Bad from the start. Took weeks for Reuben to discuss when he was going to come. Then he subcontracts the job. The sub did a terrible job, only min of ice/water shield, exposed nail, wrong heater vent not to code, First rain there was rain drips completely around my chimney. They didnt use metal flash around chimney, just "green" chaulk, Yes I said it - Green. I had to sue him in his some town for the cost of repairing his work around the chimey. I used the money to hire another contractor do flash the chimney correctly. If was a mistake dealing with Reuben after the first time he didnt show on the date he promised to start the project.