Steffey Insurance Agency

Founded 1981 • With Angi since October 2008

We have been providing insurance services to Central Indiana for over 30 years. Our agency started in Greenwood, Indiana and now has a main office at Keystone at the Crossing on the Northside of Indianapolis. We are an agressive market for personal lines and commercial lines business in Indiana, Illinois, Ohio, Pennsylvania,Tennessee and Mississippi. We are experts in Condominium Association Insurance and also write life and health insurance. We can also offer retirement planning such as IRA's, Long-Term Care, 401k plans, and annuities.


Free Estimates
Eco-Friendly Accreditations
This pro has not provided any licensing information to Angi at this time.All statements concerning insurance, licenses, and bonds are informational only, and are self-reported. Since insurance, licenses and bonds can expire and can be cancelled, homeowners should always check such information for themselves. To find more licensing information for your state, visit our Find Licensing Requirements page. Contact pro for more details.

Verified Reviews


(3) Verified Reviews

Showing 1-3 of 3 reviews
Phillip P.
Description of Work
We did end up changing our condo insurance to Steffey. They were significantly lower in price than our previous carrier. This was for the entire condo complexes property insurance.
insurance companies
I have gotten great service and very affordable prices.
Description of Work
I have my home and car insured with them.
insurance companies
We worked with Julie Dunne and Mike Steffey who were both very professional and friendly. They got us the best deal, and they were very diligent about getting us the best deal. They are an independent agency so they are able to find the best deal with all of the companies that they represent. My entire family uses Steffey.
Description of Work
Supplied us with life, auto (including classic auto) home, landlord, and catastrophic liability insurance.
insurance companies



8365 Keystone Crossing Suite 202

Indianapolis, IN 46240

Service Categories

Insurance Agencies
Financial Planning

Other Information

Services offered

Business insurance, personal insurance, health insurance, life insurance, group insurance & retirement plans.

Payment options

American Express
Financing Available


Steffey Insurance Agency is currently rated 5 overall out of 5.

Steffey Insurance Agency is open:

Monday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Tuesday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Wednesday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Thursday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Friday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Steffey Insurance Agency accepts the following forms of payment: Check, Visa, MasterCard, American Express, Financing Available

Yes, Steffey Insurance Agency offers free project estimates.

No, Steffey Insurance Agency does not offer eco-friendly accreditations.

No, Steffey Insurance Agency does not offer warranties.

Steffey Insurance Agency offers the following services: Business insurance, personal insurance, health insurance, life insurance, group insurance & retirement plans.

Other Local Pros In Your Area




Angi Certified

Offers Coupon


We offer our services NATIONWIDE. Our passion is partnering with our clients to crystallize their financial goals, design a strategy to achieve those goals and execute the plan to its completion. You know it’s not enough to just make a plan, even the most well designed strategies can fail if not executed properly and then monitored for progress and suitability. This is why we consistently monitor the progress of your plan and make changes as new developments come to light with your changing goals. Whether we are helping a young family set the path to achieve their ideal lifestyle and first home; assisting a newly widowed client in navigating and structuring his/or her retirement plan and new life; or advising a professional couple on structuring the sale of their business and transitioning into retirement, we are consistently behind the scenes working to get you there and keep you there: on track. Our Core Competencies include: Financial Planning, Wealth Management, Risk Management, Estate Planning and Multi-Generational Asset Transfer Planning, Managing Executive Deferred Comp Assets. We use the latest and the most sophisticated tools to produce accurate and realistic analyses. We pride ourselves on our independence and ability to work with the leading experts in all fields of wealth management, accounting and estate planning to design a comprehensive and robust strategy to achieve our clients’ goals. Sovereign is affiliated with Spire Investment Partners. Spire Investment Partners is the Parent Company of Spire Wealth Management, LLC an SEC RIA, and Spire Securities LLC, a registered Broker/Dealer and Member of FINRA / SIPC.  

I focus on people in or near retirement, who want to reduce risk and taxes. UpperLeft Wealth Management is here for anyone planning for and trying to figure out if they're on pace for retirement, or are looking for investment management, advice on social security, home mortgages, taxes in retirement, or other financial questions. Our data-driven processes and strategic planning mean we help you face the curveballs life can throw at you. I am a CFP® and fiduciary, and hold an M.B.A. in finance from Columbia Business School. My reputation is built on your trust. If you're ready to look at improving your odds of success, contact me at