Our initial correspondence went well. I was happy that they could service our area same day. I provided 3 pictures to David via text to minimize surprises for both of us (which I've attached). I was concerned about both cost and providing enough info to plan for parts. When I called later that afternoon to confirm whether or not the pictures were received, he seemed to have an idea that it was a problem with a relief valve. Someone arrived on time - it wasn't the same person with which I spoke to but one of his workers. I found it slightly odd that he had a lady friend with him. I later came to understand that this was his wife, they work for the same company. They ride-share because they live close by and this was his last call of the day. This is relevant info because he seemed to be in a hurry while she was waiting in a hot vehicle. He looked briefly at the leak and I thought it was because he seemed to understand what the problem was. I thought some communication may have taken place and that this was a common problem. However (as we discovered later ourselves - the leak came down to a washer in the old valve). I expected a quote. Instead he asked us if we had the replacement part, which caught me off guard. I thought maybe this wasn't a part they normally carry so my dad went to a nearby Ace hardware on the plumber's instruction. Once my dad got back with the part the plumber it took about twenty minutes to turn off the water, dig a hole around the existing valve (with our shovel) and put on a new valve. Before he cleaned up he wrote out a bill for $250. He was there for a total of 45 minutes and 20 of those minutes were spent waiting while my dad went to get a part. I asked him why it came to that amount. He said he didn't make the prices but I could call the office. I did. I asked why, when we supplied the part they were charging us that much for 20 minutes of work? Without telling me why, dave offered to lower it to $150. Assuming that the problem was fixed, (even with the oddities) I thought this was fair. They came out to my area the same day and were punctual. After I paid over the phone, the plumber packed up his truck, explained that the water needed to stay off for 20 minutes while the glue dried but that he would be back to turn it on since he lived nearby. Again - very much hurried and a little odd. He didn't even clean up. PVC pipe scraps were left and the hole he dug not filled in. Before letting him go, my dad asked him how to turn on the water. It was reasonable at this point to assume from the other odd behaviors that he might not return so we wanted to know. I was still at this point assuming the repair was thorough and complete, however. We discovered in the following day that it was still leaking. We thought about our options and . examined the old part. That's when we discovered it came down to a bad washer in the original valve. We were wondering why this was not caught by someone who is supposed to be professional. We decided to contact the company via email and explain the situation from our point of view. At first we didn't say anything about the money we paid them. They asked if they could come out and redo it. The only thing they had going for them at this point was that originally they were able to come out the same day and that they were punctual. Everything else (the quality of their work, the professionalism of the person performing the job, the experience with the quote and calling about the price) was sub par. We chose not to let them come back based on these things and instead asked for a refund. He offered us 50% back. I asked him, since the total of the cost was for labor (we supplied the parts), what his reasons were for keeping the other 50%? He did not answer the question but said (and I'm quoting from his email) "your request is denied. Again you did not give us a chance to make things right, this is normal and correct in business. You will receive a $50 discount as offered. This matter is closed and no return and answer is required." (I've attached the emails). I don't think we owe him an opportunity to come back to our residence and redo the repair when our experience led us to believe we couldn't trust them to diagnose the problem, do good work, or be straight when it comes to the cost. We're giving him an opportunity to rectify the problem, but not by working on our home further - by refund. (I've attached emails) In summary, We all hire professionals because of their knowledge and experience, and because they can usually do the job much faster. We were competent enough to do the job (and as it turns out had to) but it took us longer. I paid $150 for a job that we had to redo ourselves, my dad paid $30 for a new part that didn’t need to be replaced. The worker was in a hurry, was unprofessional, left a mess for us to clean up. It’s my opinion that none of that money needed to be spent and $180 is not an insignificant amount for us.