Got bids from 4 of the top roofers on Angies, to replace the roof on our Mira Mesa asphalt shingle roof. This selection was based on number of years in business, review grade, and content of reviews.
Excluding one, the bids were fairly close but what made Weather Master Roofing (WMR) stand out was the fact the owner (Chris) was actually in the crew, doing the job. It is difficult to impress how significant this is. i have worked with roofing crews a few summers in my youth, so i had some idea what i was getting into.
Contacted WMR and agreed on a time to start. Of course everyone else in this town seemed to be wanting a new roof at the same time; i was told by someone that Feb. is the start of "roofing's" busiest season. Fortunately we had no leaks i was aware of but i didn't need any professional roofer to tell me the shingles on the original part of the house were "shot." i nervously watched the weather forecasts.
We had to delay the actual start by a day, as they found more roof repairs than expected with the previous job. Life is like roofing, ... you never know what you are going to find til you take up the shingles. This delay was no big deal.
The crew showed up bright and early as planned. With a crew of 12, they attacked our shingles like a whirlwind. It sounded like what I imagine a herd of buffalo on the roof would sound. i could clearly hear grit and debris falling onto the sheetrock ceiling, in attic areas where there is no insulation. (The garage looked like it rained grit, but Chris and half his crew warned me about this repeatedly up to the start of the roof removal - asking if anything needed to be covered.) Starting at 7am, they had the entire roof denuded of shingles by 11am! There were numerous layers of shingles (easily over an inch thick) on top of 3/8-ths plywood. (i had to cut an opening in the old original part of the roof for access into one of the roof additions. i am saving one of these pieces, as my Dad does not believe anyone would use 3/8ths ply or re-roof that many layers of shingles.) Once all this stuff was removed, i imagine the house lifted a little.
Roofing materials were delivered directly from the supplier - shingles, underlayment, torch-down material, whirlygig-vents, etc. It was obvious there was not going to be any salvaged material sold to me as new.
Approximately half the original crew left and went to another roof removal. Chris and his remaining crew immediately started fixing improperly-installed/dangerous areas of plywood ? corner areas of the plywood where the edge did not land on the top of a rafter-truss. It is very fortunate nobody stepped on any of these areas during the roof removal.
From teh start to the finish, they were very careful to get all the debris up (esp. nails). Heard the owner coaching a new employee, in which he explained that his philosophy was to clean as you go, rather than save everything til the end, when you are tired. Someone walked the perimeter of the house repeatedly while the removal was in progress and at the end.
Early the next morning Chris and crew returned. In this house, there have been 2 or 3 roof modifications, resulting in a valley (picture an "M"). The previous owner had problems with leaks in this area so this area was of particular interest to me. Chris and his right-hand-man(?) focused on what i call the "V" of the "M". The previous owner had what is called a "cricket" built to address the leaking. This low pitch platform is apparently a common solution for this type problem. In this instance, as Chris said, it appeared that they started with a plan but once they neared the end, didn't know how to finish it. All this old "cricket" was torn out and a gradual sloping incline put in its place all the way to the edge of the roof. I was paying particular attention to this ?cricket,? and Chris accommodated several of my requests (ex.: replacing some of the plywood, additional blocking support).
Once this platform was in place, his right-hand-man installed what they called ?torch-down.? This was a multi-layer system of rolled rubber type material, covered by another rolled tar/rubber material with grit embedded on the top side. The guy putting this stuff down was clearly an expert. He made it all look easy, as without hesitation he knew just where to cut the seams, perforations and creases and then rejoin them with his ?wand-flamer? to create a continuous 3-sided ?pan? with the thick rubber. He then repeated the process with the rolled grit. This torch-down material doesn?t last as long as the shingles but am confident it was installed as well as can be.
While I was watching the ?torch-down,? Chris and his crew were replacing damaged wood (mostly along the eaves), installing underlayment, and the like. By the end of the afternoon the entire roof was covered with the Corning underlayment (this is much better stuff than the 30 pound tar paper used in my youth). At this point i breathed a sigh of relief, knowing we were protected from any light rain.
In the following days, the new whirly-gigs, shingles, drip-edge, etc. went on the roof. My attention then went to the skylights - I was very pleased with the attention to detail given the flashing for these (3x). Though the skylights are currently ok, Chris told me what to look for as they get older (hairline cracks in the corners).
They also put a rolled rubber material with adhesive on one side, in all the valleys. Apparently this is not the norm. in this area and is an added expense. This is something we use on the East coast where it rains a lot. Chris spoke very highly of the material during the installation, saying if one were to cover the entire roof with it, you wouldn?t need to bother with the roof again.
When the job was complete, Chris asked me if I wanted to keep the unused material or have him take it off my hands. This was unusual in that most trades we used in the remodel (ex. Tile), kept any unused materials without asking.
Everything was completed about 4 days before the rains. We got several significant rains, and when possible I went into the attic spaces and looked for leaks. No leaks were to be found but am confident if there ever were a problem, Chris would attend to it without hesitation.
Weather Master Roofing (Chris and his crew) were very professional, quality oriented, cleaned up well, respected my property, and did an excellent job. A quality job was my core concern but as an added benefit, they were reasonably priced. I would not hesitate to call them when I have any roofing needs or suggest them to others.