Response from Gentle Giant Moving & Storage Somerville
This review is confusing and suspicious. You only rated us on price and responsiveness. You gave us a D for price and A for responsiveness. I have no idea how those add up to an F. What I find to be extremely suspicious and frustrating is your review of our competitor, Marathon moving. The price you list for them is $600 more than the estimate we gave you which you explicitly stated was "way too high." You also gave that company a better score on price even though they were more expensive. The job in question took place in 2011 so the timing of your review also raises my suspicion. There has to be a reason you decided, out of the blue, to review a company that you called two years ago and have never hired. If we had been rude on the phone or if your grading scale had any sort of consistency than this poorly-graded review would be easier to accept, but it's frustrating because your grading scale is inconsistently applied between companies and unfairly hurts our business and the reputation of Angie's List. Review sites are only as good as their members and they reviews they post. People pay money to be Angie's List members because AL provides better-vetted reviews than some of their well-known competitors. When Angie's List becomes a haven for erroneously written reviews with illogical extremely subjective grades, the reliability of the entire system suffers. If Angie's List becomes a place where business use reviews to help themselves or hurt competitors, member confidence will decline. While it is extremely frustrating to the victim of a review like this, it happens a regularly and we've learned to accept it on sites like Yelp and Google+. Fortunately, Angie's List is not the same hotbed for that kind of activity. I'm not 100% certain that your review was malicious but the timing of the review, the reasons stated for your grades, the C + A = F math in your review of us, and the different criteria you used when judging us and our competitor gives me definite pause. As you know, many consumers use Angie's List to find quality service providers to whom they can entrust their home and possessions. When you go out of your way to slander a company on Angie's List you are going to steer traffic away from their page and take real money out of their employees' wallets. If the company in question had actually done something to deserve a low score, than by all means, a review should reflect that. That is what Angie's List members pay for: the truth. If members start deciding that they can no longer trust the fellow reviewers, whether that is due to competitive gaming of the system or an overabundance of erroneous and inconsistent reviews and grades, than the whole system falls apart. Of course, I could be misunderstanding the whole thing. If there is a logical explanation behind your grading system where $5,000 is "way to expensive" and $5,600 is not, I would love to hear it. I would also love to hear how a D for price,combined with an A for responsiveness could equal an F on total score. The only explanation provided in your review was "estimate way to high...did not hire" In fact, that is the entirety of your review. As a fellow Angie's List subscriber, that review is not very helpful at all. As an employee of Gentle Giant, it is extremely frustrating and borderline insulting that you can so dismissively hurt my company's bottom line without a clear explanation behind the reasons why. In fact, the only company you review in any detail is the family business with whom you share a last name. I apologize for the lengthy reply. Feel free to reach out with any questions or comments. I'm happy that your move went well, with or without our company and wish you all the best in your "new" home.