. Scott went onto the roof, sprayed the roof and quickly ascertained that the gutters weren’t draining. One down-spot was clogged, allowing water to pool at the location above the bay window. Clearly, no one had actually done this simple task to correctly diagnose the problem to begin with. Thus none of what was proposed actually addressed the problem and with the next rain I would have been in the same situation but $875 poorer. I then asked them to confirm that Chris had not just ripped out my existing drip-edge but had put in a new one. Scott said it was there. I then questioned the need for new shingles to extend further over the gutter guards. He confirmed that none were added but indicated that they weren’t necessary since what was there was sufficient. Mr. Ray did nullify the remaining $ due on the agreement and I’m sure he felt that was generous, particularly since Chris told him that he had removed only 6 ft of existing drip edge in the front of the house. Sadly that too was not true. So cleaning the downspout and two screws to reattach the gutter only cost me $290. Here’s what I learned, which you all probably already know: Before you hire someone to fix a problem, know the cause of the problem and don’t assume someone else will make the correct diagnosis. Alternatively, ask how they made their diagnosis. Be very careful of the wording of any agreement you sign: things spelled out in sufficient detail to assure that anyone would know what is being done is what you are expecting. Pay as you go and don’t pre-pay anything, With respect to Richard’s roofing, Mr. Ray did attempt to resolve the problems, and the individual he sent over to do so, Scott, was very professional, capable and a good representative of the company. My preference would have been to not have those problems in the first place.