In the beginning.....
I had had a minor leak that I spent an embarrassing amount of time trying to find so I finally called in roofers.
-- CALLING AND GETTING ESTIMATORS TO VISIT --
I received quotes from 4 companies, generally based on Angie's List reports and proximity. Generally the owner himself would come and I was impressed by 3 of the 4 companies. (a 5th never called back).
BUT Steve, the owner of AGL, really blew me away. Coincidentally he showed up last (due to my scheduling not his) so I already had 2 quotes in hand, and 1 idea of one estimate 'getting processed in an office'.
Steve had the lowest estimated price of any of the 2 "quotes" as well as the 'getting-processed-in-office' estimate. I use"quotes" in quotation marks here because none actually look like any sort of formal quote. Steve's numbers were the lowest, as I already said, but I'm definitely NOT just looking at numbers when I'm choosing a roofer (nor am I rich though!)
The main thing about Steve was that he showed he really wanted to make a quality, long lasting roof for my home. The difference with Steve was that when we went up on the roof, he immediately pointed out two drainage problems (the main valley and above the entry way):
Main Valley: I knew of the problem with water sitting in the valley but figured a new roof would automatically fix it. Steve had other options in mind. At no time did he seem overpressuring but he had a great and creative idea to convert the valley into a built up "Cricket" where there is a peak in the center point of what used to be the valley and then 50% of the water goes each way. To me it sounded much better than having the water run along a re-covered version of the VERY GENTLE slope I already had. In the gentle slope existing case, some water goes as far as 90-95% of the length of the valley to get to the drop out. Some of it never makes it off and just sits there. As for the "Cricket", he said he'd build it up with plywood, use two layers (X2) of APP-TorchDown and integrate it physically and aesthetically ("Charcoal") with the shingles. He recommended two layers of TorchDown because each layer lasts about 10 years and the surrounding shingles would have a lifetime warranty. That way I might get 20 years before having to replace the TorchDown in a possibly tricky process.
Above the Entry Way: Above the entry way was just some old flat roof. There had not been rain for weeks but I could still tell that small amounts of water were getting stuck on this part of the roof. There was practically no slope towards the front gutter so Steve had the idea to build, again with plywood, a gentle slope just steep enough to get the water off that section. He covered it with APP-TorchDown (X2) and used a color matching the new "Charcoal" shingles (just like with the "Cricket"). I must note that they were very careful along the edges to make sure water would not go anywhere it shouln't.
The last big thing was what to do with the flat roof'ed addition to the rear of the house. Many of the estimators walked on it and I asked if I'd like it done but only Steve pointed out the bubbles that were forming from sitting water. He said the flat roof needed to go. In order to save money, I went with just (X1) of TorchDown and just normal gray color. Steve pointed out that since I have some nice looking stained open bears in that read addition to the house, that it's imperitive I replace the flat roof there before water gets into those beams. If water damage occured, it would be unlikely that I would be able to re-create the stain.
To summarize, none of the other estimators had the idea of making the "Cricket', nor sloping the section above the front door, NOR did any emphasize the importance of getting the rear flat roof done ASAP.
When all the math worked out, I was getting the same price as the second-lowest cost guy - and that guy was NOT going to do any of the three above things though.
I was already very happy with Steve's performance. We then went inside and he gave me a rather large packet full of too much info to list here. He had proof of insurance, 10s of reference letters, a 4-5 page listing of local addresses for roofs he's done. It also had some tips from local governments about how to pick the right roofer,tips to prep before roofing, etc. It had more that applied to roofing in general and not just AGL. He gave the packet to me to keep regardless of whether I choose to go with AGL. He gave me a rough estimate and mailed me (from Torrance) a detailed, ready to sign, contract the NEXT DAY. I made a few changes and then they sent me a new and accurate (regarding my requests) contract within 2 days. At this point, the other roofers were all but out of my mind. Their quotes came later than Steve's, were vague, lacked details, and asked for more MONEY than AGL. So, I went with Steve and AGL.
--- ACTUALLY ROOFING ---
We planned to start on Wednesday (1/4) but I got a call a couple days earlier offering to start on Tuesday (1/3). That was great for me so I agreed. They estimated 3 days but they were done by late Thursday (1/5). ONLY TWO DAYS! Generally that would make me nervous but I was able to be at home for most of the time they were working. They were very nice and never asked for anything (although I offered the facilities, water, ice). They worked extremely quickly but were meticulous and clean. I found one nail on the concrete in the back which would have been bad for the my dog. They said they ran metal detector over the grass and I believe them. This nail was off the the grass and in the crack, hard to see with just your eye. There was some shingle and other roofing debris in the gutters that I cleaned out after they left. Also, I saved some money by asking them not to prime any of the new wood. I took care of that myself last weekend without issue. The AGL team was fast! A little bit more wood (especially fascia) needed to be replace than I expected so the total cost went up by ~$400. My home had been infested with termites when I bought it so I was relieved in a way that more wood did not need to be replaced! Now I kind of want to replace all the fascia since the new boards look soo much better than the old, but that's another job....
Prior to them arriving....
I coved up vents and A/C units, took things down off walls, etc like AGL's supplied paperwork suggested and ended up with no problems except for a little bit of junk in the gutters. I'm sure there was already quite a bit of junk in there so I don't fault AGL much for that.
I would recommend AGL to anyone I know within their service area. Whoever's reading this, AT LEAST ask Steve to come take a look at your existing roof before going with ANYONE else. You might get a couple good ideas from him but, more than, likely, you'll change plans and go with AGL!!!
-- UPDATE AFTER "STORM" (1/25) --
The roof looks the same (which is excellent BTW) after the storm as it did before. That's a good indicator. Also, there were no leaks in the attic! I can now repurpose the buckets and blankets I had up the for other things.
Overall, thanks Steve, and thanks AGL
---A VERY HAPPY CUSTOMER