Indianapolis Fireplace Remodel

Compare quotes from top fireplace companies

Get quotes from professionals in your area!

Reviews in Indianapolis to Remodel Fireplace

Godby Hearth & Home
4.0
Godby Hearth & Home have an excellent selection of fireplaces, mantels, fireplace doors and all fireplace accessories, the best in the City we felt. Their showroom is impressive and they maintain books of pictures showing varieties of fireplaces. They were helpful and understood completely when we backed off additional fireplace remodel work, after discovering this type of work is relatively expensive; we were considering a more extensive remodel, but for now decided to stay with new fireplace doors only. It did take two separate visits to get the measurements right and we wish the fireplace door samples available (colors, materials) had been larger to make our decision with, but overall we are very satisfied with the end result. We hope to replace the mantel next year and will feel comfortable dealing with Godby again.
- Gayle S....
Workman Services, LLC
5.0
Replaced leaking chimney cap, chinked missing mortar on chimney, replaced rotted siding on back of chimney, replaced rotted decking and joists under the firebox, upgraded wood firebox to gas including installing gas line for the firebox and kitchen stove and finally removed old tile facing to fireplace and replaced it with granite. The quote was comprehensive and the detail convinced me that his company would provide superior execution versus two competitors whose bids were respectively higher and lower. This was a job that involved multiple trades (plumbing, chimney, tile/granite, structural framing, finish carpentry and drywall) so a competent G.C. was a must and Kurt delivered on that. The sequencing and execution of the job met promise dates. The one dim spot was the granite subcontractor who was a bit difficult to work with but Kurt immediately intervened when needed including showing up at my house within 30 minutes of calling him during the install to make sure it was executed correctly; on his day off no less. The final quality of the job was top notch. The exterior siding was thicker and better sealed than the original, the masonry was in better shape than when it was originally constructed and finally the fireplace looks clean and modern. I would definitely hire Workman Services again.
- Chris W....
Godby Hearth & Home
5.0
We did purchase a new fireplace screen. Technician came out and made a template of the opening. The actual screen fit perfectly.
- Ann H....
Home Experts
5.0
They did a great job. This was an old fireplace mantel that had 3 different pieces. They first came out to assess the job and gave me a quote and scheduled me for the following week. The gentleman that showed up to do the work made sure that I was happy with the job and even caulked part of the mantel and made sure and cleaned up the mess he had made.
- Tamara K....
STEVE SCULLY FIREPLACE REPAIR, LLC
5.0
My husband called Steve Scully and spoke to his wife on the phone. He explained what we needed and unfortunately they did not offer exactly what we needed, but she discussed many options and was extremely helpful, even though we were not able to hire them. She even recommended someone who could do the service we needed. My husband was very impressed. Hope we can use them in the future!
- Katherine L....
Godby Hearth & Home
5.0
I contacted Godby Hearth and Home to purchse a new fireplace insert. My old insert was not reliable and therefore I had not used it in several years. I have an underground propane tank in my back yard. I first searched Angie's List, found the company and gave them a call. The person who responded was quite helpful, asked appropriate questions, and advised me to come to the showroom and see the inserts for myself. I did so and went with a modern lookkiing ventless model. If I hadn't gone to the showroom I'm not sure I would have known that such a choice was available. The company also honored the Angie's List discount. I placed the order on Jan 16 and the insert was installed Jan 30. However, gas wasn't getting to the insert. The tech waited while I called the propane company, talked to a man from the company, tried a few different things but the result was the propane company rep need to come out (the problem was a faulty regulator). Once gas was getting the the insert a rep from Godbys calledme to walk me through the prcess of igniting the insert (this was at 6pm so he would be sure I was home and in front of the insert). Unfortunately I had a little difficuty following his directions and he immediately offered to send the tech out on a day and Time convenient to me to show me how the system operated. The tech came out yesterday, walked me through the process and I'm now good to go.
- Joyce M....
Booher Remodeling Co
5.0
Booher was on time, great prices, made us love the remodeling process after several bad experiences with other companies.
- Brian W....
Godby Hearth & Home
5.0
The whole team at Godby was outstanding - followed through on everything they promised. Professional and engaging staff that came to the house to do the work. We love our new fireplace!
- Leah F....
YOUR CHIMNEY SWEEP INC
5.0
Joe was very friendly and arrived on time. He completed the inspection, showed me how to work the fireplace, gave me tips and replaced the screen. He was very friendly and patient with my dogs as well as with me.
- Kirstin W....
Godby Hearth & Home
5.0
The work crew showed up exactly when they said they would and quickly got to work. They came and ripped out the old unit which had never worked from when we bought our house, and we had to wait a few weeks for them to install the new one, which was a little h****** my young children. But once they came in and installed the new one and made it so it was operational it is better then we had hoped!! I personally had never owned a fireplace in my previous residences, but family and friends who had have loved it and compliment it all the time!
- Brian W....
Godby Hearth & Home
5.0
Excellent experience overall. They explained what I needed to know about gas logs, fireplace doors, and the pros and cons and of vented versus unvented. In choosing fireplace doors, they assisted me in making a choice that, when installed, was absolutely perfect. Appointments were scheduled at a time that was convenient for me, and the measurer and installer were both prompt and efficient. The installer explained how everything worked and answered all my questions. Everyone I worked with was customer service oriented and very professional. I would recommend Godby to anyone interested in installing a gas fireplace.
- Becky B....
Randy King
5.0
It went well. I ran out of materials when the job was 95% complete and have ordered materials and they have now arrived. I have requested that Randy return to finish the job and that is scheduled for next. week..
- David C....
Godby Hearth & Home
5.0
Service tech very knowledgeable, comprehensive job done; took time to call manufacturer for me to check on an issue; Owner also came out to quote me and was very knowledgeable and gave me options versus pushing a particular higher margin product. Excellent establishment and employees.
- Fiona D....
Brick + Ember Outfitters
5.0
I had some issues with installation and initially was dissatisfied with my insert functioning however the chimney staff came back out - made some adjustments at no additional cost to me and now my fireplace is working well! For the first time I am looking forward to the winter as my home will be nice and cozy with my new fireplace. The staff was so great!
- Marianne B....
STEVE SCULLY FIREPLACE REPAIR, LLC
5.0
Visited shop on a Saturday, very knowledgeable staff, arranged for estimate on Monday, arrived promptly, estimate was within my desired range, came to install fireplace insert on Friday, again arrived on time, minor problem during install that was remedied quickly and to our satisfaction, excellent quality product and service, absolutely love our new fireplace insert and have used it constantly ever since. Using less than 1/2 the natural gas ever since insert was installed.
- Larry M....

Remodel Fireplace in Indianapolis

4.9

(79)

Indianapolis, IN

Recent Review: The fireplace now fully lights but the fan still does not come on.
5.0

(60)

Indianapolis, IN

Angi Certified
Offers Coupon
Recent Review: Did a great job cleaning the two fireplaces and explaining what all was done. Was fast and thorough.
5.0

(19)

Zionsville, IN

Recent Review: Due to lack of foresight on our part, we were looking for someone to complete the project in just over a week’s time. Contacted 3 companies on Angie’s list explaining our needs and John from JEB was the only one to even call back (which he did quickly!). I believe the others might have considered it too small of a job for the hassle of getting in & out quickly. There is no doubt that John is a busy man, but he was able to adjust his schedule to help us out. He showed up on time (and even early!) both days. He worked full days with few breaks and got it done in a day and a half. He even took extra time because he recognized that the intricate pattern in the tile I chose would look best if he laid it in consideration of the laundry room entrance-which meant more work for him. I certainly wouldn’t have thought of that, but he obviously has the experience and the artist’s touch to do the job with superb attention to detail as well as excellent workmanship. We were very happy with him and look forward to inviting him back when we are ready for the larger projects we have planned.
4.9

(143)

Indianapolis, IN

Recent Review: It went mostly well. Super happy with the customer service. I was very taken care of. Trustworthy.
4.4

(52)

Indianapolis, IN

Recent Review: Bill from Duncan's was great! He was on time, made sure that we knew what knew what he was doing and did it lightning fast! The guys were very courteous even attempting to take off their shoes when they entered the house. After they finished cleaning the fireplace, I walked past and thought that the glass hadn't been replaced it was THAT clean! Great job. Would recommend them to all. Would use them again!
4.9

(43)

Indianapolis, IN

Recent Review: The end product is perfect. Exactly what I had envisioned.
5.0

(33)

Sheridan, IN

Angi Certified
Recent Review: Great. Jim was a pleasure to work with. He got back to me the same day that I left a message. I sent him photos of the post and he gave me an estimate which was accurate. He showed up on time. The work quality was excellent and he cleaned up his mess. I also appreciated that I didn’t have to continually track him down to find out when he would be out. He gave me an estimated time frame and followed up with me to confirm. Would use again!
5.0

(9)

Indianapolis, IN

Recent Review: Everything went perfect!!!!! They were very professional, knowledgeable, and friendly. They did a very thorough job cleaning and inspecting our gas fireplace. Will definitely use them for future cleanings and inspections!!
5.0

(7)

Cicero, IN

Recent Review: They were a top notch. Their craftsmanship was excellent. Their crew were very neat and kept the site very clean.
4.8

(16)

Indianapolis, IN

Recent Review: Elite Stucco was great! Their price was very reasonable and they were very professional. They kept the job-site clean and got our repair done quickly. The quality of the work was excellent! Would highly recommend
5.0

(5)

Brownsburg, IN

Angi Certified
Recent Review: It went very well. I very impressed with this Co. owned by Jordan & Alex Smith, I had never worked with a contractor before, we had always done any work ourselves in the past but sad to say I am to old now ( Age 80 ) they removed old ceramic tiles in the kitchen & also put in new underlayment . The new wood floor looks wonderful, I am so pleased how it came out. Alex & Jordan are a joy to work with. I was so happy with there work I will be having them do a remodel in my Master Bath this winter. Mrs. L. Salvo Zionsville, In.
4.8

(175)

Carmel, IN

Recent Review: Ralph Woods was prompt in visiting my home and providing me an estimate to do the work. He indicated he could perform the work on Saturday, April 19. I had a roofing contractor who I had scheduled to start the roof replacement on Monday, April 21. However, it rained on Saturday and, to prevent delay of start of my roof replacement, Ralph and his crew came out Sunday and worked from about 9:00 AM to 4:30 PM. They did a great job on the exterior chimney and replaced the top row of bricks with limestone slabs, used some of those bricks to perform tuck pointing of the chimney, and then grouted the spaces between the chimney flues. They also carefully removed the bricks from the fireplace in the kitchen and also used several of the chimney bricks removed to replace those. They did a great job and I was pleased with their approach and the results. They also cleaned up pretty well when they were done. I had to leave before they were done and Ralph called me that evening to make sure I was satisfied. In addition, the roofing contractor was able to get started on time the next day.
4.6

(22)

Greenfield, IN

Recent Review: Fiano built our space late last summer. Plantings are guaranteed. Norway spruce trees that were planted look bad. One of his employees was dispatched to our home recently to look at and clean up the trees. It was his opinion that day the trees need replaced. Nick Fiano has told me the trees are/will be fine. Nick will not return phone calls. He will not respond to emails. I am disappointed in his professionalism. His follow up is not good.
4.1

(107)

Indianapolis, IN

Recent Review: The quality of the brazilian cherry was amazing! The carpenter who did the work was so accomplished in woodworking. He did an excellent job and was very pleasant to have in our house for a week! The stairs are a conversation piece, they are so pretty. Thanks you!!
4.3

(86)

Indianapolis, IN

Recent Review: I think the design was really good and bad was poor quality work, which I think that they have pretty decent review. I think we just got really bad crew, that came in and some things they forgot to do and I think they came back and fixed so I just feel like the plant installation was poor so may be they could have done was just spend more time planting natural plants they way they had them spaced out and everything was poor. They planted some plants in the lawn area, different species of what they said they were going to do so I guess what they could have done differently is better care installing the plants and following our landscaping better and pay more attention to the landscape design. They still have not responded to couple of things that they need to fixed and I have been in touch with them four times I think since the job was completed about plant that still need to be fixed. They planted the wrong type of bush for among others, it is the wrong species and they keep pushing off saying that they will come out and fix it in the summer, end of the summer and I keep touch in base with them, they responded and but it just didn't get done. I would not use them again.
4.9

(143)

Indianapolis, IN

Angi Certified
Offers Coupon
Recent Review: We moved into our new (existing) home in Sept 2021 and wanted a complete re-do of our fireplace. And a 3rd bay added to our garage for storage space of our lawn and other outdoor equipment. Having contracted Spivey Remodeling in the past at our previous address and being very pleased with their work, we contracted them again for our new home. The old fireplace was stone from top of chimney down to the foundation. The new fireplace is very elegant and a stand out from what it was. The garage addition turned out super! It blends in with the rest of the house and the neighborhood. It looks like it was always there. Thank you to Spivey Remodeling and crew.
4.7

(48)

Indianapolis, IN

Recent Review: My husband called Steve Scully and spoke to his wife on the phone. He explained what we needed and unfortunately they did not offer exactly what we needed, but she discussed many options and was extremely helpful, even though we were not able to hire them. She even recommended someone who could do the service we needed. My husband was very impressed. Hope we can use them in the future!
4.7

(783)

Brownsburg, IN

Angi Certified
Offers Coupon
Recent Review: They come out twice a year to inspect and clean my furnace, air conditioner, and fireplace. I have a service contact on these items. They have been punctual and professional each time. One toilet was replaced and another repaired. Water heater was flushed out. I also called about what I thought was a plumbing issue with the water heater and I was told that it was "to code" and didn't need work. Price listed below is for the toilet purchase and installation.
4.8

(193)

Carmel, IN

Recent Review: VERY PROFESSIONAL, VERY CLEAN, DID AN EXCELLENT JOB. GOOD VALUE FOR THE MONEY.
4.9

(220)

Indianapolis, IN

Recent Review: Godby Hearth & Home have an excellent selection of fireplaces, mantels, fireplace doors and all fireplace accessories, the best in the City we felt. Their showroom is impressive and they maintain books of pictures showing varieties of fireplaces. They were helpful and understood completely when we backed off additional fireplace remodel work, after discovering this type of work is relatively expensive; we were considering a more extensive remodel, but for now decided to stay with new fireplace doors only. It did take two separate visits to get the measurements right and we wish the fireplace door samples available (colors, materials) had been larger to make our decision with, but overall we are very satisfied with the end result. We hope to replace the mantel next year and will feel comfortable dealing with Godby again.

Rate Angi’s Remodel Fireplace in Indianapolis

Featured Rating:
4.7

Remodel Fireplace in Indianapolis are rated 4.7 out of 5 based on 2,243 reviews of the 20 featured Indianapolis pros

The Angi rating for Remodel Fireplace in Indianapolis is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Remodel Fireplace needs. Angi’s review system takes into account ratings on price, quality, timeliness, responsiveness and feedback for Angi Certified Pros.

Frequently Asked Questions & Answers about Remodel Fireplace

What services are related to Remodel Fireplace?

  • Fireplace Companies

  • Plumbers

  • HVAC Contractors

  • Home Remodeling Contractors

What do customers in Indianapolis say about Remodel Fireplace?

We moved into our new (existing) home in Sept 2021 and wanted a complete re-do of our fireplace. And a 3rd bay added to our garage for storage space of our lawn and other outdoor equipment. Having contracted Spivey Remodeling in the past at our previous address and being very pleased with their work, we contracted them again for our new home. The old fireplace was stone from top of chimney down to the foundation. The new fireplace is very elegant and a stand out from what it was. The garage addition turned out super! It blends in with the rest of the house and the neighborhood. It looks like it was always there. Thank you to Spivey Remodeling and crew.